338 réponses à ce sujet

[Solid_Shepard12345]

Positives:



An excellently told story. +2

Had some of the best dialogue in the series and allowed you to reromance Liara. +2

Brought back Liara and gave her lairs of character development. +1

Added to Illium and featured beautiful locations. + 1

Exceptional cutscenes. +2

Had the best bosses in the series. +1

Greatly added to the main story and brought a satisfying conclusion to the Shadow Broker 's story. + 1

The voice acting was exceptional. +1

Featured a good amount of variety. +1.

The missions were structured and designed better than every story in the base game and the plot was far better and, ironically, had more character development (I realise that's because it focused on one character whereas the game focused on twelve but Liara was given more depth than, in my opinion, any character in the main game [except maybe Tali, The Ilusive Man and Mordin]). +3

Featured the incredible dosiers, video footage, opportunities, investments and retrain squad powers. + 3



Total Positives : 18.



Negatives:

You were forced to bring another squad mate who was completely ignored for the duration of the mission. -1

Reused a rogue Spectre (ok, she wasn't rogue but a Spectre trying to kill you was done before). -2

The Shadow Broker's identity was a complete "cop out". -1

Very short. -3.

The chase scene (although a change of pace) was far too easy. -1



Total Negatives: -8.



Total Score: 10/10.



This was, without a doubt, my favourite mission in any game (in any series). Everything about it was exceptional and the few errors are very minor.

[Ulathar]

I'd say....9/10

[Marxman2]

10/10 from me



Only problem i had was it crashed occasionally during conversations. Other than that it was fantastic!

[DigitalMaster37]

ExtremeOne wrote...

Clive Howlitzer wrote...

8/10. My only beef really is the fact my squadmates just stand around like stiffs and aren't involved at all. Especially since I had Tali and Garrus with me the whole time. However, I can understand not paying the VAs to come back.

  


they should have had the squad voices at least a certain few but it seems like it was nothing about getting the voice actors back more of they purposely muted the squad members for the whole Liara Shepard stuff. which smells of fan service to the Liara fans. 

Dude how is that haterade problem working out?

Need some counceling or therapy?

Seriously, get over it, everybody had to deal with the Tali fandom boasting about what they got, so why are you suddenly butthurt?

Relax and enjoy the DLC, no one is asking you to join the Liara fandom, so stop sulking!

[Throw_this_away]

9.7



points lost for a few small graphical glitches. Points won for everything else.

[SCaitan]

9/10



-1 for the upload sharade yesterday. That could have been avoided. The DLC in general is shiny, no crashes and bugs.

[glacier1701]

8/10 - basically the DLC is what BioWare is known for and missed in making the main game. Had it done the storyline/enemies as well as they were done in LotSB then ME2 would have been the perfect game. The DLC loses points because the car chase, while great, should have been more 3 dimensional rather than on a plane and was short. Also the lack of interaction between squadmembers (economics dont make it such a negative as it would have been but still considering how some of the VAs who also voice DA stuff have been used in that it seems a bad choice not to have given them additional lines to voice when coming in for those sessions). Also points lost because of bugs that have appeared in the PC version (sound and loss of picture in particular) which should have been caught since they do seem to be those afflicting large groups rather than unique pieces of hardware.

Provided this level of quality is kept up in the next DLC (of major proportions) we'll have real hope for ME3.

Modifié par glacier1701, 08 septembre 2010 - 07:50 .

[Yeti13]

9 the files at the end are what did it for me, loved the humor bioware

[theelementslayer]

cant say 10/10 because Bioware has to surprise us again. But everything was amazing so Ill say 9.5/10. Cant wait too see what you have next

[darknoon5]

9.5/10, though to make it 10/10 I would need squad mate interaction, however I appreciate that is alot of trouble

Great DLC

[Trintrin86]

darknoon5 wrote...

9.5/10, though to make it 10/10 I would need squad mate interaction, however I appreciate that is alot of trouble
Great DLC

This, particularly interaction if you brought Garrus/Tali along.

[sumof all fear]

10/10, I enjoyed every part of it, expanding the game's already headcrushing depth, liara romance options, the new species. just to name a few.

[Link Ashland 614]

It's a bit long, sorry:



I completely loved it, better than Overlord, and I loved Overlord too (9.5/10) but this had that something that Overlord didnt: Liara.



SPOILER: Never to know who the first SB was, I loved that, aand the Yaght or whatever you write was cool.

I didn't like Liar ending up as the SB; not that I didn't like it, I don't like her there 'cause she may end up evil. I loved that too.

The consoles, dossiers, retrain for sqaudmates and the agent's missions are awesome!

SPOILER END



I really loved it, 1.57 GB worth, every single bit.



10000/10

[Malanek]

9/10. Only downside is that it was a little short and I had a couple of topography glitchs in getting stuck on top of the ship. I would have loved a follow up mission that Liara gives you after the end.



However the story and action was great. The humour was nailed near perfectly plus there was some genuine emotional moments in the story. Having insta-cast singularity and Liara as a playable ME2 companion was pretty cool as well.

[hooahguy]

9/10. As the OP said, it needed to be longer.

[VettoRyouzou]

I give it a 10/10 I mean I guess people could call the shadowbroker a cop out do not being the orginal.. But think about it he still been in power for 60 years cop out or not for as long as your shep been alive he been the SB.

[Persephone]

9/10 Best DLC so far. If only Witch Hunt (Which had so much potenial) could have been half that amazing.

[h_pepon]

Deeper and richer gameplay - this time we did more than "just shooting stuff."

Excellent story, dialogue, and character development.

Superb cutscenes, voice acting, and score.

Interesting level design.

Details such as a new hub, the dosiers, video footage, etc.

Connects or at least starts to connect ME2 with ME3, while providing a satisfying conclusion to the SB chapter.



10/10. There are some minor details, but I couldn't be more pleased actually

[havoc373]

10/10



it was definetly the best DLC thus far. i loved the design of the shadow brokers ship, i'm considering making a model of that once i finish the normandy. (smaller scale though) the car chase was cool. nice change of pase, however it was ****** easy, finished it in one go on insanity. another thing i noticed, the AI seemed to be quite improved for the shadow brokers agents. (might just be me being used to the old content), i also love how it opens up a more enjoyable mission hub, instead of just getting an e-mail from TIMMY.



all in all shadow broker was definetly worth my 10 bucks. More Plz bioware!

[Sailears]

Disclaimer: I loved it, so please don't take this as a harsh criticism.

8/10 If I am nitpicking.

Outstanding DLC. Best by far, so i will only mention the tiny gripes:

Shadow Broker fight was a little silly. I know he's a significant character, so should not be steamrolled like a regular merc, but grinding through those fights just doesn't do it for me. Vasir fight was a little better - at least that had some variety.
Also it's a shame about the lack of dialogue from other squad members (Garrus, Tali etc...).

Everything else - fantastic. The humorous combat banter, the salvaging of Liara's character (from the original state on Illium), the cinematics. Oh, and the dossiers and vids are amazing.

KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!

[NvVanity]

9/10. Overall very solid.





My only gripe is the skycar chase scene. Thats the only time we get to do it. I want to do one again and lets do one on Omega, Citadel, Bekenstein and any other planet!

[Xslient12]

8/10

[archurban]

10/10 !!!



even I can't believe it what I said.



it is 10 times better than overlord, other DLC in other games.

[LadyJaneGrey]

9/10 - and this from someone who wasn't a big Liara fan.

[RyuGuitarFreak]

9 - I found some annoying bugs and the SB battle was too easy. Other than that, everything was GREAT.