123 réponses à ce sujet

[PsyrenY]

TekFanX wrote...

I wish I could have helped matriarch Benezia, instead of her falling to the indoctrination.

The leader of the colonists on Feros(I didn't kill him, but I wish I could have helped him by knocking him out until the Thorian's dead.)

Actually, I forgot both of these as well. Yes, Benezia and Fai Dan deserved to live.

[Mox Ruuga]

Well, it was Lizard Boy who killed her, but I hated that Nassana was character derailed into a psycho and wasted as Thuna's victim in his introduction.

I liked that sneaky asari back in ME1...

[DrSpoonbender]

The manner in which Thane executed Nassana with a shot to the gut staring in her eyes seemed particularly cruel. 

FieryPhoenix7 wrote...

If my memory isn't betraying me, I read somewhere that there was originally something you could say/do to prevent Thane from killing Nassana during his first appearance scene. This was subsequently changed to the current version of that cutscene.

It would have been interesting to see how this alternate scene would have played out.

Tela Vasir proved to be a competent adversary; it was still disconcerting to have Tela bleed to death as Shepard questioned her.

Were there any scruffy looking men that I regretted killing…no.

Modifié par DrSpoonbender, 13 septembre 2010 - 11:43 .

[FlyinElk212]

I know they're the most commonly said, but I have to go with Benezia and Vasir. Those damned Asari and their making me feel bad for them thing.

[packardbell]

Fai Dan

[SnakeStrike8]

packardbell wrote...

Fai Dan

Oh, yes, him. The first playthrough when I got to that scene was especially gut wrenching for me because I'd expended all my grenades by the time I got to the crane controls, leading me to think the scene would play out diffirently if I had some left- maybe my paragon shepard would toss one and save Fai Dan from himself?
Oh, how sad that was...

[Neria Rose]

Saren - loved the character. Hated that he had to go.

The Thorian (yeesh, am I the only one?). - extremely fascinating species, wish we could have learned more.

[Whatever42]

I was a little sad about the Thorian too - but it had to go, sadly.



There are few I regret killing but not much. I don't feel bad about Vasir after just seeing all the bodies she left in her wake. I'd kill her again.

[fongiel24]

Fai Dan was sad, but technically Shepard doesn't kill him. My Shepard won't take responsibility for that one, tragic as it was.

[AresXX7]

Shadow_broker wrote...

Vorcha # 72 of Garrus recruitment

lol
It was a tragic thing for him to share the same fate as the 71 before him. 


I will add Tela Vasir to my list, what a waste of potential.

[OneDrunkMonk]

Benezia and Tela Vasir

[NanQuan]

You know, I can't think of anyone I feel guilty for killing. The only ones that come to mind are Ash/Kaidan and Jentha, but even then, I don't feel guilty and I don't actually wish that I didn't have to kill/sacrifice them.



I would have never made the choice to leave ash or kaidan if the game didn't force me; but I'm glad they did. It's better for the story.



As for Jentha, yeah she was nice to me, but she's still a merc who is trying to kill Garrus (and me). If she didn't want to die then she shouldn't run in front of my gun. Plain and simple.

[casedawgz]

Everyone I've killed has chosen to put themselves in a situation where they are my enemy. While I wouldn't necessarily say I'm proud of killing the average merc grunt, I don't regret any of them. They were shooting at me. I'm better at shooting stuff than they are, and I shot them to death before they could shoot me to death. It's that simple.

[Zan Mura]

Hate is a strong word. But my paragon does feel an amount of regret over Saren and Tela Vasir, among a number of other less significant personalities.

Tela Vasir did what she thought was best, she defended her stand as a champion of the council to the very end. Doing what she had to do to keep the council safe. She wasn't evil per-se, but one of those necessary personalities that are needed in this life of ours, people who don't let morals and ethics blind them to the simple and obvious facts. Except her facts weren't quite as up to date as Shepard's, with regards to the Shadow Broker's motivations and the reality of the impending Reaper invasion. With more information, in another life, Tela Vasir could've been a valuable friend.

Saren even more so. I haven't read the books still, which is something I'm sort of ashamed of, but I retain my right to make estimates of his personality based on ME1. Saren was hailed as a legendary Spectre, also someone to let ends justify the means. Something that Shepard is forced to do on a regular basis as well, although potentially with more compromises. To me, Saren was a great personality. While he started as a one-dimensional evil, the few discussions he had with Shepard over the course of ME1 seemed to show between the lines the reality of his motivations and situation. Saren did what he did to save the galaxy, doing what he believed was ultimately best for all involved. But Sovereign's indoctrination changed and twisted his motivations without him even knowing, killing his own reason and making him blind to what was actually going on.

The scene in the end of ME1 where you have a chance to convince him over what's going on, where he kills himself, was to me an extremely powerful event effectively finally revealing his real character, his real strength. And further emphasizing the great amount of respect he had for Shepard, who was undoubtedly the only person alive Saren felt truly understood the situation. Saren's respect for Shepard grew slowly over the course of the story, but ultimately reached such heights that through her persuation and reasoning, he was forced to realise what Sovereign's indoctrination had done to him. He had so much respect for her achievements that he actually believed her words more than he did his own. And in that single second of mental clarity, he took his own life to buy a mere fleeting chance for Shepard to do what Saren had initially tried to do: to save the council, and the galaxy with it.

To me, Saren died a hero. A tragic hero, and an unsung one. Someone whose deeds even before the events of ME1 were anything but what is typically considered good or acceptable. Someone who did a number of horrible and unforgivable deeds. But a hero of his own kind nevertheless.

Modifié par Zan Mura, 14 septembre 2010 - 07:10 .

[only1sgop]

Kronner wrote...

Tela Vasir

I 2nd that. She was bad ass Also, Saren who was with the dark side but saw the light at the end before saving the Galaxy.

Modifié par only1sgop, 14 septembre 2010 - 08:51 .

[GnusmasTHX]

No one. Though it would've been interesting to see the Thorian, Benezia and Saren live.

[turian councilor Knockout]

Samara and Morinth, depends who you choose.

[Spartindude]

The Thorian, Shadow Broker, Benezia, and NOT KAIDEN! (Never liked him, never will. not enough story with him)

Zan Mura wrote...



To me, Saren died a hero. A tragic hero, and an unsung one. Someone whose deeds even before the events of ME1 were anything but what is typically considered good or acceptable. Someone who did a number of horrible and unforgivable deeds. But a hero of his own kind nevertheless.

Agreed, great job for Bioware for creating an anti-hero.  I origonally hated Saren, I wanted his corpse to rot in the nether realms but instead he fell to our squid-like robot overlords. 

Modifié par Spartindude, 14 septembre 2010 - 09:19 .

[Loain]

Sure I regretted having to kill Fist, Shiala, The Rachni Queen, Rana Thanoptis and Wrex but they all had to die or at least they did in my story's narrative.
I really hated that I didn't get to pull the trigger on Nassana Dantius though.

[Breakdown Boy]

The monkeys on Tuchanka, I can still hear their screams!!!

[Commander Kurt]

Eclipse captain Enyala. That's really the only one, but I havn't played LOTSB yet.

[ValerioN7]

OneDrunkMonk wrote...

Benezia and Tela Vasir

I forgot her:D

So Nassana, Kaidan, Benezia and Tela Vasir.

[Rieverre]

Kate Bowman. Though that was more just me being the cause of her death rather than killing her outright. On the whole, though, the one time I opted to do that quest with the Paragon ending I ended up even more disappointed, walking out of the base and just standing there thinking to myself 'what the hell did I just _do_?' about letting someone like Balak walk.

[Markinator_123]

Regret killing anyone? Absolutely not! Everybody I killed had it coming! I feel no regrets whatsoever. I am disappointed in you Bioware board, feeling sorry for fictional characters that oppose you.

Modifié par Markinator_123, 14 septembre 2010 - 11:01 .