Questa discussione ha avuto 1339 risposte

[dawsdgd]

Your honest reason for saving either ashley or Kaiden?

[upsettingshorts]

I save Kaidan, because I think Ashley Williams has a pretty good story arc if she dies on Virmire. She gets to redeem her family name, and posthumously earns medals from - well - every race out there practically, according to the news in ME2. I highly doubt any future Williamses would have any problem advancing in the Systems Alliance military. It seems - for a character that loves poetry - a poetic way to die. Especially if she went down fighting alongside Salarians - so I usually send her with them.



If Kaidan dies on Virmire, if I was reading about his story in a history book - it just doesn't have any punch to it. He's only that guy who died on Virmire when the nuke went off. Maybe human biotics get a better shake, but you could help them out through a sidemission. I just think more needs to happen with Kaidan for him to be interesting.



ManShep or FemShep, Paragon or Renegade - my ME1 Shepard either romances Liara or nobody, so that doesn't come into it.

[greed89]

Kaiden was so bland it actually hurt



hence Ashely lives

[Quaay]

I play an infiltrator so to balance my team I used Kaidan and Wrex always. I never used Ashley in my squad. Kaidan is also my love interest.

[Mark B]

Kaiden always seemed a whiny ****, and I hated that little cut scene when you go over to talk to him.

Modificata da Pacifien, 22 settembre 2010 - 03:22 .

[Bismar09]

I normally send Ashley with the salarians, so I always end up saving her to make sure Kirrahe lives. It also just seems epic to die defending a nuke when it goes off, but thats just my opinion... lol

[Stigandr Ogaefa]

I am always torn between which to kill during my playthroughs because I dislike both of 'em. During my latest playthrough I killed Ashely and Saved Kaiden, because Kaiden seems to be the lesser evil of the two. Kaiden is just a whiner while Ashely is Xenophobic and Religious.

[upsettingshorts]

Stigandr Ogaefa wrote...
 Ashely is Xenophobic and Religious.

/grits teeth

I ought to make a macro for responding to this kind of nonsense.  But I'm too tired to bother now.

[Stigandr Ogaefa]

She may not be very xenophobic and that is not my main reason. The main reason is she believes in a god and I cant stand that in people. Hell, I kill Leliana for the same reason.

[SDCrush]

Stigandr Ogaefa wrote...

She may not be very xenophobic and that is not my main reason. The main reason is she believes in a god and I cant stand that in people. Hell, I kill Leliana for the same reason.

This isn't the right place for me to start a big religious discussion, but I hope you understand how bigoted and smallminded that makes you sound.

As for the original question, I've done a number of ME playthroughs, and I think I saved Ashley all but once.  Kaidan's fairly boring in my opinion, but the main reason is I'm old-fashioned.  What kind of man lets a woman die when he could do something to stop it? (yeah yeah, I know, if I told her she'd shoot me herself:whistle:)

[casedawgz]

I saved Ashley because killing Carth once wasn't enough.

[Gibb_Shepard]

Saved ash because i like her character far more than kaidan.

[Berkilak]

Romanced Ash on a previous playthrough. Never got past Kaidan's Onasi Syndrome.

[Berkilak]

Stigandr Ogaefa wrote...

She may not be very xenophobic and that is not my main reason. The main reason is she believes in a god and I cant stand that in people. Hell, I kill Leliana for the same reason.

I truly hope that you're a 15 year old that is just realizing that they don't need to believe everything their parents say and is overreacting to that realization in a big way before coming to a middling ground later on in life..

 If you are any more physically/socially mature than that... May God have mercy on your soul.

[YR_Lim]

Saved Kaiden and let god save Ashley.

[Kronner]

I usually save Kaidan - superior rank, biotic, open-minded.

Ashley is ordinary soldier with no special abilities, dime a dozen.

[Raygereio]

Kaiden dies, every single time. Why? Because he's Carth Onasi and if someone gives me the oppertunity to blow up Carth with a nuke, I say 'thank you kindly' and take it.

[Axeface]

I saved both through different playthroughs. However If I had to choose I would save Kaiden. I love his character and want him by my side in ME3.

Ash's sacrifice will also clear her family name. It's what she wanted.

[Christmas Ape]

Because I feel something for the character of Gunnery Chief Ashley Williams.

[FROST4584]

I  always save Ashley, because she seemed like a more interesting and complex character. I found Kaiden to be very dull.

Modificata da FROST4584, 12 settembre 2010 - 05:18 .

[General Douchington]

On my Infiltrator(my first, and pretty much primary character) ended saving Ashley on my Insanity run(which is the one I ended up importing into ME2). There's some upsides and downsides to this, for me, anyways:



Pros:

-Slept with her, eh? Eh?

-Girlfriend's gonna get maaad in ME3.



Cons:

-Kaiden was a bro.

-Bros b4 hoes.

-Did I mention kaiden was, like, a bro?

[Boombox]

I usually save Kaidan, depending on the playthrough, he's more useful and I think he has a better back story. I just hate Ashley's snarky comments all the time. I just wanna tell her to shut up everytime she opens her mouth.

[Thiev]

I save Kirrahe

Truly, he was the main factor that decided who lived through Virmire on my first playthrough. It was Kaidan who survived, because I thought he was more suitable to work with aliens.

[BewareTheDrow]

Ashley was pretty much doomed to die the second she started spouting poetry at me. I'm inclined to agree with a previous poster that the "religious" side of her wasn't particularly appealing either. I don't care for religion in life or otherwise, and I don't feel that Ashley being a religious character brought much to make her any less annoying either.

[HTTP 404]

it was her or Kaiden...seriously I would leave both of them. haha. besides at least Ashley had more balls than Kaiden.  I did both for story sakes anyway.  Meeting Kaiden with my Male Shep in 2 was reeally awkward.

Modificata da HTTP 404, 12 settembre 2010 - 06:34 .