15 réponses à ce sujet

[Cypher0020]

After laying down ME1 for months, I picked it up to finish my Maleshep playthrough   and I'm stuck on romance options.... I can't decide....

if I want to be loyal to Ash all the way through..... or skip romance till ME2 for Jack....


Ash.... or Jack....... I can't decide....

Also don't know about who to make the VS.......

[Funkcase]

Whoever you want, why have other people decide? It's you're playthrough, flip a coin if you're having trouble deciding.

[Cypher0020]

well its fun to ask opinions



plus...the romance threads are 100+ pages long... O_o I rarely enter those

[Gibb_Shepard]

O_o.....Jack?



Uhh, i definitely prefer Ash. I like her personality better, she's much more attractive, she's been with you from the start, and she's not a psycho **** who kills for fun. But to each their own.

[Quaay]

You could make 2 different end saves for that character and try both that way. I love Jack but I hear Ash is worth it soooo yea. Same character, 2 different files to import...that's what I vote.

[magelet]

I think Jack is cooler than Ashley, but I haven't done either romance myself.

Ashley is more of a normal person, whereas Jack is....well, not.

[GodWood]

They're both good.

But Jack is better

[Cypher0020]

I could always spare Ash on Virmire and romance Jack.....besides importing a dudeshep... I need that paramour achievement lol

[TheodoricFriede]

Neither are my favorite, but Jack is more acceptable then a pile of irradiated dust...I mean Ashley.

No offense to Ashley's fans of course, i see her appeal, but she just wasn't for me.

[CroGamer002]

Only one of my Shep's will stay loyal to Ashley.
And that one is still in ME1 playthrough and he will be my worst import for ME3( worse from Ecael one)

Modifié par Mesina2, 27 septembre 2010 - 08:01 .

[Gethforceone]

I say Jack, but I'm biased.

[Raanz]

I liked the Ash romance better then Jack's. Jack is a little too dysfunctional for me.

[LessThanKate]

I'm curious about Jack's romance myself; over time I've come to like her a little more, and maybe someday I'll make a second male Shepard and romance her, but character wise I much prefer Ashley. Badass normal over crazy ass

Still, I was a little annoyed that my faithful Shepard couldn't even talk to Jack without her asking if he wanted some (seriously, honey, get over yourself). Told her I wasn't interested, and that was it. Every time I spoke to her again she told me to ****** off. Because men are bad an will hurt you and this is Lifetime.

It's not not entirely fair to hold that against her because most, if not all, the LI characters are that way, but she's...difficult.

[wizardryforever]

As someone who's romanced both several times, I have to say Jack's is very well done, whereas Ashley's pales in comparison to Liara's.  If you see your Shepard as attracted to "broken" women, and he wants to "fix" them, then it goes great with Jack's romance Paragon style.  On the other hand if your Shepard is a bastard who sleeps with everyone he can, Jack's Renegade romance is also pretty good I'm told (never did that, not coldhearted enough).  If you're going for the Paragon playthrough, turn her down the first time she offers to sleep with you ("if this is just about sex, why don't you ****in say so?") with the top option.  If Shepard is just interested in sex, then go for the bottom, "I want you" option.  I'm torn between Jack and Tali for best romance in ME2, and Liara is hands down the best in ME1. IMO.