83 réponses à ce sujet

[skcih-deraj]

I'd pick Ashley Williams.



Sure she'd most likely refuse and would be pissed that I'd even suggest her. But she'd be able to handle it and wouldn't be that bad if you ask me.

[PrinceLionheart]

Samara is already a Justicaar so I'd believe she wouldn't even consider the role since she's so devoted to her own moral code.

For someone able to get the job done; Garrus and Jacob. SB's dossier on Garrus pretty much stated that the only thing keeping Garrus from really excelling is that he's staying in Shepard's Shadow. Jacob already has a lot of experience doing shadow ops from working with both the Corsairs and Cerberus.

[PrinceLionheart]

sagequeen wrote...

jacob seems to much of a follower to me - same problems as kaidan in lacking that charisma, but without the steely resolve that kaidan seems to have (imo, anyhow)

He works out just fine as a squad leader during the suicide mission though. 

[Aedan_Cousland]

Garrus.

Assuming you encouraged him to reapply, he should have been one in ME2. Samara would be a great candidate as well, but as a Justicar I doubt she'd be interested. She'd have to give up one for the other, and she seems far too devoted to her duties as a Justicar to just walk away from it.

The rest can all be easily disqualifed for one reason or another.

Wrex and Grunt wouldn't make good candidates because they are Krogan. As such they aren't exactly diehard Council loyalists, and the Krogan aren't deep thinkers or cunning stategists either.

Liara is the Shadowbroker. Conflict of interest

Ashley is suspicious of aliens & the Council

Kaidan - nothing really special about him

Tali - poor leadership abilities. Quarians are also blacklisted in Council Space

Jacob and Miranda make poor candidates due to previous Cerberus affiliations. Nothing really special about Jacob

Thane is dying.

Jack has the emotional maturity of a 16 year old and is a former pirate and convict.

Legion is a Geth

Zaeed is a mercenary - his loyalities are suspect

Kasumi is a thief - her loyalties are suspect

Morinth - mentally unbalanced

Mordin -  STG background would normally make him a good candidate, but perhaps a little too eccentric

Modifié par Aedan_Cousland, 15 octobre 2010 - 05:20 .

[Christmas Ape]

Garrus, full stop. Hell, a Renegade-guided Garrus even makes the implication he was in the selection process - where Shepard was at the start of Mass Effect, "the first of many missions together" - but decided it was still too much red tape.



He also brings the skills, the psychology, and the vettable background the rest of your crew completely lacks.

[Aedan_Cousland]

Christmas Ape wrote...

He also brings the skills, the psychology, and the vettable background the rest of your crew completely lacks.

Agreed.

Really the only characters besides Garrus with  backgrounds that *might* make them good Spectre candidates are Mordin and Samara. Despite being former STG Mordin however could easily be disqualified due to his eccentricities. He's a little too much a mad scientist. Samara while an excellent candidate on paper, isn't likely to abandon her duties as a Justicar to become a Spectre. And she would have to if she wanted to be a Spectre, as there could be a potential conflict of interest if someone were both a Justicar and a Spectre.

The only character with a legitimate shot at being made a Spectre is Garrus.

Modifié par Aedan_Cousland, 15 octobre 2010 - 04:48 .

[thesolarrock]

kaidan

[Asari]

Aedan_Cousland wrote...

Wrex and Grunt wouldn't make good candidates because they are Krogan. As such they aren't exactly diehard Council loyalists, and the Krogan aren't deep thinkers or cunning stategists either.

That is just racist, I bet council wouldn't want to make them look bad to decline a krogan if he is worth that title

Liara is the Shadowbroker. Conflict of interest

Though they don't have to know that, but I guess it is unlikely that Liara would like to become a Spectre.

Ashley is suspicious of aliens & the Council

Saren hated humans, he just didn't admit it.

Kaidan - nothing really special about him

I hear ya, L2 biotic and we havn't seen him do anything special..just heard though!
*Super-Biotic Kick! KA-POOOW!!*

Jack has the emotional maturity of a 16 year old and is a former pirate and convict.

Made me think of Gears of War for some reason, Marcus Phoenix were also a convict  still hes a hero. But yeah, just think of what she did to that moon.

Zaeed is a mercenary - his loyalities are suspect

Few know that he founded the blue suns and I bet few know that he is a mercenary.. I say why not? As long as hes qualified

Kasumi is a thief - her loyalties are suspect

few knows that as well, her stealth abilities would make her a great spectre, at least thats what I think.

Morinth - mentally unbalanced

Says who?  Bet they don't even know that she is a Ardak-Yakshi or whatever the name of that is.

Mordin -  STG background would normally make him a good candidate, but perhaps a little too eccentric

As for Thane he will prolly die soon, he is very old for his species.. Guess that will stop him from becoming one.


Just remember that Saren went rogue and did not care much for civilians and so did that Asari from latest DLC.


I just get the feeling that the council would accept anyone that can get the job done, do their dirty work.


Shepard became a spectre pretty much because he made it clear that Saren gone rogue, plus they ugh ... Needed...? (as in why not just send another spectre) someone to stop him.


Seems like most of the Spectres work alone, Shepard feels like the only one that is not. Bet Shepard couldn't do this alone

[Barquiel]

Aedan_Cousland wrote...

Morinth - mentally unbalanced

Morinth would be a great spectre...if someone could convince her that crime lords and terrorists are more "interesting" than young artists.