Acharnae wrote...
Also got Yusaris. Seems inferior to the star metal sword I gave Alistair.
Yusaris is a 2-handed sword, whereas Alistair usually fights with a one-handed longsword and a shield (unless you re-specced him using a mod, or just gave him a 2-hander). It's not meant to be end-game like Starfang, it's meant to be a nice early-game bonus since many people do the Broken Circle quest first. You'll almost certainly want to use it for the High Dragon and Flemeth fights though, it's practically meant for those.
There also was a beastmaster dagger with 2 rune slots in a locked chest (maybe randomly generated?), that is nice for a dual weapons rogue.
Yep, the Beastman's Dagger is always there. It's not as good as other endgame daggers though.
Glad you found the quest alright.