402 réponses à ce sujet

[Ryzaki]

tool_bot wrote...

slimgrin wrote...

Meltemph wrote...

I personally did not find Witcher to be anything special in terms of darkness...

The main reason I ended up trying it out, was because I was always hearing how dark it was. I really didn't see it to be any more dark then NWN, DAO, BG, PST, and ect.

I found it more immature then anything(and I'm not just talking about the sex cards). I enjoyed Witcher for what it was, but I never understood the desire for everyone to point out how dark it was.

By all means, tell us what you think a dark rpg is.

From what I remember Digital Devil Saga was pretty dark, although as far as rpgs go I don't know if I'd call any dark. But then again, mt definition of dark doesn't fit well with rpgs as you're character would have to feel weak and vunerable for it to really work.

SMT! I never played DDS.

...Hm...I don't think any of the Persona games were "dark dark" they were more of the light grey I consider DA.

Edit: I'm talking about Persona 2/3/4

I never played the original

Modifié par Ryzaki, 17 octobre 2010 - 04:00 .

[Meltemph]

Oh, or Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Summoner, almost forgot about that one. Would be a toss up.

Modifié par Meltemph, 17 octobre 2010 - 03:59 .

[Addai]

LOLZAO wrote...
Da certainly tried to be a true dark fantasy title but it only made it on some parts like the Bloodmother(not the her appearance ,but the story behind her), the Orzammar king choice, Connor/Isolde choice(if you don´t chose to go to the circle of mages for help) and the dark ritual choice.The other ones there is always a clear good choice ex:Zathrian breaks the curse and tuns out that Lanaya is a very good leader and even keeps the peace wit humans when conflicts flare up or the circle decision if you decide to save the mages nothing happens(to be fair they could transform into abominations/Blood mages later but this never expanded upon not even on the epilogue so i guess nothing ever happens).

I don't see those story lines quite in the same way.  For instance, Lanaya knew about Zathrian and the curse and said nothing, so she's a grey character too.  Sarel also knew.  It was a case of the leaders of the clan using blood magic to perpetrate a fraud on their own people and perpetuate a horrible curse on innocent human beings.  So... yeah.  Kinda dark.  And "saving the Circle" is putting the mages back into prison, only it's now a blood soaked prison.  Honestly I get the impression that some people just haven't really thought about the choices you're given to make.

Da is very good game(one of the best i played thus far),but no it is not a dark fantasy if it is then it is a "low" dark fantasy(if that makes any sense).
 

I thought the argument was that it's actually high fantasy?

Modifié par Addai67, 17 octobre 2010 - 04:09 .