132 réponses à ce sujet

[Reinoc]

Modifié par Reinoc, 14 octobre 2010 - 03:51 .

[ErichHartmann]

Reinoc wrote...

Ha, I'm sure someone will make a slap Bethany mod for DA2.

[Addai]

Maybe your PCs need to take up yoga and learn to relax.

[ChickenDownUnder]

I could live with npcs doing something physically violent to my character if I do something that offends them.



Frankly it is a bit mind-boggling that Alistair lasted as long in my party as he did.

[tmp7704]

Upsettingshorts wrote...

Personally I'd be happy with some kind of way to tell them to quit their ****ing. Even if it had no practical effect - it might even make the issue worse.

But it'd be cathartic.

Isn't the whole "rivalry" path built pretty much on that?

[Zenjamin]

mistaken double post.... sorry.

Modifié par Zenjamin, 14 octobre 2010 - 05:28 .

[Zenjamin]

David Gaider wrote...

Skellimancer wrote...
 Just to let them know we have a disapproval rating too.

If they don't get to slap you, you don't get to slap them. You're not their mother.

But we are the leader of the group. 
They are not on equal footing with me.

People in DAO said way too many stupid things and even questioned direct orders...
I dont want to be a dick about it. But I do want to be a dick to stupid / selfish/ short sited companions (ie: morrigan and Sten)

*ducks shoe*

Please? this wouldnt be that hard to implement.
Let it be like in ME2 (did I really just say that) Where you can interrupt them with an action sequence.
Or even just a unacted option. You get to sellect something like *slaps morrigan*.


You know.... something like that....

Or a spartan kick.
Yaaaaaa. I would really like that.


EDIT:

Reinoc wrote...

This literally got me to LOL in the middle of the library.
Best. Mod. Ever.
I play on the 360. but this makes me want to get da2 for the PC just so someone could mod this in case they made another character who wants to put you down every time you do something nice.

Modifié par Zenjamin, 14 octobre 2010 - 05:29 .

[Patriciachr34]

Slapping will only work if your Hawke is named Larry, and the companions are named Mo and Curly.

[upsettingshorts]

tmp7704 wrote...

Upsettingshorts wrote...

Personally I'd be happy with some kind of way to tell them to quit their ****ing. Even if it had no practical effect - it might even make the issue worse.

But it'd be cathartic.

Isn't the whole "rivalry" path built pretty much on that?

I hope so.

[McCreath]

Face it people. If Bioware didn't allow you to slap Isolde in DA:O, who richly deserves several good hard slaps, they have a thing against slapping in general and it ain't gonna happen.

[Meltemph]

Ya, Isolde gave argument for sacrificing her to save the son, so he could actually be a better well rounded person. I'd be afraid to imagine a mother like that...

[upsettingshorts]

McCreath wrote...

Face it people. If Bioware didn't allow you to slap Isolde in DA:O, who richly deserves several good hard slaps, they have a thing against slapping in general and it ain't gonna happen.

You could have her kill herself in a bloody ritual, I thought that WHO IS THIS MAN, TEAGAN?!

[tmp7704]

Zenjamin wrote...

But we are the leader of the group. 
They are not on equal footing with me.

In most cases you're only a leader because they choose to ask to come along, though. Start getting abusive and see how long that goodwill is going to last.

Not to mention leadership is hardly carte blanche to beat up people. Or at least don't be surprised if some choose to overlook your rank if you try that.

Modifié par tmp7704, 14 octobre 2010 - 06:33 .

[David Gaider]

Zenjamin wrote...
But we are the leader of the group. 
They are not on equal footing with me.

You are their leader because they follow you willingly.

There's already a rivalry path in every DA2's follower relationship that allows you to argue with them. I've no interest in indulging childish player power trips beyond that.

[upsettingshorts]

David Gaider wrote...
There's already a rivalry path in every DA2's follower relationship that allows you to argue with them.

Oh good.  That's good enough for me then.

/pulls ejection-seat cord
//bails out of thread

Edit: Crap, I came back.

Modifié par Upsettingshorts, 14 octobre 2010 - 06:50 .

[Loc'n'lol]

McCreath wrote...

Face it people. If Bioware didn't allow you to slap Isolde in DA:O [...]

I distinctly remember slapping her unconscious with an armored fist.
(Given the circumstances, that was not nearly as enjoyable as it may sound btw)

[Wulfram]

The only occasions it might have actually beeen tempting to use such an option in DA:O were down to writing oversights, rather than actually being the fault of the characters.

[upsettingshorts]

Wulfram wrote...

The only occasions it might have actually beeen tempting to use such an option in DA:O were down to writing oversights, rather than actually being the fault of the characters.

I thought it was the game mechanic that rewarded the player for enthusiastically agreeing with whoever they were talking to - except Sten, which is why I think Sten is awesome.

[Wulfram]

Upsettingshorts wrote...

I thought it was the game mechanic that rewarded the player for enthusiastically agreeing with whoever they were talking to - except Sten, which is why I think Sten is awesome.

I'm mostly thinking of when Wynne effectively asks the CE if they're considering killing their father for a minor stat boost.

edit: Sten is indeed awesome

Modifié par Wulfram, 14 octobre 2010 - 06:58 .

[Zenjamin]

David Gaider wrote...

Zenjamin wrote...
But we are the leader of the group. 
They are not on equal footing with me.

You are their leader because they follow you willingly.

There's already a rivalry path in every DA2's follower relationship that allows you to argue with them. I've no interest in indulging childish player power trips beyond that.

I will be satisfied with that.
Though I think there are situations where it is immoral not to slap an immoral person. 
If im a seargent in the army, and one of my privates suggests torturing a little boy in the courtyard, I would do more then just slap him. 
Sometimes, rightious anger is anything but childish.

[Addai]

Zenjamin wrote...

But we are the leader of the group. 
They are not on equal footing with me.

People in DAO said way too many stupid things and even questioned direct orders...
I dont want to be a dick about it. But I do want to be a dick to stupid / selfish/ short sited companions (ie: morrigan and Sten)

I think you're looking for the Three Stooges sim.

I was going to say "that's over in the console section," but it would get me in trouble.  LOL

[Inside_Joke]

I think I may be one of the few who doesn't like slapping. Or hitting. It just ... seems so wrong *but the murder knife isn't? ya ...* Like silly wrong though. *Like throwing a shoe, who slaps someone?*



I don't know. I mean in ME I punched the reporter and felt so bad *I didn't expect it*. Then I got over it. Then Lance Henrikson told me I was bad and I felt worse



I don't want Mr. Henrikson scolding me again.

[tmp7704]

Inside_Joke wrote...

*Like throwing a shoe, who slaps someone?*

I can see that as companion interaction, now.



Bush disapproves: -10

[Beerfish]

In one of these games I'd like to see the player have to actually pay his companions, at least expense money. It would set up a nice leader vs companions dynamic. Some companions asking for more gold, some getting ticked off if they find out that they are not being paid the same as another.