Aller au contenu

Photo

Questions and Reactions to the DA2 Design Department's Choices, Beginning With "WTF?"


339 réponses à ce sujet

#51
Dave of Canada

Dave of Canada
  • Members
  • 17 484 messages

Felene wrote...

Probably too late to redo all darkspawn model anyway.
Can someone post a picture of the new darkspawn?
I can't remember what they looks like.


For comparison:
Posted Image

turned into:

Posted Image

#52
Mike Laidlaw

Mike Laidlaw
  • BioWare Employees
  • 765 messages

namedforthemoon wrote...

Yes, let's stay on topic. Maybe the Devs can explain the whole darkspawn = "I'll get you, He-Man, and your Battlecat, too!" look.


All classes of darkspawn now look like they are afflicted with the same disease, rather than one group mysteriously turning blue, which is nice. As to why some of them wear coifs, I can only assume it's a comfort thing.

#53
Dave of Canada

Dave of Canada
  • Members
  • 17 484 messages

Mike Laidlaw wrote...

All classes of darkspawn now look like they are afflicted with the same disease, rather than one group mysteriously turning blue, which is nice. As to why some of them wear coifs, I can only assume it's a comfort thing.


Do they always act like Putties from the Power Rangers, though?

#54
ErichHartmann

ErichHartmann
  • Members
  • 4 440 messages
Huh, I must be the only one who likes the new darkspawn design. Doesn't really matter since killing them is enjoyable no matter what they look like. :)

#55
Trumellionaire1

Trumellionaire1
  • Members
  • 54 messages

ErichHartmann wrote...

Huh, I must be the only one who likes the new darkspawn design. Doesn't really matter since killing them is enjoyable no matter what they look like. :)


no no, the devs obviously like it too, or else they wouldnt have changed it.

#56
attend

attend
  • Members
  • 163 messages
[quote]Dave of Canada wrote...

[quote]AlexXIV wrote...
I am having the feeling I am a little bit faster than you today *proud*Posted Image[/quote]

Pft. You can keep being faster than me, the ladies love the slower guy. /flex


Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.... so true!

#57
Dave of Canada

Dave of Canada
  • Members
  • 17 484 messages

ErichHartmann wrote...

Huh, I must be the only one who likes the new darkspawn design. Doesn't really matter since killing them is enjoyable no matter what they look like. :)


I don't mind it, they actually seem like they descended from an infected human but... I just don't like the way they prance around in the footage I've seen.

#58
Maconbar

Maconbar
  • Members
  • 1 821 messages

Dave of Canada wrote...

ErichHartmann wrote...

Huh, I must be the only one who likes the new darkspawn design. Doesn't really matter since killing them is enjoyable no matter what they look like. :)


I don't mind it, they actually seem like they descended from an infected human but... I just don't like the way they prance around in the footage I've seen.


They turned Michael Jackson into a brood mother.

#59
DMC12

DMC12
  • Members
  • 316 messages

Dave of Canada wrote...

ErichHartmann wrote...

Huh, I must be the only one who likes the new darkspawn design. Doesn't really matter since killing them is enjoyable no matter what they look like. :)


I don't mind it, they actually seem like they descended from an infected human but... I just don't like the way they prance around in the footage I've seen.


Their "prancing" is no where near as bad as playing Benny Hill with an Emissary boss, especially since we're apparently able to do a quick sprint or leap into combat.


Edit: The only thing I don't like is that they have sad eyes and their mascara is dripping. If they had lips I think they would be quivering. No one knows what it's like to be the bad man. Behind hurlock eyes...

Modifié par DMC12, 23 octobre 2010 - 12:00 .


#60
Fortlowe

Fortlowe
  • Members
  • 2 555 messages

Dave of Canada wrote...

Felene wrote...

Probably too late to redo all darkspawn model anyway.
Can someone post a picture of the new darkspawn?
I can't remember what they looks like.


For comparison:
Posted Image

turned into:

Posted Image


I doubt that this is close to what the finish product will be. There's no sky, the ground looks untextured, and there's no discernable light source.

#61
Pseudo the Mustachioed

Pseudo the Mustachioed
  • Members
  • 3 900 messages
I was impressed that they chucked the usual fantasy stuff and actually went simpler. Almost... ballsy.

#62
Dave of Canada

Dave of Canada
  • Members
  • 17 484 messages

Fortlowe wrote...

I doubt that this is close to what the finish product will be. There's no sky, the ground looks untextured, and there's no discernable light source.


True, that screenshot is ancient. HOWEVER, the demo version of the Darkspawn still appears roughly the same.

#63
Trumellionaire1

Trumellionaire1
  • Members
  • 54 messages
true, but the finished product is definitely going to be very similar to this

#64
Apollo Starflare

Apollo Starflare
  • Members
  • 3 096 messages

Dave of Canada wrote...

ErichHartmann wrote...

Huh, I must be the only one who likes the new darkspawn design. Doesn't really matter since killing them is enjoyable no matter what they look like. :)


I don't mind it, they actually seem like they descended from an infected human but... I just don't like the way they prance around in the footage I've seen.


I know what you mean, but I will say that the prancing didn't seem as noticable when I played the demo. Not sure if that was just because of me being distracted but it certainly didn't stick out as massively different to DAO when I was engrossed in the game.

But yeah, so far I have no problems with the art direction etc etc. Want to see more upto date screenshots though, the concept art is awesome but it can be misleading - and screenshots have been almost entirely from the Blightlands so far.

I find it exciting knowing how much of the game we know absolutely nothing about actually, I'm still planning on quitting spoilers once I've gotten a feel for what they have in store for us in the bulk of the game.

#65
DMC12

DMC12
  • Members
  • 316 messages

Pseudocognition wrote...

I was impressed that they chucked the usual fantasy stuff and actually went simpler. Almost... ballsy.


*Crosses fingers for giant Terminators as enemies...with lasers...and hookers*

#66
Daerog

Daerog
  • Members
  • 4 857 messages
What I don't like is the uniformity of the darkspawn, from what I've seen from both games so far. I would like it if they mixed up the ones from Origins with the ones from DA2. Could make it so the DA2 kind are "fresh" darkspawn and the Origins kind (due to degrading from the blight/taint) are the "aged" darkspawn. Also, seeing armor from both games all jumbled together will really emphasize the disorganization of the darkspawn and their lack of unity without an archdemon or whatever. Their armor is made by ghouls or special darkspawn, right? No talented smiths like Wade.

I like the blight seeping from the eyes of the DA2 hurlocks. I like the zombie look of the hurlocks in Origins. Haven't seen the genlocks in DA2 yet. Having a DA2 hurlock fighting alongside an Origins hurlock would be neat.

I don't mind the new hurlock look, it adds variety to the looks of darkspawn, and I can imagine the blight eating away at them until they look like Disciples and then hurlocks from Origins. It's like an aging process: ok skin with blight seeping out, more decaying as seen in the disciples, and then complete zombie mode in Origins hurlocks.

#67
Trumellionaire1

Trumellionaire1
  • Members
  • 54 messages

DaerogTheDhampir wrote...

What I don't like is the uniformity of the darkspawn, from what I've seen from both games so far. I would like it if they mixed up the ones from Origins with the ones from DA2. Could make it so the DA2 kind are "fresh" darkspawn and the Origins kind (due to degrading from the blight/taint) are the "aged" darkspawn. Also, seeing armor from both games all jumbled together will really emphasize the disorganization of the darkspawn and their lack of unity without an archdemon or whatever. Their armor is made by ghouls or special darkspawn, right? No talented smiths like Wade.
I like the blight seeping from the eyes of the DA2 hurlocks. I like the zombie look of the hurlocks in Origins. Haven't seen the genlocks in DA2 yet. Having a DA2 hurlock fighting alongside an Origins hurlock would be neat.
I don't mind the new hurlock look, it adds variety to the looks of darkspawn, and I can imagine the blight eating away at them until they look like Disciples and then hurlocks from Origins. It's like an aging process: ok skin with blight seeping out, more decaying as seen in the disciples, and then complete zombie mode in Origins hurlocks.

..what he said

#68
tmp7704

tmp7704
  • Members
  • 11 156 messages

ErichHartmann wrote...

Huh, I must be the only one who likes the new darkspawn design. Doesn't really matter since killing them is enjoyable no matter what they look like. :)

I don't mind them, though it's amusing to see supposedly "tainted and diseased" humanoids sport such perfectly white teeth when the non-diseased originals without taint are on opposite end of the scale, so to speak.
It's the garter belts and stockings on ogres that's killing me. Posted Image

#69
Felene

Felene
  • Members
  • 883 messages

SirOccam wrote...

Felene wrote...

Probably too late to redo all darkspawn model anyway.
Can someone post a picture of the new darkspawn?
I can't remember what they looks like.


*snip*


Thanks SirOccam.

That does kind of looks like Skeletor.

Darkspawn Forge Master must have quit his job.

Modifié par Felene, 23 octobre 2010 - 12:13 .


#70
Pseudo the Mustachioed

Pseudo the Mustachioed
  • Members
  • 3 900 messages

DMC12 wrote...

*Crosses fingers for giant Terminators as enemies...with lasers...and hookers*


The DA2 giant Terminator will poke you to death with its enormous metal origami pauldrons.

Modifié par Pseudocognition, 23 octobre 2010 - 12:16 .


#71
ChickenDownUnder

ChickenDownUnder
  • Members
  • 1 028 messages

deserk wrote...

Is it just me, or does the entire design look far too much like some utterly cliche and stylized anime crap you would see from some mainstream japanese game developers?


I swear I must be the only one here that doesn't scream bloody murder over something not being 100% realistic, cuz that must totally mean it is like anime. Liek totally.

Well, alright, not the only one that thinks so, but I want my turn to be dramatic as well, gosh darn it all.

And what about the combat? How can there be anything tactical from combat which works that quick? At the moment it looks like a mindless one-button-spamming hack and slash Dynasty Warriors rip-off. What about about all those combat effects, those flashing blue circles about? Again, ripping off bloody Dynasty Warriors or some other awful fighting system's effects.

....did the pause button get removed?

And what happened to the Darkspawn? They look ridiculously like some kind ill-designed clown-like Skeletor or some other cartoon villain from the 80s.

Okay I'll give you this one.

I know some people will say "It's not finished", well you can bet that is it is going to be looking something like that, when they are willing to show actual gameplay.

Was a private test demo, or something. Only very special people got to play it... just one of those people were too "special" in head and couldn't keep themselves from revealing it.

Er, well, that's just my impression.

I was honestly much happier about DA2 before seeing that gameplay video. This doesn't even look like a Western RPG, and it bears nothing akin to it's original dark, realistic and relatively earthly style. But this... just loooks wrong and far, far, far too cartoonly/anime stylized.

What's wrong Bioware? Have you flushed out all the good modelers
and artists who helped make the great visual atmosphere and world of
DA1 or are you trying the seemingly common developer practise of
bankruptcy by pushing out originality and creativity, for more money in a
market you have no idea about?

My intent is not to mindlessly
insult Bioware, because they are definitely my most favourite of all
video-game developers, BUT this looks severly different from anything
from the DA 2 I was expecting, which is why it's extremely disappointing
to see a Dragon Age sequel which looks entirely alien from anything
BioWare could have made, and it would be so disappointing to see another
good and stand-out company falter to the low-qualities, cliches and
bland designs of the absolute conventional and uncaring, money-grinding,
creativity-killing video-game companies of today.


o k

Modifié par ChickenDownUnder, 23 octobre 2010 - 12:40 .


#72
namedforthemoon

namedforthemoon
  • Members
  • 2 529 messages
You know, regarding the Darkspawn, we're probably not going to see them that much, anyway, except for in the beginning of the game. Ferelden is tainted with the blight, but not the Free Marches. The blight didn't make it that far, unless it's through the Deep Roads. I'm sure Hawke's story is more about something else than fighting Skeletor... Er, I mean, Darkspawn.

#73
Dave of Canada

Dave of Canada
  • Members
  • 17 484 messages

namedforthemoon wrote...

You know, regarding the Darkspawn, we're probably not going to see them that much, anyway, except for in the beginning of the game. Ferelden is tainted with the blight, but not the Free Marches. The blight didn't make it that far, unless it's through the Deep Roads. I'm sure Hawke's story is more about something else than fighting Skeletor... Er, I mean, Darkspawn.


Some concept art appears to be in the Deep Roads.

#74
namedforthemoon

namedforthemoon
  • Members
  • 2 529 messages

Dave of Canada wrote...

namedforthemoon wrote...

You know, regarding the Darkspawn, we're probably not going to see them that much, anyway, except for in the beginning of the game. Ferelden is tainted with the blight, but not the Free Marches. The blight didn't make it that far, unless it's through the Deep Roads. I'm sure Hawke's story is more about something else than fighting Skeletor... Er, I mean, Darkspawn.


Some concept art appears to be in the Deep Roads.


No, that's not the Deep Roads, that's the hallway. They're going to see the Wizard, where the Qunari will ask for courage, the Dwarf will ask for brains, the ... Whatever that is will ask for a heart, and Hawke just wants to go home, dammit.

#75
Trumellionaire1

Trumellionaire1
  • Members
  • 54 messages

namedforthemoon wrote...

Dave of Canada wrote...

namedforthemoon wrote...

You know, regarding the Darkspawn, we're probably not going to see them that much, anyway, except for in the beginning of the game. Ferelden is tainted with the blight, but not the Free Marches. The blight didn't make it that far, unless it's through the Deep Roads. I'm sure Hawke's story is more about something else than fighting Skeletor... Er, I mean, Darkspawn.


Some concept art appears to be in the Deep Roads.


No, that's not the Deep Roads, that's the hallway. They're going to see the Wizard, where the Qunari will ask for courage, the Dwarf will ask for brains, the ... Whatever that is will ask for a heart, and Hawke just wants to go home, dammit.

pft liek the Qunari need more courage. definitely need a heart though. the dwarves definitely need the brains too lol. as for courage, well the elf will need some of that.