22 réponses à ce sujet

[Dasher10]

Assuming that you didn't kill her on Nodacrux, does anybody want to see her return in ME3?

[Michel1986]

I killed her

[Angel-Shinkiro]

who's doctor ross again?

[Michel1986]

http://masseffect.wi...eni_Corporation

[AntiChri5]

Killed her.

[Sailears]

Meh, not really. Sometimes the interactions are one off, and you never meet that person again. I don't see a compelling reason to revisit every npc that Shepard has met in the course of the last two games.

[Mister Mida]

She pissed me off, just like Bowman did. I rarely let her live.

[Pacifien]

Hey, if "spoilers" is in the title of your post, that's an excellent sign that it doesn't go in the NO SPOILERS forum. So moving to the ME1 forum...

[Dasher10]

She's one NPC that I simply can't bring myself to kill unless I'm playing an ultra-Renegade "kill everyone" playthrough. So they brought some dangerous creatures back. I fail to see how that warrants death. She's been through hell for days becuase you killed the Thorian when she was just doing her job. I take the cash since the Paragon option is lawful stupid and the renegade option is just psychotic.

[MisterDyslexo]

I don't think that the mission is affected by the save transfer, so either choice you make is irrelevant. I just skip it now since its pointless in ME2 & ME3.

[Dasher10]

Yeah, but I'd like to possibly run into her for all of a minute or potentially get an e-mail from her thanking me for showing her mercy.

[Beerfish]

I've killed her every single time no matter if I am renegade or paragon. The only options are to take a bribe or to kill her and she is the ****** that tries to kill you. I don't want to kill her, I just have no choice at all because having her buy me off after making terrible excuses as to what she did just doesn't cut it.

[MisterDyslexo]

I kill her. She's dumb enough to attack the person who just killed all the monsters they couldn't take on. Left me do the math:

-Dr. Ross & Mercs<Thorian Creepers

-Thorian Creepers<CommanderShepard

So by the transitive property:

-Dr. Ross<Commander Shepard

I like to think of her attacking as natural selection-weeding out the undesirables.

Modifié par MisterDyslexo, 24 octobre 2010 - 05:19 .

[Christmas Ape]

The Thorian has left more than enough bodies in its wake, and ExoGeni is already going to get Council and Alliance reaming for hiding it. No point in ruining the careers of, or executing, a few scientists who would up under threat thanks to Thorian magic.

And hey; she'll even pay me for clearing their route out. What's not to like?

[Dasher10]

MisterDyslexo wrote...

I kill her. She's dumb enough to attack the person who just killed all the monsters they couldn't take on. Left me do the math:

-Dr. Ross & Mercs<Thorian Creepers

-Thorian Creepers<CommanderShepard

So by the transitive property:

-Dr. Ross<Commander Shepard

I like to think of her attacking as natural selection-weeding out the undesirables.

It's not so much her attacking you as much as you attacking her and she's defending herself. Plus, you're inadvertantly responsible for her plight. And I still fail to see what's so morally reprehensible about experimenting on nonsentiant creatures. If they were experimenting on turians or asari, I could understand shooting them on principle. Still, what bugged me was that there was no, "Keep the money, you're free to go" option.

[MisterDyslexo]

Dasher10 wrote...

MisterDyslexo wrote...

I kill her. She's dumb enough to attack the person who just killed all the monsters they couldn't take on. Left me do the math:

-Dr. Ross & Mercs<Thorian Creepers

-Thorian Creepers<CommanderShepard

So by the transitive property:

-Dr. Ross<Commander Shepard

I like to think of her attacking as natural selection-weeding out the undesirables.

It's not so much her attacking you as much as you attacking her and she's defending herself. Plus, you're inadvertantly responsible for her plight. And I still fail to see what's so morally reprehensible about experimenting on nonsentiant creatures. If they were experimenting on turians or asari, I could understand shooting them on principle. Still, what bugged me was that there was no, "Keep the money, you're free to go" option.

Its that she is responsible for the deaths of the ExoGeni people who died. She didn't want to answer for what she did. She probably could've gotten off by saying "I was forced by ExoGeni to experiment on monsters. They didn't care if we were safe.", or by ExoGeni buying off some officials to buy off the aforementioned bad publicity. Its not the experiments that were so bad

[caradoc2000]

Dasher10 wrote...

It's not so much her attacking you as much as you attacking her and she's defending herself.

You give her the chance to get arrested and go to jail, which she will not accept. Her getting killed is entirely her choice.

[Virginian]

Killed the skank.

[Beerfish]

Dasher10 wrote...

MisterDyslexo wrote...

I kill her. She's dumb enough to attack the person who just killed all the monsters they couldn't take on. Left me do the math:

-Dr. Ross & Mercs<Thorian Creepers

-Thorian Creepers<CommanderShepard

So by the transitive property:

-Dr. Ross<Commander Shepard

I like to think of her attacking as natural selection-weeding out the undesirables.

It's not so much her attacking you as much as you attacking her and she's defending herself. Plus, you're inadvertantly responsible for her plight. And I still fail to see what's so morally reprehensible about experimenting on nonsentiant creatures. If they were experimenting on turians or asari, I could understand shooting them on principle. Still, what bugged me was that there was no, "Keep the money, you're free to go" option.

Last time I looked I just stood there after saying, 'I'm taking you in.' and her an her cronies grabbed their weapons and she yells 'Kill them'! or something to that effect and they start shooting at me.  She refuses to take any accountability for her actions as the lead scientist.  She also attacks me after I tell her I'm not taking her bribe and she has to be taken to the authorities for a due process trial.

[NipNappy]

Saddness is that i coud not Kill her sooner .... but she did make me smile....

[kdkikos]

Morality......funny thing.
I let her live this time tho.
Im curious if she will be around in mass effect 3.

Modifié par kdkikos, 08 septembre 2012 - 10:49 .

[Staff Cdr Alenko]

kdkikos wrote...

Morality......funny thing.
I let her live this time tho.
Im curious if she will be around in mass effect 3.

You realise you've just necro'd a year old thread, don't you?

<beat>
...
<changes face from scornful to a big smile>

Thank you, now I can post in it

Dasher10 wrote...

She's one NPC that I simply can't bring myself to kill unless I'm playing an ultra-Renegade "kill everyone" playthrough. So they brought some dangerous creatures back. I fail to see how that warrants death. She's been through hell for days becuase you killed the Thorian when she was just doing her job. I take the cash since the Paragon option is lawful stupid and the renegade option is just psychotic.

Really? That's interesting, I always kill her (and I consider myself a full-blown paragon) because she's the one attacking (resisting arrest, my Shepard only tries to bring her in)  and the only alternative is taking a bribe.

Modifié par Staff Lt Alenko, 09 septembre 2012 - 08:56 .