Master Shiori wrote...
It was sickening, especially with Hawke trying to be "nice" when talking to her before that.
I mean, Izzy just fought her way to the Viscount's Keep alone to save Hawke's life and fix her mistakes and Hawke just throws her over to the Qunari like a piece of silver.
It's good to have options in the game, but that's not one I could ever force myself to pick. Even if my Hawke's wasn't all that fond of Isabela, she would at least respect her choice to return with the tome enough to stand up to the Arishok.
Yeah, the picking of nice dialogue lines beforehand made it all worse really. If you choose the aggresive lines the whole thing at least makes sense.
My last run was a rivalry one with Isabela, and even if my Hawke was seriously pissed at Isabela, she pretty much shared Aveline's menatality ("if anyone's gonna kick her ass, it's me"). Turning her over after making up for her mistake was simply too much of a punishement.
It's a good thing that even if you turn her in, Isabela escapes quite quickly. The girl's got skillz.