hoorayforicecream wrote...
Master Shiori wrote...
hoorayforicecream wrote...
Some interesting replies. Do you think the sibling attitude would change based on circle/templar or warden paths?
Carver would definitely be different as a warden. More sure of himself and proud of what he accomplished during his time in the order. Thus less bitter of Hawke.
As a templar, it really depends on whether we're talking about Carver before or after the Final Straw. Before, he'd be his usual bitter self. After, he would be more confident due to having stood up to Meredith and helping Hawke.
Bethany as circle mage would be the same as she was in act 1. Not sure about Warden Bethany, since I never made her join them.
I'm curious why you think that Circle Bethany and Templar Carver wouldn't necessarily grow or change much while in the Gallows. I always thought that their experiences there outside of Hawke's watchful eye is what allowed them to mature more. I thought Hawke, as the overprotective older sister, kind of coddled them.
For Bethany, being in the circle is more about finally being free to use your magic rather then hide it from others. I don't think she ever felt that Hawke was coddling her as much as protecting her from those who'd fear her and try to do her harm simply for being born a mage. She even tells you that her magic is what shapped the lives of her entire family. Her time in the circle make her realize how mages can be mistreated even when in a "safe enviroment" by those who are supposed to watch them and protect them, but she never held the entire templar order or the Chantry responsible for that, just individual templars.
So Beth would definitely have more first hand experience when it comes to mages and how they're perceived and treated, but I don't see it have an effect on her personality. She would, however, be more confident in herself and more likely to speak her mind without fear of revealing her powers, but this would be because of her older sister's status and reputation. Unlike Carver, she never struck me as someone who wants to make a name for herself, just life as normal a life as possible. That's why she's happy for Hawke to get all the attention.
Templar Carver has basicaly traded living in Hawke's shadow for being in Meredith's iron grip. Considering how the knight commander runs the order in Kirkwall, I doubt he'd be able to do much else than follow her orders to the letter and keep his thoughts to himself. Something that he was allowed to express while with Hawke.
Once, he's taken a stand against Meredith, he would finally be free to pursue his own career within the templars or outside the order.