120 réponses à ce sujet

[Phategod1]

Rojahalive wrote...

Let's pretend Bioware was cruel enough to give us real choices that matter, and there were no charm/intimidate get-out-of-jail-free cards in ME2. Which characters would you side with in their respective confrontations, thus likely condemning the other to die?

Miranda or Jack?

Tali or Legion?

And let's make it interesting and pretend Bioware wanted to make it so half your crew would die, and gave everyone a similar choice in some form or another:

Mordin or Grunt?

Jacob or Zaeed?

Garrus or Thane?

Samara or Kasumi?

And just for cruel fun:

Joker or EDI?

Anderson or TIM?

Jack after both LM i feel like I trust Jack more

Legion I find him more fascinating then Tali

Mordin he has a greater ability to help the Krogan then grunt.

Jacob a better soldier but a real people person.

Garrus he still needs guidance and Thanes dieing anyway

Samara shes probably the second character I tryst the most.

Joker I trust flesh over a over groan PC.

Anderson really does this need an explanation.

Modifié par Phategod1, 31 octobre 2010 - 05:54 .

[kalle90]

Miranda

Tali

Mordin

Jacob

Garrus

Samara

Joker

Anderson



... Choice 1 for each...

[snapdragon3]

Jack
Legion
Zaeed
Thane, no wait...Garrus 
Samara
Joker
Anderson

Modifié par snapdragon3, 31 octobre 2010 - 06:05 .

[Erlex]

Daewan wrote...

Miranda (I need those skills)

Paragon: Tali
Renegade: Legion

Mordin (I need those brains)

Zaeed (the Paragon would be really sorry about it, though)

Garrus (hahahahaha, Thane!  Over Garrus?  Hahahahahahhaha!)

Samara (hey, I already killed Jack, I need a powerful biotic)

EDI (well, I kinda need the Normandy to work... and again, the Paragon would feel really guilty about it)

Paragon: Anderson
Renegade: TIM (and he'd be paying for it for the rest of his life!)

I would choose same like you just would choose Joker over Edi i like joker's humor

[djarlaks10]

Miranda



Legion



Mordin



Jacob or Zaeed - would gladly make them both die



Garrus



Kasumi



Joker



TIM

[CalJones]

Miranda or Jack?
That really depends on which character I'm playing. I've got a lot of Shepards. It's about 50/50. If I were Shepard, (and being female and all, I wouldn't be invested in a romance with either) I'd be more inclined to save Miranda. She's not the easiest character to like, but Jack is extremely volatile and I'd be uncomfortable letting her loose on the galaxy post-mission. (A paragon male who romances her has the chance to help her change, but I don't think she'll listen to anyone else). There's also the thing about her degenerative neural condition. Not sure how bad that is, or if it will kill her, but either way, Miranda looks like a safer bet.

Tali or Legion?
I like Legion, but I'd be more inclined to go with Tali, since she's been with me from the start, and there's that loyalty there. However, if Legion could become a sort of geth ambassador, there's a case for saving him/it/them because of the potential for peace with the quarians and an extra force versus the Reapers. I'm not sure if you could get that with Legion gone.

Mordin or Grunt?
Mordin. Yes he's near the end of his life, but he's a brilliant scientist and, at the end of the day, Grunt is just muscle. I don't have any particular love for Grunt and, actually, don't use him much.

Jacob or Zaeed?
Jacob is a good guy, but as a character, he's pretty dull, and I didn't find him all that useful as a squadmate. I rather like Zaeed. But Zaeed is getting close to retirement and Jacob's still in his prime. Neither of them is leaving loved ones, as far as we know. It's a close call and I'm really not sure. At a push I'd save Zaeed but I could be swayed.

Garrus or Thane?
Garrus. Again, he's been with me from the start, and is either my Shepard's BFF or lover. He's also Turian Batman. I like Thane, but he's dying anyway. Even my femShep who romanced Thane would be more inclined to save Garrus. Letting Thane go out heroically instead of suffocating to death from Kepral's Syndrome would be a better story arc for him anyway.

Samara or Kasumi?
Kasumi. I liked her. Samara is nearly a thousand years old, she's lived a full life and has taken care of Morinth. Living with that won't be easy. I don't think she'd have a problem with sacrificing herself for the greater good. Kasumi is still young and has a lot of life left to live.

Joker or EDI?
Joker. I'm sure EDI has backups, anyway.

Anderson or TIM?
TIM is a dodgy character but who knows, he could be the only one with the wherewithal to stop the Reapers. But I'd be more inclined to save Anderson. More data required!

[Kronner]

Miranda or Jack?
Miranda, I like her better. Jack is a psycho.

Tali or Legion?
Legion easily. I do not like quarians at all. And Tali is just annoying imho.

Mordin or Grunt?
A tough one. I'd probably side with Grunt.

Jacob or Zaeed?
That depends. I like Zaeed better, but he can act stupid at times (ie his LM). Jacob is boring, but he is more stable and seems to get along with anyone. So Jacob it is.

Garrus or Thane?
Tough choice again. Probably Thane.

Samara or Kasumi?
Samara, she is a lot more powerful and I like her better.

Joker or EDI?
EDI. Joker can be replaced, EDI is one of a kind.

Anderson or TIM?
TIM because he is more important.
Anderson has crush on Kahlee and that made him do some stupid stuff. But I like Anderson better.

Modifié par Kronner, 31 octobre 2010 - 06:41 .

[FEC4x]

Jack

Tali

Mordin (This one is tough for me)

Jacob

Garrus

Don't have Kasumi

Joker

Anderson

[Phaedon]

Rojahalive wrote...
Miranda or Jack?
Miranda probably.

Tali or Legion?
Tali

Mordin or Grunt?
Can't pick.

Jacob or Zaeed?
Zaeed

Garrus or Thane?
Garrus

Samara or Kasumi?
Tough choice...probably Samara.

Joker or EDI?
Joker.

Anderson or TIM?
Easy one. Anderson.

[Tasha vas Nar Rayya]

Miranda just moans about how her 'perfect genetics' isn't good enough for her, whereas Jack has fought for a life, so def Jack.



As interesting as Legion is, Tali has that enthusiasm that the team needs, she also sounds like a female Zevran (anyone else noticed that?)



Grunt's abilities aren't amazing, and Mordin has got some of the best lines in the game (including his *ahem* sexual advice.)



Jacob is the most dull character in the game. Sorry, but he is. Even though Zaeed isn't great, he wins over Jacob.



Garrus and Thane are both the ones I always take on missions! Thane is a fascinating and multi - layer character. But Garrus has developed and matured from ME1 and he is pretty damn cool in every way. Also, he's my headbump partner, so Garrus it is!



I like Samara, but even though it's her character, she is very cold and emotionless. Kasumi wins, because I'm an adept, so I don't need lots more biotics.



Joker makes bad jokes, he's a bit mad and a little vain. Very much like me, so I have to choose him over EDI.



Anderson's your very typical navy commander, right to the voice. TIM is fascinating, but I went against him every step of the way, because aliens have as much right for 'dominance' as humans do. They're all jerks and saints just like us in the end!

[mineralica]

Miranda or Jack?

Very hard choice. I'm with Jack because of hope on her stability



Tali or Legion?

Legion. There are only two quarians whose judgement I trust. Tali is frequently overreacted, so entire situation is her fault.



Mordin or Grunt?

Mordin. Easy one. Grunt is too aggressive and careless to me.



Jacob or Zaeed?

Zaeed, he's like my Shep's dad. Never liked Jacob.



Garrus or Thane?

Thane. Because of Garrus'es behaviour in ME2.



Samara or Kasumi?

Samara. Sorry, my most favourite character, but Samara's social role is better for me.



Joker or EDI?

EDI. Don't love characters who are "just for fun" longer than 1 game.



Anderson or TIM?

Dislike them both. May I kill TIM and punch Anderson?

[Haventh]

Miranda (I like her background, Jack comes as annoying to me)

Tali (though choice, but i like Tali more as a character)

Grunt (i can't say no to my loyal krogan, who considers my Shepard his battlemaster..)

Zaeed (easy choice)

Garrus (Thane will die anyways, no? And i like Garrus more)

Kasumi (I got a thing for Japanese women)

I want both Joker and EDI, their talks are so hilarious, don't deny me that joy Bioware..

Anderson (Even though i think TIM knows when to take action, he is also all interested in power, at least it seem that way to me, and TIM tends to become very obsessive, i would call him insane, and unstable. Anderson has a more healthy view on human advancement, advance, but get along with other races,)

[Gogo1]

Miranda (I just do not like Jack at all, plus Miranda has a more interesting background)

Legion (I love sharpshooters / assassins)

Grunt (Cause he's krogan, and krogan are awesome)

Zaeed (Don't like Jacob, lol)

Thane (Again; sharpshooters / assassins are awesome in my book)

Skip (Don't have Kasumi)

Joker (Because he's human, and Shepard has a background with him from ME1)

TIM (I like how he's mystic, and I want to find out more about him)

[Eag07]

Jack

Legion

Mordin

Zaeed

Garrus

Samara

Joker

Anderson


No hesitation here.

[Collider]

Miranda
Tali
Mordin
Jacob
Garrus
Kasumi
Joker
Anderson

Only one I hesitated on was Samara vs. Kasumi.

Modifié par Collider, 31 octobre 2010 - 11:20 .

[Icinix]

All of these were tough...



Jack.

Tali.

Mordin.

Jacob.

Garrus.

Samara.

EDI.



...except for this one.

Anderson.

[Locutus_of_BORG]

No stipulations stated, so I will assume that I get to choose the circumstances of and surrounding the deaths.

Miranda or Jack?
Miranda. Jack is a psycho. Miranda also has more 'personality'

Tali or Legion?
Tali. With Legion, they can rebuild him. They have the technology. They can make him better than he was before.

Mordin or Grunt?
Really tough. Grunt's a baby, while Mordin's an interesting old man. Don't want to be called a baby-killer tho.

Jacob or Zaeed?
Zaeed has a personality/soul, while Jacob gets along with everyone other than Thane. I suspect Jacob may actually be a robot/cilon... so Zaeed, since we could probably rebuild Jacob.

Garrus or Thane?
Thane, because he's found peace. Garrus needs a girlfriend. As his captain/surrogate-dad, I'm obliged to find him one.

Samara or Kasumi?
Tough. Samara is almost 1k yrs old, while Kasumi is probably just living out her prime years... Then again, Samara is like a super-milf. 

Joker or EDI?
Joker. See Tali and Legion.

Anderson or TIM?
Anderson - he's not gonna get home free that easy. Also, I would love to see the look on TIM's face when his money can no longer save him. Then I will rebuild and enslave him because he is a robot.

Modifié par Locutus_of_BORG, 31 octobre 2010 - 11:34 .

[Unwise Wisdom]

Miranda

Tali - As much as I like Legion, it's a machine, not a person.

Grunt - I like Mordin, but he's so old that ensuring his safety won't give him that much extra time.

Jacob - Never liked Zaeed.

Garrus - I'm secretly in love with Garrus and Thane is going to die anyway.

Samara - I don't even have Kasumi

Joker - EDI isn't a person.

Anderson - I actually wouldn't mind killing TIM myself.

[Rojahalive]

Wow, I'm surprised by most of these answers. I really didn't think Jacob or Grunt would be popular at all. Not surprised by Tali and Garrus popularity, but expected Legion and Thane to do better.

As for myself...
Jack
Legion
Mordin
Zaeed
Garrus
Samara
Joker
TIM

Kappa Neko wrote...

Yep, pretty easy:
Jack, Tali, Mordin, Jacob, Garrus, skip (don't have Kazumi either), Joker, Anderson.

Why not make it more interesting:
Garrus or Tali
Miranda or Samara
Legion or Grunt
Jack or Thane
Mordin or Joker
Kazumi or Zaeed
Jacob or TIM
ok, EDI or Anderson is stupid...

I actually found these pretty easy. To each their own, though.

I'd go with...
Garrus
Miranda
Legion
Jack
 Mordin
Zaeed
TIM
Anderson

Not a fan of Tali, Grunt, and Jacob. Not fan of EDI and Anderson either though I love their voice actors. I like Thane and Kasumi, but they are easily cast away in either set of choices simply because the alternatives are better. I am a huge fan of TIM, Mordin, Joker, Garrus, and Legion.

I wish ME2 had elevator convos, and more squad banter in general, just because I think Miranda + Jack would be the best lulz... ME2 had a lot of potential for interesting conversations since the squad was so diverse.

Modifié par Rojahalive, 01 novembre 2010 - 12:35 .

[Mars Nova]

Jack: What happened to her was inexcusable, and Miranda is wrong to simply brush it off by saying "it wasn't really Cerberus," much less insult her by saying that she was obviously a mistake.

Tali: When Legion agreed to join me, he agreed to serve under my command.  And I won't have my crew members going behind each other's backs to steal classified information.

As to the others, it would depend on what exactly their confrontation is about.

[s0meguy6665]

Miranda

Legion

Hard one.... Mordin probably

Jacob

Garrus

Samara

EDI

Anderson hands down

[Manic Sheep]

Based on who I want to keep or who I would actually side with?

Jack, although she is in the wrong for confronting Miranda in her room like that in the first place.

Tali, I understand legions position and I sympathize with him but a war is the last thing needed right now.

Others I’ll just pick who I like best since the confrontation didn’t actual happen.

Mordin

Uhhhhhhhhhh Zaeed

Garrus

Samara...I don’t have kasumi so I don’t really know anything about her anyway

Joker, he’s ma bro

Anderson

[Annihilator27]

Grunt

Zaeed

Garrus

Samara

Joker

Anderson

[Hyper_gateway]

Jack

Tali
--------

Grunt

Jacob

Garrus

Samara
-----------

Joker

Anderson

[Reaper27]

Miranda or Jack?
Jack (Nothing personal, I just like Jack more)

Tali or Legion?
Legion (Nothing against Tali but I don't like her anywhere near as much as Legion)

Mordin or Grunt?
Mordin (Tough choice)

Jacob or Zaeed?
Zaeed (Nothing personal Jacob)

Garrus or Thane?
Garrus (Ouch. By far the hardest choice here. I mainly chose Garrus because Thane is dying anyway)

Samara or Kasumi?
Samara (Samara is just more useful and Kasumi is a criminal anyway)

And just for cruel fun:

Joker or EDI?
Joker (Kill Seth Green? No way)

Anderson or TIM?
Anderson (He was Shepard's mentor)