120 réponses à ce sujet

[Darthnemesis2]

Rojahalive wrote...

Let's pretend Bioware was cruel enough to give us real choices that matter, and there were no charm/intimidate get-out-of-jail-free cards in ME2. Which characters would you side with in their respective confrontations, thus likely condemning the other to die?

Miranda or Jack?

Tali or Legion?

And let's make it interesting and pretend Bioware wanted to make it so half your crew would die, and gave everyone a similar choice in some form or another:

Mordin or Grunt?

Jacob or Zaeed?

Garrus or Thane?

Samara or Kasumi?

And just for cruel fun:

Joker or EDI?

Anderson or TIM?

Jack
Legion
Mordin
Jacob
Garrus
Kasumi
EDI
Anderson

[Deturis90]

Miranda
Tali
Mordin
Zaeed
Garrus
Samara
- - - 
Joker
Anderson
 

[UltraBoy360]

Can I throw in an additional choice here? It's something I thought may happen in ME2 - it didn't, but it's still theoretically possible (though unlikely) for DLC or ME3.



What if Wrex discovered Mordin's role in sustaining the Genophage. He demands that Shepard hand the scientist over to face Krogan justice. If not - Shepard loses Wrex's friendship, and possibly an ally against the Reapers.



If he does hand Mordin over - of course the Salarians would be furious and again, possible loss of an ally and a Council member species as well. What would you do?



This would have been the best and toughest choice for me in any Bioware game; Wrex and Mordin are two of my absolute favourite video game characters.

[Ashii6]

Jack ( I like both, Jack and Miranda, but... Jack is very specific )
Legion ( Legion > Tali. I didn't like her anyway. )
Mordin ( I'd rather Wrex than Grunt. Mordin is the best salarian I've ever met so far. )
Zaeed ( Jacob is man without personality )
Garrus ( It doesn't matter for me ( but for my Shep does ). But Thane is going to die in the end )
Kasumi ( The same situation as with Jack and Miri. )
Joker ( Mkey, it's weird. EDI is not a living creature.. She has only interface )
Anderson ( TIM - go to hell )

Modifié par Ashii6, 03 novembre 2010 - 10:56 .

[CalJones]

@UltraBoy - that's a horrible decision. However, if the Urdnot Torsk videos you see in LotSB are typical of krogan justice, there's not a chance in hell I'd hand Mordin over. He might be old and near the end of his life but I wouldn't betray a friend that way. Especially not one who sings Gilbert and Sullivan.

[LordPennlocke]

Miranda

Tali

Mordin

Jacob

Garrus

Samara

Joker

Anderson

[anmiro]

 Jack.

Tali. I am more sympathetic to the Geth and Legion than I am the Quarians. But if I have to choose between killing a machine and Tali, its the machine.

Mordin.

Jacob.

Garrus.

Kasumi or Samara? I wish there was more context for why they were at odds with each other. If I had to choose it would be Kasumi. I like Samara more, but she has already had a long life by human standards. Kasumi is still young.

Joker. AI' are dangerous.

Anderson. No contest.

[Noristias]

Miranda (she saved our live, anyway)
Tali (Legion > Tali. I hate her, she might be useful in ME3 ;p)
Mordin (because i like him.)
Jacob (this is difficult, because I don't like both of them)
Garrus
Kasumi (great personality - I support her for ME3)
Joker (no comment ;p)
Anderson (TIM? Haha!)

Modifié par Noristias, 03 novembre 2010 - 11:11 .

[Chignon]

Jack

Legion

Mordin

Zaeed

Thane

Samara

Joker

Anderson

[Ryzaki]

Rojahalive wrote...

Let's pretend Bioware was cruel enough to give us real choices that matter, and there were no charm/intimidate get-out-of-jail-free cards in ME2. Which characters would you side with in their respective confrontations, thus likely condemning the other to die?

Miranda or Jack?

Tali or Legion?

And let's make it interesting and pretend Bioware wanted to make it so half your crew would die, and gave everyone a similar choice in some form or another:

Mordin or Grunt?

Jacob or Zaeed?

Garrus or Thane?

Samara or Kasumi?

And just for cruel fun:

Joker or EDI?

Anderson or TIM?

Miranda
Legion
Mordin
Jacob
Garrus
Samara
EDI
Anderson

[UltraBoy360]

CalJones wrote...

@UltraBoy - that's a horrible decision. However, if the Urdnot Torsk videos you see in LotSB are typical of krogan justice, there's not a chance in hell I'd hand Mordin over. He might be old and near the end of his life but I wouldn't betray a friend that way. Especially not one who sings Gilbert and Sullivan.

Ouch. I'd forgotten about Urdnot Torsk. Yeah, I agree, I wouldn't hand him over either. As I was on the way to Tuchanka on my first playthrough - I was sure that was what was going to happen. I was relieved/slightly disappointed it didn't. Imagine Wrex disappointed in you - it'd kill my Shepard.

[Cerberus Operative Ashley Williams]

Miranda (Jack is unstable)

Tali (organic > sentient robot I'm sorry, plus she was a ME1 squadmate)

Mordin (who's going to run the tech lab?)

Jacob (I can trust him far more than Zaeed)

Garrus (Thane will die soon anyway, also gotta stick with my ME1 homies)

Samara (she has nearly unmatched honor, plus Kasumi is a thief)

Joker [again he's from ME1 and organics (especially humans) > sentient technology]

TIM (sorry Anderson I love you but you don't have what it takes to get what needs to be done done)

[ShadyKat]

Rojahalive wrote...

Let's pretend Bioware was cruel enough to give us real choices that matter, and there were no charm/intimidate get-out-of-jail-free cards in ME2. Which characters would you side with in their respective confrontations, thus likely condemning the other to die?

Miranda or Jack?

Tali or Legion?

And let's make it interesting and pretend Bioware wanted to make it so half your crew would die, and gave everyone a similar choice in some form or another:

Mordin or Grunt?

Jacob or Zaeed?

Garrus or Thane?

Samara or Kasumi?

And just for cruel fun:

Joker or EDI?

Anderson or TIM?

This is actually very easy for me
Miranda
Tali(Not even close, and Legion is just a machine).
Mordin
Jacob
Garrus (not even close)
Kasumi
Joker
Anderson (not even close)

Modifié par ShadyKat, 04 novembre 2010 - 03:21 .

[Dean_the_Young]

Reasons, people, reasons!



No one else is interested in mere lists. Talk about your choices,and the choices of others!

[Xallah]

Miranda (don't really know why, but I choose Miranda)

Tali (She's so cute, besides she was my typical companion in Mass Effect 1)

Grunt (Can't choose really. I genereally hate salarians and love krogans, but Mordin is so cool, and Grunt has nothing really special about him, except the blue eyes. If we were talking about Wrex... damn, why no romance with him? ( )

Zaeed (brutal scars rock ))) )

Thane (So romantic, so suffering, definitely Thane. Besides I never really liked Garrus, neither his personaly, nor looks. There so many really beautiful and bright turians, why are we stuck with him? The easiest choice for me)

Kasumi (another hard one, but... ahhh... Kasumi)

Joker (as someone said before, no ME without Joker!)

TIM (one morer hard one, but TIM)

[HappyHappyJoyJoy]

From a personal perspective:
Miranda - I like her better than Jack, the latter is too uncontrolled
Tali - we've been together for ages, I stay loyal
Mordin - brilliant person and the reason we aren't toast to the swarms.  I like talking to Mordin, I rarely go venture to see Grunt unless I need his loyalty mission or paragon/renegade points badly.
Jacob - better person overall.
Garrus - same as Tali
Samara - I find her fascinating.  Kusumi is just a master thief, there are more out there I don't know about
Joker - same as Tali
Anderson - does this need an explanation?


From a game perspective:
Miranda - more useful in most situations.  Unless I am a Sentinel, in which case it's Jack.
Legion - also more useful and doesn't "die" in combat as often.
Grunt - much more useful in combat.  I rarely bring Mordin along.
Zaeed - disruptor ammo > "this'll take the heat off!"  Even if my class has access to disruptor, Zaeed is a tank.
Thane - rare quality of biotics and long-range touch with the sniper rifle. 
Samara - need someone to hold up that biotic shield.  Also has Reave.
(rest of choices don't matter)
I'd take Legion and Thane with me to go kill the proto-Reaper.

[2A92 Legion]

Jack (don't like her but she's not Cerberus operative)
Legion (We are Legion so...)
Grunt (could use extra firepower:D)
Zaeed (Go to hell Jacob! - at last)
Garrus (Ol' times man...)
Kasumi (Great thief;P)
Joker? EDI? Its like pilot or ship! Makes no sense!
Anderson! (TIM - bite my shinny metal ass goodbye!)
@Ash: Very sexy interface...

Modifié par KKs_45, 04 novembre 2010 - 03:58 .

[Ashii6]

KKs_45 wrote...

@Ash: Very sexy interface...

If you say so..

[Anakin1000]

In my final walkthrough (save for me3) i killed:
-Jack - she's so damn annoying
-Jacob - Miranda is mine!
-Tali - haters will hate
-Grunt - i don't like stupid krogans
-Samara - i hate good-good-only good paladins 
-Mordin - i don't know exactly why 
also didn't recruith both Zaeed and Kasumi - this DLC guys just don't fit to Mass effect Universe in my opinion
i don't get suicide mission with no victims so i had to kill some (most) of them 
Poor Hawke and his family in DA2 

Modifié par Anakin1000, 04 novembre 2010 - 06:46 .

[Zack56]

Rojahalive wrote...

Miranda or Jack?

Tali or Legion?

Mordin or Grunt?

Jacob or Zaeed?

Garrus or Thane?

Samara or Kasumi?

And just for cruel fun:

Joker or EDI?

Anderson or TIM?

Miranda (controling sure but not crazy)

That's a hard one... Tali

Mordin (more to to talk about than Grunt)

Easy, Zaeed

Garrus (been through a lot with him)

Kasumi (She is actually fun to talk with)

I can't choose between Joker and EDI! That's just cruel!

Anderson (star of 3 books and I wanted to kick TIM out the airlock when I first saw him)

[ThisIsMadness91]

All too easy...Jack, Tali, Mordin, Jacob, Garrus, Kasumi, Joker, Anderson.