1770 réponses à ce sujet

[Crimson-Cobalt]

Jesse Houston wrote...


 This interactive comic's initial release will be exclusive to PS3 owners who would be otherwise unable to realize the full effect of choice in the Mass Effect universe and will be included on the Cerberus Network.

The comic isn't exclusive,it's just being released on the PS3 first.Lets all stop arguing about which version is better.

Modifié par Crimson-Cobalt, 14 novembre 2010 - 06:49 .

[Lard]

Skilled Seeker wrote...
The comic contains the same story as the game. It is comparable.

So you know for certain the comic is going to contain *all* of the same story elements as the full game? People are already guessing that there are certain elements that are going to be removed from the comic because of space.
It's not the same experience and not the same content.

Jesse Houston wrote...
We've talked briefly about the
Interactive Comic.  BioWare Edmonton (the group that made Mass Effect 2)
teamed up with the fine folks at Dark Horse Comics to create an
interactive backstory.  While I can't release all the details about this
yet, what I can tell you is that we want to create a stunning visual
experience that not only tells the core story elements of  Mass Effect
1, but also is fully interactive allowing you to be faced with some of
the major choices which will have consequences your Mass Effect
universe. 

The important word being "core". It's not going to contain the full content from the game.

Modifié par Lard, 14 novembre 2010 - 06:49 .

[durasteel]

Lard wrote...

Ahhhh so your personal collection is important enough to shaft PS3 owners.

No, the PS3 owners would still get the comic.  If everyone gets the comic, then no one gets the shaft, see?

Yes, yes, the PS3 owners got the shaft years ago by being excluded from ME1.  We all agree that was bad, but it is no reason to shaft PC and 360 owners today.

And please, don't come back with that "you don't need it" rhetoric.  We don't any of us need these video games, at all.  We want them.  We need to mow the lawn, hit the gym, buy our wives Christmas presents, etc.  This is not now, nor will it ever be, a legitimate conversation about need.

[Skilled Seeker]

Lard wrote...

Skilled Seeker wrote...
The comic contains the same story as the game. It is comparable.

So you know for certain the comic is going to contain *all* of the same story elements as the full game? People are already guessing that there are certain elements that are going to be removed from the comic because of space.
It's not the same experience and not the same content.

Great, reason enough to want it then.

I will repeat...

PS3 owners wont get shafted if the comic comes out on PC/360. It doesn't make any different to them. Only a jealous sadistic mentally challenged person would want to punish us for something that is out of our control.

[gethslayer7]

Skilled Seeker wrote...

Lard wrote...

Skilled Seeker wrote...

Its not about knowing the story. Its about experiencing it in comic form. For example I watched Monsters Inc the movie. That didn't stop me from buying the novel. The novel is based on the movie and is a 'less than full experience' as you say. But its a different media and reading Monsters Inc is enjoyable in its own way. Same with the comic in this case..

A novel and a movie both contain the same "amount" of content - that is contain the same story.

A video game and a comic are not comparable - apples and oranges. Completely different.

The comic contains the same story as the game. It is comparable.

skilled seeker have you realised lard id the one saying its not comparible but how woud he know he hasnt got the game

[Lard]

Vurtax wrote...

You don't get it, the bottom line is we're avid fans that want to get our hands on everything that deals with Mass Effect. And the fact the comic will never be coming to PC and 360 is upsetting because its like Bioware turning their back on their pre-established fanbase for a potential fanbase. Considering it's a million times easier to code content for the PC and 360 than it is the Ps3. It doesn't make sense why we aren't getting it.

So what? There are rabid fans on the PS3 who want ME1.

And ME2 is the second game in a series - it doesn't make sense that we're not getting the first game.

This is totally half-assed on the part of Bioware.

Modifié par Lard, 14 novembre 2010 - 06:52 .

[Ryzaki]

Well I do and no it won't

[durasteel]

Lard wrote...

A novel and a movie both contain the same "amount" of content - that is contain the same story.

A video game and a comic are not comparable - apples and oranges. Completely different.

I think the producers and directors of Hellboy, 300, The Watchmen, and dozens of Batman and Superman movies would all disagree with you.

[gethslayer7]

lard look at it this way what if mass effect was a ps3 exclusive but then you found out we were getting a comic u woudent like it

[10 Steps Back]

durasteel wrote...

Lard wrote...

Ahhhh so your personal collection is important enough to shaft PS3 owners.

Yes, yes, the PS3 owners got the shaft years ago by being excluded from ME1.  We all agree that was bad, but it is no reason to shaft PC and 360 owners today.

Agreed as said before two wrongs do no make a right

[Lard]

durasteel wrote...

No, the PS3 owners would still get the comic.  If everyone gets the comic, then no one gets the shaft, see?

Yes, yes, the PS3 owners got the shaft years ago by being excluded from ME1.  We all agree that was bad, but it is no reason to shaft PC and 360 owners today.

So as long as only PS3 owners get shafted, it's all right? 

Great argument.

[gethslayer7]

Lard wrote...

Vurtax wrote...

You don't get it, the bottom line is we're avid fans that want to get our hands on everything that deals with Mass Effect. And the fact the comic will never be coming to PC and 360 is upsetting because its like Bioware turning their back on their pre-established fanbase for a potential fanbase. Considering it's a million times easier to code content for the PC and 360 than it is the Ps3. It doesn't make sense why we aren't getting it.

So what? There are rabid fans on the PS3 who want ME1.

And ME2 is the second game in a series - it doesn't make sense that we're not getting the first game.

This is totally half-assed on the part of Bioware.

dont ever say anything bad about bioware its not thier fault u dont get me1

[Skilled Seeker]

Lard my point is you would consider the book of Monsters Inc inferior to the movie. So will you have a go at me for having both when I don't 'need it' lol. Reading a book is not the same as watching a movie, it is enjoyable in a different way.



Same with the comic, it is a unique enjoyable experience that PC/360 users should get.

[Lard]

gethslayer7 wrote...

lard look at it this way what if mass effect was a ps3 exclusive but then you found out we were getting a comic u woudent like it

I wouldn't care personally, as long as I was getting both games.
But we're *not* getting both games, and 360 owners are whining like we're getting some kind of special treatment, when in reality we're getting shafted.

Skilled Seeker wrote...

Lard my point is you would
consider the book of Monsters Inc inferior to the movie. So will you
have a go at me for having both when I don't 'need it' lol. Reading a
book is not the same as watching a movie, it is enjoyable in a different
way.

Same with the comic, it is a unique enjoyable experience that PC/360 users should get.

Obviously you can't read, because that's not what I said.

I said a novel and the movie are similar because they have the same story content and structure.
This is like having a movie and a kids version of the novel that's 30 pages long. Not the same at all.
ME1 is an experience that PS3 owners should get, but we're not.

Modifié par Lard, 14 novembre 2010 - 06:56 .

[gethslayer7]

Lard wrote...

durasteel wrote...

No, the PS3 owners would still get the comic.  If everyone gets the comic, then no one gets the shaft, see?

Yes, yes, the PS3 owners got the shaft years ago by being excluded from ME1.  We all agree that was bad, but it is no reason to shaft PC and 360 owners today.

So as long as only PS3 owners get shafted, it's all right? 

Great argument.

yep because weve been loyal since me1 u just jumped on the train hhalfway through the journey

[Skilled Seeker]

Lard wrote...

durasteel wrote...

No, the PS3 owners would still get the comic.  If everyone gets the comic, then no one gets the shaft, see?

Yes, yes, the PS3 owners got the shaft years ago by being excluded from ME1.  We all agree that was bad, but it is no reason to shaft PC and 360 owners today.

So as long as only PS3 owners get shafted, it's all right? 

Great argument.

Whats your stance? Lets hurt as many people as possible?

PS3 owners wont get shafted if the comic comes out on PC/360. It doesn't make any different to them. Only a jealous sadistic mentally challenged person would want to punish us for something that is out of our control.

[gethslayer7]

Skilled Seeker wrote...

Lard my point is you would consider the book of Monsters Inc inferior to the movie. So will you have a go at me for having both when I don't 'need it' lol. Reading a book is not the same as watching a movie, it is enjoyable in a different way.

Same with the comic, it is a unique enjoyable experience that PC/360 users should get.

exactly

[charmingcharlie]

Lard wrote...

A novel and a movie both contain the same "amount" of content - that is contain the same story.

A video game and a comic are not comparable - apples and oranges. Completely different.

Erm what ?  I don't know what movies based on books you have seen but in my experience the movie is usually an "abridged" version of the book (oh look that "abridged" word has been used in here).  You usually find a book contains much more detail, I have seen movies based on books that cut out massive chunks of plot to fit the 2 hour time limit for most movies.

Now if I read a book and I like the book, then a movie comes out based on that book naturally I am going to want to see that movie.  Even though the movie will not be as indepth or detailed as the book I will still want to see the movie because it is a new way to experience the story.

In essence what some are saying here is "you read the book and it isn't fair you get to see the movie as well because I can't read the book so only I should have access to the movie".

[Crimson-Cobalt]

durasteel wrote...

Lard wrote...

Ahhhh so your personal collection is important enough to shaft PS3 owners.

No, the PS3 owners would still get the comic.  If everyone gets the comic, then no one gets the shaft, see?

Yes, yes, the PS3 owners got the shaft years ago by being excluded from ME1.  We all agree that was bad, but it is no reason to shaft PC and 360 owners today.

And please, don't come back with that "you don't need it" rhetoric.  We don't any of us need these video games, at all.  We want them.  We need to mow the lawn, hit the gym, buy our wives Christmas presents, etc.  This is not now, nor will it ever be, a legitimate conversation about need.

Agreed,but Bioware never said that Xbox/PC players are not getting the comic.They just said that the comic's initial release will be on the PS3. 

P.S:I can't wait to get my hands on the PS3 version.My Xbox is modded so getting DLC from the Live Marketplace is out of the question.Are the DLC packs a good enough reason to repurchase the game?

Modifié par Crimson-Cobalt, 14 novembre 2010 - 06:59 .

[10 Steps Back]

gethslayer7 wrote...

lard look at it this way what if mass effect was a ps3 exclusive but then you found out we were getting a comic u woudent like it

There is no point in asking questions like this it's not the scenario. In this scenario he is defending the position that the comic should be exclusive because the first was exclusive to the opposite platforms. He could very well say that through all his arguments he believes that this method is fair but in the what if scenario you put how are we to say he actually would say that?

[gethslayer7]

Crimson-Cobalt wrote...

durasteel wrote...

Lard wrote...

Ahhhh so your personal collection is important enough to shaft PS3 owners.

No, the PS3 owners would still get the comic.  If everyone gets the comic, then no one gets the shaft, see?

Yes, yes, the PS3 owners got the shaft years ago by being excluded from ME1.  We all agree that was bad, but it is no reason to shaft PC and 360 owners today.

And please, don't come back with that "you don't need it" rhetoric.  We don't any of us need these video games, at all.  We want them.  We need to mow the lawn, hit the gym, buy our wives Christmas presents, etc.  This is not now, nor will it ever be, a legitimate conversation about need.

Agreed,but Bioware never said that Xbox/PC players are noy getting the comic.They just said that the comic's initial release will be on the PS3. 

P.S:I can't wait to get my hands on the PS3 version.My Xbox is modded so getting DLC frome the Live Marketplace is out of the question.

u havent been able to get dlc im so sorry for u

[Lard]

gethslayer7 wrote...
yep because weve been loyal since me1 u just jumped on the train hhalfway through the journey

This isn't an army, and it's not a government. It's not about "loyalty".

Companies are there to convince me to spend my money on their products.

And I don't want a console that breaks down after 2 weeks.