111 réponses à ce sujet

[AdmiralCheez]

Okay, guys.  I am trying to do a bit of data collection here, and your help would be appreciated.  Here's what I need, for as many saves/Shepards as you want to list:

1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?

2. Who died in Mass Effect 1?  Wrex?  Kaidan?  Ashley? (If you only played ME2, just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)

3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2?  Any DLC characters?  Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?

4. Who was loyal in ME2?

5. Who died?  Include Morinth/Samara.

As an example, here's my own data:

SAVE #1: Everyone recruited in ME1, Kaidan died on Virmire.  Everyone recruited and loyal in ME2, including Kasumi and Zaeed.  Everyone survived.  Chose Samara over Morinth.

SAVE #2: Same as above.

SAVE #3: Same as above, only Ashley died.

Also for the sake of science, please take the time to vote on these three polls.  Sorry to spam you with them, but more data = more accurate predictions.

UPDATE: The data has been compiled, and can be viewed here.

Again, a big whopping thank-you to everyone who participated.

Modifié par AdmiralCheez, 29 novembre 2010 - 06:00 .

[Dave of Canada]

Do you want the first playthrough or the following playthroughs?

[Cra5y Pineapple]

1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?

2. Who died in Mass Effect 1?  Wrex?  Kaidan?  Ashley? (If you only played ME2, just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)

3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2?  Any DLC characters?  Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?

4. Who was loyal in ME2?

5. Who died?  Include Morinth/Samara

1. All of them.

2. Kaidan died due to eeney-meeny-miny-mo.

3. Everybody including DLC.

4. Everybody again.

5. Morinth died but no one else.

Nothing's really changed through my playthroughs. However on my femshep I flipped a coin again to save Kaidan or Ash and I ended up saving Kaidan. I didn't romance him though.

Modifié par Cra5y Pineapple, 22 novembre 2010 - 11:24 .

[AdmiralCheez]

Dave of Canada wrote...

Do you want the first playthrough or the following playthroughs?

As many as you can provide.  I'm looking for overall statistics.  One for each of your Shepards is good.  Most importantly, I need the ones you are considering for import in ME3.

[Zulu_DFA]

Liara, Ashley, Zaeed, Legion, Kasumi, Morinth, Jacob.

[Tyrannosaurus Rex]

perfected playthrough:

Everyone recruited in both games.

ME1: Ashley sacrificed on Virmire.

ME2 KIA on collector base: Jack, Thane.

Loyal ME2 squadmembers: Everyone (including DLC) execpt Jack (sided with Miranda on purpose).
Samara chosen over Morinth.

Modifié par Lizardviking, 22 novembre 2010 - 11:27 .

[Da_Lion_Man]

1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?

Save 1: Everyone
Save 2: Everyone

2. Who died in Mass Effect 1?  Wrex?  Kaidan?  Ashley? (If you only played ME2, just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.

Save 1: Wrex and Ashley
Save 2: Wrex and Ashley

3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2?  Any DLC characters?  Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?

Save 1: Everyone except Kasumi
Save 2: Everyone, Kasumi and Zaeed included

4. Who was loyal in ME2?

Save 1: Everyone but Zaeed
Save 2: Everyone

5. Who died?  Include Morinth/Samara.

Save 1: Morinth, Zaeed and Legion
Save 2: Morinth

[SojournerN7]

1. Everyone Recruited. (Liara first after Citadel)
2. Kaiden died.
3. Everyone, including DLC characters.
4. Everyone was loyal.
5. No one died. Just another day at the office.

[PrinceLionheart]

Everyone except for Kaidan.

[Googlesaurus]

1. Everyone.

2. Kaidan.

3. Everyone excluding DLC characters.

4. Everyone.

5. No one.



With multiple saves, I've saved Kaidan twice and Ashley once.

[ReiSilver]

1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?

everyone



2. Who died in Mass Effect 1? Wrex? Kaidan? Ashley? (If you only played ME2, just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)

Ashley for one Shepard

Kaidan for the other



3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2? Any DLC characters? Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?

Everyone recruited



4. Who was loyal in ME2?

everyone



5. Who died? Include Morinth/Samara.

Morinth died for one Shepard

Samara for the other

[Dave of Canada]

In my first playthrough of Mass Effect, everybody was recruited and Kaidan died. Repeat this for the following 19+ playthroughs afterward and one playthrough where I nuked Ashley instead. I never not-recruited anybody.

In my first playthrough of Mass Effect 2, nobody died. I felt this was a cheap effect for the Suicide Mission and reloaded, intentionally killing people off. There's a few playthroughs where a dozen of people are dead so I can't really list it but the average playthrough that I'm considering to import has: Tali, Samara and Thane dead with Legion sold to Cerberus.

Actually, let me crank out the game and name down a few.
Playthrough: Tali / Samara / Thane dead. No Legion.
Playthrough: Everybody dead but Morinth and Kasumi, using the guide from this forum.
Playthrough: Mordin / Zaeed / Grunt dead.
Playthrough: Jacob dead.

[Exile Isan]

AdmiralCheez wrote...
1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?

2. Who died in Mass Effect 1?  Wrex?  Kaidan?  Ashley? (If you only played ME2, just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)

3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2?  Any DLC characters?  Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?

4. Who was loyal in ME2?

5. Who died?  Include Morinth/Samara.

1. Everyone recruited.
2. Ashley.
3. All characters recruited in my games now (which I plan to import), but on my first few playthroughs I didn't have Kasumi or Zaeed.
4. Everyone.
5. Only Morinth is dead in any of my games.

Modifié par Exile Isan, 22 novembre 2010 - 11:51 .

[luakel]

First playthrough:

1. Everyone recruited who could be.

2. Kaidan died at the nuke, Wrex convinced to stand down.

3. Recruited everyone, only got DLC after finishing the main playthrough though.

4. Everyone except Zaeed... see below.

5. Morinth died in Samara's loyalty mission, everyone (including crew) made it through the Collector base, Zaeed left to burn after the main storyline was done.

Used the same ME1 save file for second playthrough of ME2, same as above except Jacob, Jack, and Zaeed all died in the Collector base.

[PrinceLionheart]

Everyone except Kaidan. Even with Kaidan, it was nothing personal. Ashley is my lady.

[MrFob]

Not sure what you want to gain by this data collection but here you go:

Save1:
1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?
Everyone
2. Who died in Mass Effect 1?  Wrex?  Kaidan?  Ashley? (If you only played ME2, just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)
Ash
3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2?  Any DLC characters?  Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?
All recruited (incl. DLC
4. Who was loyal in ME2?
All but Legion
5. Who died?  Include Morinth/Samara.
Legion & Morinth (chose Samara)

Save2:
1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?
All
2. Who
died in Mass Effect 1?  Wrex?  Kaidan?  Ashley? (If you only played ME2,
just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)
Wrex & Kaiden
3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2?  Any DLC characters?  Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?
All incl. DLC (legion given to Cerb)
4. Who was loyal in ME2?
only Zaeed
5. Who died?  Include Morinth/Samara.
All but Zaeed

Save 3:
1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?
All
2. Who
died in Mass Effect 1?  Wrex?  Kaidan?  Ashley? (If you only played ME2,
just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)
Ash
3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2?  Any DLC characters?  Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?
All incl. DLC but not Legion (not activated, still in the AI core)
4. Who was loyal in ME2?
All (but Legion obviously)
5. Who died?  Include Morinth/Samara.
Only Morinth (chose Samara)

Save 4:
1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?
All
2. Who
died in Mass Effect 1?  Wrex?  Kaidan?  Ashley? (If you only played ME2,
just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)
Kaiden
3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2?  Any DLC characters?  Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?
All
4. Who was loyal in ME2?
All
5. Who died?  Include Morinth/Samara.
Only Morinth (chose Samara)

Save 5:
1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?

All

2. Who
died in Mass Effect 1?  Wrex?  Kaidan?  Ashley? (If you only played ME2,
just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)

Ash

3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2?  Any DLC characters?  Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?

All

4. Who was loyal in ME2?

All

5. Who died?  Include Morinth/Samara.
Only Morinth (chose Samara)


Save 6:
Shep died during SM

[HappyHappyJoyJoy]

1.  Everyone recruited in ME1.
2.  Kaidan died once, Ashley died twice.
3.  Everyone recruited in ME2, except for some old games before I bought Kasumi.
4.  Everyone loyal.
5.  Only Morinth.

[Giggles_Manically]

1) Everyone in ME1 recruited

2) Kaidan is dead in 50% and Ash is dead in 50% of my ME1 games

3) Everyone recruited in ME2

4) Everyone is loyal

5) NO ONE died.

[BrokenPolygon]

1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?
Save 1: Everyone
Save 2: Everyone

2. Who died in Mass Effect 1?  Wrex?  Kaidan?  Ashley? (If you only played ME2, just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)
Save 1: Ashley
Save 2: Wrex, Kaidan

3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2?  Any DLC characters?  Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?
Save 1: Everyone including both DLC
Save 2: Everyone including both DLC

4. Who was loyal in ME2?
Save 1: Everyone
Save 2: Everyone except Zaeed, Miranda, and Tali

5. Who died?  Include Morinth/Samara.
Save 1: Samara
Save 2: Everyone except Samara, Kasumi and Tali

[Dark_Caduceus]

1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?

Everyone.



2. Who died in Mass Effect 1? Wrex? Kaidan? Ashley? (If you only played ME2, just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)

Ashley died, Wrex and Kaiden alive.



3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2? Any DLC characters? Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?

Everyone recruited, including Zaeed and Kasumi.



4. Who was loyal in ME2?

Everyone, including Zaeed and Kasumi.



5. Who died? Include Morinth/Samara.

Morinth died, everyone else is alive.

[Jedi Master of Orion]

Playthrough 1 - Everyone was recruited in ME 1. Kaidan died. I recruited everyone except Kasumi. Everyone was loyal except Zaeed. Samara killed Morinth. Everyone survived the suicde mission.

Playthrough 2 - Everyone was recruited in ME 1. Kaidan died. I recruited everyone except Kasumi. Everyone was loyal. Samara killed Morinth. Only Samara died in the suicide mission.

Playthrough 3 - Everyone was recruited in ME 1. Kaidan died. I recruited everyone except Kasumi. Everyone was loyal. Samara killed Morinth. Nobody on the team died in the suicde mission, but half of the Normandy's crew didn't survive.

I have just a few more but they haven't been completed yet.

Modifié par Jedi Master of Orion, 23 novembre 2010 - 01:16 .

[Iakus]

1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?

2. Who died in Mass Effect 1?  Wrex?  Kaidan?  Ashley? (If you only played ME2, just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)

3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2?  Any DLC characters?  Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?

4. Who was loyal in ME2?

5. Who died?  Include Morinth/Samara.

The save I intend to import:

1)  Everyone

2) Kaiden died on Virmire

3) All but Kasumi.  Don't have that DLC.  May remedy that if I ever decide to buy that DLC

4 Everyone

5 Morinth.

[Quickstrike]

 1. Everyone

2. Kaiden (Determined by a coin flip.)

3. Everyone, including dlc characters.

4. Everyone

5. Samara killed Morinth. 
Jack, Tali, and Jacob died during the suicide mission. (All 3 killed intentionally.)

[Rekkampum]

[quote]AdmiralCheez wrote...

Okay, guys.  I am trying to do a bit of data collection here, and your help would be appreciated.  Here's what I need, for as many saves as you want to list:

[quote]1. Who was recruited in Mass Effect 1, if you played it?

2. Who died in Mass Effect 1?  Wrex?  Kaidan?  Ashley? (If you only played ME2, just give the name of the person you ran into on Horizon.)

3. Who did you recruit in Mass Effect 2?  Any DLC characters?  Did you skip a possible squadmate, like Legion?

4. Who was loyal in ME2?

5. Who died?  Include Morinth/Samara.[/quote]


First Shepard:

1) All characters recruited.
2) Saved Wrex; Ashley died.
3) All characters recruited. Legion recruited. Didn't recruit Zaeed and Kasumi before suicide mission.
4) All loyal.
5) None died on mission. Morinth died in loyalty mission.

2nd Shepard:

1)All recruited.
2) Saved Wrex; Kaidan died.
3) All characters recruited, Legion recruited. Recruited Zaeed, not Kasumi.
4) All loyal.
5) None died. Killed Morinth.

3rd Shepard:

1)All recruited.
2) Saved Wrex. Ashley died.
3) All characters recruited, Legion sold to Cerberus. Recruited Zaeed and Kasumi.
4) All loyal.
5) Zaeed and Kasumi died. Killed Samara.

4th Shepard:

1)All recruited.
2) Saved Wrex. Kaidan died.
3) All characters recruited, including Legion and the two DLC's.
4) All loyal.
5) All survived. Killed Morinth.

5th Shepard:

1)All recruited.
2) Saved Wrex. Kaidan died.
3) All characters recruited, "".
4) All loyal except Jack.
5) Tali died. Killed Morinth.

6th Shepard:

1)All recruited.
2) Saved Wrex. Ashley died.
3) All characters recruited, "".
4) All loyal except Grunt.
5) All survived. Killed Morinth.

7th Shepard:

1)All recruited.
2) Saved Wrex. Ashley died.
3) All characters recruited, "".
4) All loyal except Jack and Grunt.
5) All survived. Killed Morinth.

Intend to import all saves, as I have one for each class, and three extra.

Modifié par Rekkampum, 23 novembre 2010 - 01:23 .