28 réponses à ce sujet

[Manic Sheep]

royceclemens wrote...

Funkcase wrote...

royceclemens wrote...

ASH- See above. Also, remember her little analogy about how people would sic their dog on a bear because "as much as you love your dog, it isn't human?" And then at the end of the game you had the option to sic the Destiny Ascension on the geth ships so the Alliance would sustain fewer casulaties, making the analogy COME MAGICALLY TO LIFE? When the focal point of the story hinges on being a better person than Ashley Williams, how trustworthy is she really?

You read into it wrong then, Humanity was the dog in that analogy. She was saying the Council will do that to Humanity.

And she is the only character who watches Shepards back from Wrex on Virmire, the one who saves Shepards life if you dont charm Wrex, how can you not trust her? 

Her dislike of aliens might be problamatic at times, but she works well with them for the most part.

You read my reading into it wrong.  When Ash provided the analogy, yes, humanity was the dog.  But at the end of the game, the Council would have been the dog getting sicced on the Geth so the Alliance would have fewer casualties to take down Sovereign.  Bring a non-romanced Ashley to the Citadel Central Control and she will tell you let the Geth destroy the Destiny Ascension, completely unaware (or uncaring) that she's advocating humanity do the same thing to the Council that she was so upset the Council would do to humanity.

Point still stands, and the end of ME1 consists of basically being better than Ashley.  Hence: untrustworthy. 

She was never upset about it and he never suggested that she or humanity was any different, it’s simply a fact she that she accepts. Also it not like leaving the council to die is an 'evil' ending and there are actually reason why you would do it other than ‘I feel like being a pro human power hungry Jerk’ so I understand what you mean by “the ending consist of being better than Ashley”. And how exactly does any of this make her more likely to stab you in the back?

.

Modifié par Manic Sheep, 13 décembre 2010 - 06:23 .

[hooahguy]

Garrus: Of course!
Tali: Ehh..... I kinda screwed with her loyalty by telling the council the truth... oops?
Samara: Not really. Her justicar code makes me wonder if she will kill me later on. 
Morinth: No.
Kasumi: Shes a thief, I dont think she would steal something from me, especially since I helped her before. And shes not a killer. 
Zaeed. A little bit, mostly out of respect. But Im cautious.
Miranda: Yup! I romance her every time so I trust her with my life.
Jacob: Yea, its a mutual respect.
Jack: No. She hates Miri and I, so I tend to "accidentally" forget to research heavy ship armor.
Grunt: He is young, but he will learn. So yes, I trust him.
Legion: Yup. Hes my bro! And he is an awesome dancer.
Mordin: Of course. He is a doctor and a warrior. He is like Shep, plus he can heal people and talk to you about your sex life. =P
Thane: I feel that though Thane is an assassin, he is dying and has found Sheps cause a cause to be loyal to as he dies. So yes.

Modifié par hooahguy, 13 décembre 2010 - 06:48 .

[Alienmorph]

hooahguy wrote...
Tali: Ehh..... I kinda screwed with her loyalty by telling the council the truth... oops?

Congratulations... I see a quarian civil war in your future...

[Cerberus Operative Ashley Williams]

Characters I trust

Miranda
Jacob
Garrus (ME2)
Samara
Mordin
Ashley
Kaiden

Characters I'm wary of

Tali (ME2)- Deeply involved in Flotilla politics and I work for Cerberus, but she's a familiar face (heh, face).
Grunt - Admittedly just wants to fight. I don't sense devotion to the cause.
Zaeed - He's a merc, but I feel he is still honorable.
Thane - same as Zaeed.
Wrex - same as Zaeed and Thane.
Garrus (ME1) - He seems a decent fellow but he's a damn Turian.
Liara (ME2) - If it's her vs. TIM, sorry, but she's going down, and I think she knows it.

Characters I don't trust at all

Jack - crazy and hates Cerberus
Legion - I don't know maybe because he's a Geth
Kasumi - She's a thief. Also, I don't trust people who act innocent and sweet all the time.
Tali (ME1) - who is this random person and why are they here?
Liara (ME1) - again, I don't really know why she's on my ship.

EDIT: added ME1 characters.

Modifié par Cerberus Operative Ashley Williams, 13 décembre 2010 - 07:58 .