Ms .45 wrote...
Ineffable Igor wrote...
I know that it's just a game, but that sort of thing [All characters being bi] breaks imersion for me, it cheapens the story AND the characters. One of the best things about the fantasy genre is how it adds certain fantastic elements to real world situations and interactions, and making those interactions anything less than what I would expect from real life affects the experience of the story in a negative way for me.
Don't forget that we're metagaming here. The characters won't all be bisexual in YOUR game. So, I can play as F!Hawke and romance Merrill, and have absolutely no-one else be bi (except Isabela, and she's just, well, Isabela).
In other words, maybe you should stay out of the forums so you don't know this sort of stuff - because knowing it is what breaks your immersion.
Um, no thanks. If they're bisexual in one game I would be even more disappointed if they weren't just as blatently bisexual in mine, because that would mean BioWare had completely marginalized the impact sexual orientation has on someone's character. It's a big part of who someone is, not their defining characteristic, obviously, but it still matters A LOT. It determines how you experience puberty, the people you choose to associate with, how you relate to others on sexual matters, etc. Making sexuality variable would change who the character is in a substantial way. Having it be a "this character will be this way in X's game and this way in Y's game" situation does not sit well with me.
On the subject of metagaming, I will happily admit to this. I do it constantly, but that's not what breaks immersion as far as I'm concerned, anymore than being the author of a work of fiction can break your immersion in it. I suspect that we have different definitions of immersion. And that's lovely. To each their own.
Modifié par Ineffable Igor, 02 mars 2011 - 01:03 .