FenrisDeSolar wrote...
I actually think her appearance perfectly suits her personality, and I don't think it's more designed for male enjoyment than Merrill's is. They're both archetypes in a sense, both were made to look appealing to some players. Male or female, I might add, since practically everyone I know who loves Isabela is a woman.
I guess I was thinking more about the fact that, in DAO, she didn't have a massive cleavage and no pants: they redesigned her to add that, and it so happens that it makes her more visually appealing to males (some females as well, but the original post only mentioned males, so I'm sticking to that). You can probably blame it on the fact that they used a generic human female body model for her in DAO, but still. The "no pants" bit is just overkill, IMO. I don't think she needed such a huge wardrobe overhaul to be sexy, even with her personality being what it is.
Also, I do think that her appearance ticks a lot more boxes on the traditional "hot babe" checklist than Merrill's. "Big boobs + curves + lots of leg" is also a stereotype of attractiveness that's usually expressed by men. Besides, do those women you mention who love Isabela love her personality, or are they also physically attracted to her?
I find her physically attractive, even if I don't like her personality, but it's somehow cheapened by the fact that, to me, she's clearly been redesigned specifically to be attractive. Something along the lines of "oh well, of
course, I'm going to find that hot". It's almost like...there's no merit in me finding her attractive, in a sense. And it does also have to do with the fact that she fits a traditionally male image of attractiveness.
Beyond that point, however, the discussion dips into to what extent female perception of another female's attractiveness has been conditioned by the predominant male perception of a female's attractiveness...and that's probably a bit too OT.
*browses through the lovely Fenris art that's been posted on the previous page to be on topic*
Modifié par Nilfalasiel, 27 septembre 2011 - 11:28 .