Aller au contenu

Photo

The Official Fenris Discussion thread


55380 réponses à ce sujet

#46351
sagefic

sagefic
  • Members
  • 4 771 messages
poking my nose into this convo for just a moment, though i'm totally new to playing the fenris romance...

i would also point out that being a Crow is, as Zevran points out, has it's upsides. you get rewards and notoriety. yes, it's that 'gilded cage' thing, but if you perform well, you get some good out of it, so the fact that zevran sort of (sort of) accepted his role makes sense. you could resist it all and die or accept it and live pretty well. also, given that he'd wanted to die, i always get the impression that zevran had sort of made some sort of peace with his past before he met the warden - i mean, deciding he wanted to die is a strange sort of closure - then got a second chance at everything. it's no wonder to me he's a little more 'up' throughout the game.

but fenris' didn't sound like he had much of an option ever - everything he did was at the will of his master: eating, sleeping, etc. i get the impression he probably hardly thought of himself as a person, much less of having choice. he strikes me that he's still trying to figure out WHAT he is - slave, living weapon, person, etc. - much less WHO he is. i find it totally understandable that he hightails it out of hawke's place. hawke is a human, a noble, respectable, surrounded by friends and family - many things he is not. it's no wonder to me he thinks his lack of position will matter to hawke eventually and he'd rather do the leaving rather than be asked to leave.

so yeah, even being completely new to the fenris story, i kind of thought, yeah, that completely makes sense. i also don't think he has anything in common with zevran except for light hair.

Modifié par sagequeen, 23 octobre 2011 - 10:44 .


#46352
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages
I was just responding to the statement that said that Zevran was not a slave. He was. And while the Crows had some advantages, he desperately wanted to get free of them but until the warden, could not find a way out. As soon as he was given a chance to escape, he does, so you have to wonder how terrific he thought that gilded cage really was.

He also mentions that the alternatives for who*rehouse boys are far worse than the Crows. Manual labor perhaps? So he realized it could be so much worse for him. But I'd say being bought at age 7 means he really never had an option either. It was just something he accepted and made the best of.

I'm not taking away from Fenris' story. I think comparing them is a bad idea though. I can't think that either is "worse" than the other. Both stories horrific, both characters are completely different, and both suffered in ways that are unimaginable.

Fenris DID manage to escape. On his own, he came to himself. That put him up above Zevran in some ways who saw the only escape as being death. But again, I can't imagine either story, and people saying Fenris should "just get over it" are trivializing something that most people would not be able to survive to begin with.

Modifié par ejoslin, 23 octobre 2011 - 10:54 .


#46353
Arcane_Solona

Arcane_Solona
  • Members
  • 570 messages
 Before reading the rest of the posts in detail, I must say that, in reference to your first post on the previous page, Arquen, once again, its like you took the words right out of my mouth head. After reading Nil's initial post regarding the awkwardness and uncomfortableness of the Fenris romance dialogues, I was about to risk being late for uni and type out this entire page of why the Fenris romance is just the greatest thing ever, but luckily for me, I have someone on this thread who apparently shares a brain and says exactly the things I have in mind. I definitely see the romance options right at the beginning as "lightening the mood" options, because Fenris does tend to get all dark and heavy a lot of the time, and it makes perfect sense for my snarky (now aggro) Hawke to want to lighten things up. His response to "I can't imagine why they'd be put off" doesn't seem uncomfortable or awkward; I love his response to that, may it be the "I'll take that as a compliment" one or the "You say what's on your mind, I'll give you that".
The romance dialogue post "Alone" is beyond reproach, in my humble opinion. Its perfect, believable, sweet, and passionate. I love it. It always makes me beam so warmly when my Hawke says "wherever it leads, I hope we'll stay together" and you get that sincere and appreciative smile from him. Sigh. Believe me, I too could go on and on and on about Fenris dialogues. I'm obsessed with that elf. I'm hopeless.

@Yankee23- Maker's breath, he's even fitter than Fenris! (from what we can see through that sexy armor of his*
(doesn't it annoy anyeone else how EVERYONE in Dragon Age, may it be Origins or 2, seems to be extremely fit? Even an old man is all toned and buff with a six pack! Makes me want to spend my life at the gym, even though I'm a swimmer and reasonably fit as it is). Sorry, that was an off-topic rant. I tend to throw those in every now and then.

Modifié par Arcane_Solona, 23 octobre 2011 - 10:59 .


#46354
Nilfalasiel

Nilfalasiel
  • Members
  • 1 741 messages

ejoslin wrote...

While I agree with much of what you say, I do want to point out that Zevran was, in fact, a slave.  He was sold at the age of 7, as a slave, to the Crows, who then took over raising him as an assassin.


That part I wasn't 100% sure of, so I tried to mitigate my argument. I wasn't certain just what level of autonomy he would have had.

But yeah, all I was trying to say was: similar circumstances and backgrounds, different people, and thus different ways of dealing with what they've been given. Wasn't suggesting that one was better than the other or that their personalities were comparable. Even though their reactions to emotional attachment can be. Sorry if it came across that way.

Modifié par Nilfalasiel, 23 octobre 2011 - 10:59 .


#46355
Sealy

Sealy
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages
I agree that Zev and Fenris had similar pasts. Not exactly the same but the basic makeup is there. They can both say "Hey, I was a slave once upon a time" I think the biggest difference is that Zevran can say he isn't a slave anymore, he grew up knowing what free will was, but he enjoyed his work and the lifestyle it could have afforded. I also think his slave status ended close to when he decided to leave the Dalish and return to the crows. Or at least it turned into voluntary slavery.

#46356
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages

Fleshdress wrote...

I agree that Zev and Fenris had similar pasts. Not exactly the same but the basic makeup is there. They can both say "Hey, I was a slave once upon a time" I think the biggest difference is that Zevran can say he isn't a slave anymore, he grew up knowing what free will was, but he enjoyed his work and the lifestyle it could have afforded. I also think his slave status ended close to when he decided to leave the Dalish and return to the crows. Or at least it turned into voluntary slavery.


That's assuming he went back to the Crows voluntarily.  He never says the circumstances of why he returned to the Crows, just that life with the Dalish wasn't for him -- he may have tried to move on and was found and punished, or he may have returned on his own.  That's all up to individual interpretation as we're never given that information.

I actually am not sure what you mean by Zevran can say he's no longer a slave.  Are you talking a mindset?  Because he's certainly running from his masters even at the very end of DAO.  However, he chose to sacrifice his freedom when he chose to stay with the warden until the end of the blight, so who know.  Fenris could never really run from Denarius as he was so distinctive whereas Zevran could have blended in at just about any alienage.

I find both stories fascinating.  Then again, a hug part of that interest are the sexy, sexy voices that told the stories.  What amazing voice actors.

#46357
darkrose

darkrose
  • Members
  • 467 messages

Harle Cerulean wrote...

darkrose wrote...

What if you go to the Rose? Because really, three years is a long time.


As others have said, the Rose doesn't count - no one there messes with romance flags, so there's no risk.  


As a side note, and not really directed at you since I know you didn't say this, but on an extreme of the same topic, I'm always a little :blink: whenever I see someone complaining that the three year gap is completely unrealistic because no one is that patient/can go without sex that long.  It's not really that unlikely.   

Three years may be a long time without sex to some people, but to others, not so much.   Some Hawkes probably need the Rose outlet in that time, others may be content with their hands and/or a phallic tuber.  It really depends on the person.  Three of my Hawkes visited the Rose during the gap, with varying frequencies of visits; a couple more didn't at all.


Honestly, my Hawke doesn't visit the Rose, because he feels weird about it. The only time he actually sleeps with anyone there is Jethann, and that's more to yank Carver's chain than anything. 

Three years is a long time to be constantly in the company of the guy you're madly in love with, knowing you can't touch him, but the Rose won't fix that. I suspect my Hawke spent a lot of nights crying on Isabela's shoulder.

#46358
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages

darkrose wrote...

Harle Cerulean wrote...

darkrose wrote...

What if you go to the Rose? Because really, three years is a long time.


As others have said, the Rose doesn't count - no one there messes with romance flags, so there's no risk.  


As a side note, and not really directed at you since I know you didn't say this, but on an extreme of the same topic, I'm always a little :blink: whenever I see someone complaining that the three year gap is completely unrealistic because no one is that patient/can go without sex that long.  It's not really that unlikely.   

Three years may be a long time without sex to some people, but to others, not so much.   Some Hawkes probably need the Rose outlet in that time, others may be content with their hands and/or a phallic tuber.  It really depends on the person.  Three of my Hawkes visited the Rose during the gap, with varying frequencies of visits; a couple more didn't at all.


Honestly, my Hawke doesn't visit the Rose, because he feels weird about it. The only time he actually sleeps with anyone there is Jethann, and that's more to yank Carver's chain than anything. 

Three years is a long time to be constantly in the company of the guy you're madly in love with, knowing you can't touch him, but the Rose won't fix that. I suspect my Hawke spent a lot of nights crying on Isabela's shoulder.




Honestly, three years is a long time to remain in love with someone after they break up with you.  That to me is the bothersome thing about the time gap there.  I totally get where Fenris is coming from and why he left.  I even can get three years without sex.  But three years being in love with someone after they break up with you and not moving on as Hawke does just strikes me as creepy.  Then again, since it's a story, and I really do like the love story there, as long as I don't think too hard about it it doesn't bother me.

#46359
darkrose

darkrose
  • Members
  • 467 messages

omearaee wrote...

 Didn't Gaider say that the human genes would always be dominant and that all off spring would be human.  Not sure though.


That was what we were told in Origins. However, Feynriel definitely doesn't look fully human, so I'm not sure if that changed.

My personal canon is that the gene that determines "elvenness" is strongly recessive, so the child of an elf and a human will look human. The child of two elf-blooded humans would have a slight chance of appearing elven. The child of an elf-blooded human and a full elf would have a greater chance of looking like an elf. 

As far as Fenris, I sort of assumed that he and Varania have different fathers. I can't imagine that slaves would be encouraged to form attachments. I...don't really want to think about Danarius any more than necessary, though.

#46360
Arquen

Arquen
  • Members
  • 1 280 messages
Last time jumping into this.. LOL.. promise!

To clear a couple of things up -- I know about Zevran's slavery and history and past, and I agree with all the horribleness and brutality and conditioning and etc. he suffered. I said as much in my post.

That being said I was trying not to delve off topic into Zevran analysis. Since that wasn't the point. To clarify my statement about Zevran being a slave. He was sold to the Crows, but became an assassin. He was not a "slave" in the sense that Fenris was a slave and that is the context and definition I was using. A Tevinter Slave to a Magister would have been more "correct" I suppose. Once again I realize everything about Zevran, but the point is exactly that I agree here with everyone about the bottom line -- they are NOT comparable as characters.

Their comparable history is that they are both elves, and both went through some crappy situations where they had no control over their lives. That can pretty much be said for ANY character in the Dragon Age universe. From Alistair to Anders. They all have been handed lemons.. that's kind of the point of Dragon Age isn't it? So when I come across this "Zevran got over it" kind of comparison I just get.. irked... as I said. I don't like the comparison, and apparently that is agreed?

The other major difference is the autonomy -- as I said. Zevran had a gilded cage -- Fenris had a cage made of iron bars spiked with lyrium that he had no thought of even attempting to escape from. Zevran, while still a "slave" to the Crows had choices, and Freedom. Freedom within his role in the Crows -- How he was going to complete a mission. Who he was involved with during the mission. What his approach was going to be. Zevran had and used frequently very basic autonomous and critical thinking skills that were part of his training and his personality. 

This is something that is not a part of Fenris's history at all. Even after the Fog Warriors he was still stuck in a slave's mentality so much that he did not know how to act outside of his master's will. I don't think Zevran's situation with Rinna is comparable because he had closed off his heart and he made a choice. The rest was bravado. He said himself that he had bragged about being the best assassin and taking on the worst missions. Not because he wanted to die at that time, but because he wanted the renown and the power associated with that. Rinna is a Zevran discussion though. Suffice to say that it was a tragic occurrence and one that changed Zevran forever, and one he will regret forever. And yes "wrong" is the right word, and it is what sent him to his spiral of wanting to leave the Crows one way or another. In all reality through death, and that's how he ends up with the Warden in the first place.

With the Fog Warriors Fenris had no choice because he didn't even know what choice was. It just.. isn't comparable. Other than a general sense of "it was bad because of the way they were trained and brought up." The Fog Warriors are something that changed Fenris too, and something he will forever regret, but to say that because they both had that "one big regret," and therefore are similar does not compute to me. You don't compare one kind of traumatic situation to another. You don't compare one person's personal tragedy to another person's. For the simple reason that everyone is different, and with the lives these two led.. they are about as far apart as you can get in terms of personality, situations, and personal motivations for doing what they do and acting how they act.

I'm not trying to belittle Zevran's hardships at all here. When I say he had free will and autonomy I'm not talking in grandiose terms of freedoms and liberties and that Zevran had all of these things, and was free to do whatever he wished. Zevran was a prisoner to the Crows, and yes, a slave to them in some ways. I don't equivocate that to a life of a slave in Tevinter to a Magister. What's more I definitely don't find it comparable to a slave who had his memories wiped by a lyrium ritual and remembers nothing except being a slave.

Zevran's situation and life are incomparable to Fenris because of the basic human autonomy that was allowed to Zevran and denied to Fenris. Incomparable because Fenris's situation is completely different from Zevran's, and because they are different people. Saying they were both in bad situations and horrible/traumatic/tragic places in their lives does not automatically make them comparable. You could sit here and use that comparison for every one of the characters if that was all that is necessary to draw a similarity. Hence, I do not compare them because to say one situation was like another situation just belittles the personal story of both characters.

I just try to avoid turning this into a Zevran thread -- people tend to go off on that tangent, and that isn't the point. The point is simply that I do not agree that Zevran and Fenris should be compared. What is more I find it difficult to understand when people blame Fenris for having such a poor outlook and taking such a long time to "get over it" and "make lemonade" when Zevran already is smooth sailing and such a more happy and "silver lining" person when he's gone through similar tragedy. That's where I get irked.

But I suppose enough of that.. I have said my piece on the subject.

Oh, and last thing about the flirt because I found it rather funny...

Except how often do you go telling a complete stranger that they're handsome unless you're intending to flirt with them? I can understand complimenting a friend or an acquaintance on their appearance, but for those first flirts, Hawke and Fenris have literally just met. And while he does say that his markings must appear strange, he has also just crushed someone's heart for calling him a slave. I wouldn't be so very ready to associate that topic with flirtation right off the bat.

A complete stranger who just offered you their service, and who you are trying to get to know. The whole point of the flirt is to kind of feel him out a bit, and tease him a bit. It isn't a jab at his slavery. It has nothing to do with his slavery or his markings or anything. I find it completely non-offensive. And yes, I have been guilty of saying "your quite handsome" to someone I just met because it was the truth. It wasn't overly flirtatious on my part, it was just a statement, LOL. Hell, I didn't even mean it as a flirt -- it was an offhanded comment to the guy. It really is nothing intended -- a simple flirt that isn't even a flirt -- just a true statement. One Hawke -- who is intrigued by this handsome weapon elf would put out there to see what the response would be.

Also, this:

To be honest though, you are justified in yelling at him for setting you up. There's nothing to get offended at. But still, I wouldn't trust myself to know his tells and his triggers or just how far I can go without offending him from one conversation after seeing him kill a guy (and a bunch of others, judging by the state of that bleeding guard). Of course, the more you talk to him, the more you realise that he's not easily offended, but I'd rather be certain of that before I go making those comments. Maybe I'm just overly cautious, but I fully believe in "better safe than sorry". Or "better safe than dead", as the situation would have it.

I completely agree here, and that is what I was trying to say. You are justified in yelling at him, and your being honest with him, and he responds WELL to that. You've seen him kill someone.. your not stupid, but you also know that his trigger is probably Tevinter hunters, his former master, and people in general trying to kill/hunt him, and calling him a slave is obviously a no go. "A magister's lost property, namely myself.." He makes a jest about his own slavery, and does the eye-roll as well to cement it. All suggestions of someone who isn't exactly going to take a harmless comment about "waste of a perfectly handsome elf" as some kind of backhanded insult about slavery or as if it was making fun of his situation. I don't know, maybe I'm just a more quickstudy of people like that. I speak my mind as well, regardless. He just offered me his services, he promised me he would repay me. I helped him out with this personal matter. He's revealed personal information to me already about himself, albeit not much. It did not feel like he would be angry or try to kill me or something if I said he was handsome, LOL. It wasn't like he was even a stranger at that time per say. He was a new comrade who I was going to be spending time with, and wanted to know more about.

OK OK.. I promise no more wall of texts --- I'll try :pinched:

#46361
Arcane_Solona

Arcane_Solona
  • Members
  • 570 messages
@ejoslin But then again, its not really a break up per se, is it? It was really obvious in that scene that Fenris is mad about Hawke (the "Command me to go and I shall" scene more so than the glowy kiss one), and he doesn't really say "we're ending this. Its over". His words and demeanour clearly show that, as much as he loves Hawke and wants to be with her/him, he's terrified because, 1) he has never been emotionally involved with anyone ever before in his remembered life, so this is all brand new to him and he doesn't know how to deal with such intense and overwhelming emotions, and 2) the flash of memories, which was so unexpected, really threw him off. Ever since his escape, finding out about his family and past seems to be the most important thing to him, apart from killing Danarius. So to have that suddenly present itself to him just derailed him; there he was, in a passionate and intimate moment with Hawke, and his memories all of a sudden gush into his mind for only a moment. Its like a person with amnesia suddenly got all their memories back, only to have lost them again a moment later. I'm sure everyone can imagine how disturbing that can be.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, if it was a conventional break-up, where he just walks up to you and says "this was great and all but its over", yeah, my Hawke would definitely move on. If, however, you know that he has A LOT of baggage and that he's not like others in that he spent his entire life as a slave with amnesia, and he clearly adores you and would be with you in a heartbeat but for his personal issues, there is no way my Hawke can move on, particularly because she knows its not his fault that he can't be with her.

I hope what I said makes sense, because my thoughts are all over the place.

Modifié par Arcane_Solona, 24 octobre 2011 - 01:46 .


#46362
darkrose

darkrose
  • Members
  • 467 messages

ejoslin wrote...

darkrose wrote...

Three years is a long time to be constantly in the company of the guy you're madly in love with, knowing you can't touch him, but the Rose won't fix that. I suspect my Hawke spent a lot of nights crying on Isabela's shoulder.


Honestly, three years is a long time to remain in love with someone after they break up with you.  That to me is the bothersome thing about the time gap there.  I totally get where Fenris is coming from and why he left.  I even can get three years without sex.  But three years being in love with someone after they break up with you and not moving on as Hawke does just strikes me as creepy.  Then again, since it's a story, and I really do like the love story there, as long as I don't think too hard about it it doesn't bother me.


I can see that. For me, what makes the difference is that Fenris clearly hasn't moved on either. He's still wearing the favor, which Hawke interprets as an indication that the door isn't completely closed. 

Arcane_Solona wrote...

I guess what I'm trying to say is, if it was a conventional break-up, where he just walks up to you and says "this was great and all but its over", yeah, my Hawke would definitely move on. If, however, you know that he has A LOT of baggage and that he's not like others in that he spent his entire life as a slave with amnesia, and he clearly adores you and would be with you in a heartbeat but for his personal issues, there is no way my Hawke can move on, particularly because she knows its not his fault that he can't be with her.


Yeah, exactly. It's not like Isabela, "this was fun, thanks" or Anders, "great sex can I move in now". Fenris clearly doesn't want to leave, but he feels like he has to. It makes sense that a Hawke who really does love him is willing to wait.

Modifié par darkrose, 24 octobre 2011 - 01:55 .


#46363
Tashash

Tashash
  • Members
  • 1 040 messages

Yankee23 wrote...

The tattoo is not real and yes, he is that fit, as evidenced by this lovely pic from Mr. Emery's facebook page. Posted Image
Posted Image


*Stares, chokes on her lunch, dies*

Holy freakin' Mabari!!!! Mercy! Sweet bloody Andraste!!!

WOW...........Is it bad that I want to paint Fenris' markings on him? I get the feeling that character and VA share a similar physique.

Phew *fans self* He is hot...Like 'A Rage demon can't compete' hot. Ok, I'l stop now Posted Image

#46364
Arcane_Solona

Arcane_Solona
  • Members
  • 570 messages
@Tash I'm with you there, Tash! *swoons*

#46365
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages

Arcane_Solona wrote...

@ejoslin But then again, its not really a break up per se, is it? It was really obvious in that scene that Fenris is mad about Hawke (the "Command me to go and I shall" scene more so than the glowy kiss one), and he doesn't really say "we're ending this. Its over". His words and demeanour clearly show that, as much as he loves Hawke and wants to be with her/him, he's terrified because, 1) he has never been emotionally involved with anyone ever before in his remembered life, so this is all brand new to him and he doesn't know how to deal with such intense and overwhelming emotions, and 2) the flash of memories, which was so unexpected, really threw him off. Ever since his escape, finding out about his family and past seems to be the most important thing to him, apart from killing Danarius. So to have that suddenly present itself to him just derailed him; there he was, in a passionate and intimate moment with Hawke, and his memories all of a sudden gush into his mind for only a moment. Its like a person with amnesia suddenly got all their memories back, only to have lost them again a moment later. I'm sure everyone can imagine how disturbing that can be.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, if it was a conventional break-up, where he just walks up to you and says "this was great and all but its over", yeah, my Hawke would definitely move on. If, however, you know that he has A LOT of baggage and that he's not like others in that he spent his entire life as a slave with amnesia, and he clearly adores you and would be with you in a heartbeat but for his personal issues, there is no way my Hawke can move on, particularly because she knows its not his fault that he can't be with her.

I hope what I said makes sense, because my thoughts are all over the place.


It's a breakup in every sense of the word.  Again, I get why it happened.  I understand Fenris perfectly there in that scene. I don't understand Hawke.  I could understand if it were 3 months.  Even a year.  But three years is a long time to wait for someone to sort themselves out when he has made no promises, has made it clear that a relationship is NOT something he can do, and who has been talking about leaving with increasing frequency (according to his codex).  That doesn't mean other people don't understand Hawke.  But it is so outside of anything I would do that I cannot relate to a character who would hang on like that.

Modifié par ejoslin, 24 octobre 2011 - 02:00 .


#46366
Sealy

Sealy
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

ejoslin wrote...

Fleshdress wrote...

I agree that Zev and Fenris had similar pasts. Not exactly the same but the basic makeup is there. They can both say "Hey, I was a slave once upon a time" I think the biggest difference is that Zevran can say he isn't a slave anymore, he grew up knowing what free will was, but he enjoyed his work and the lifestyle it could have afforded. I also think his slave status ended close to when he decided to leave the Dalish and return to the crows. Or at least it turned into voluntary slavery.


That's assuming he went back to the Crows voluntarily.  He never says the circumstances of why he returned to the Crows, just that life with the Dalish wasn't for him -- he may have tried to move on and was found and punished, or he may have returned on his own.  That's all up to individual interpretation as we're never given that information.

I actually am not sure what you mean by Zevran can say he's no longer a slave.  Are you talking a mindset?  Because he's certainly running from his masters even at the very end of DAO.  However, he chose to sacrifice his freedom when he chose to stay with the warden until the end of the blight, so who know.  Fenris could never really run from Denarius as he was so distinctive whereas Zevran could have blended in at just about any alienage.

I find both stories fascinating.  Then again, a hug part of that interest are the sexy, sexy voices that told the stories.  What amazing voice actors.


Yah I mean mindset. Fenris still treats himself as a slave where as Zevran very much acts the role of a free elf.

I dunno about the going back willingly but the line is "Naturally the reality did not match up at all to the fantasies I had constructed as a boy while staring at those gloves." which to me implys Zevran not liking the Dalish lifestyle or possibly they treated him like a "flatear" and Zevrans personality seems the type to not take that lying down. But you are correct it is up to interpretation. Posted Image Why can't you be "everything at face value!" bioware. Posted Image 

#46367
Arquen

Arquen
  • Members
  • 1 280 messages
LOL -- Solona -- we must share a brain somehow... o.O;;

I feel the same way about the 3 year gap. More than that I feel the 3 year gap is completely justifiable.

To be "madly in love" with someone for 3 years -- no -- I did not see it that way. Hawke's mother dies soon after the break up, and my Hawke at least didn't give a crap about "love" at that point. She was trying to rebuild her family-- she was trying to move on with her own life.

Fenris is still always there, and he isn't going anywhere. There is nothing wrong with them simply being friends and being around each other. I can completely understand being in love with someone, having them end it because of THEIR personal issues, and then being there as a friend without the explicit goal to want more.

Hawke is not necessarily pining over Fenris or waiting or aching for him to come back. Hawke has a lot of other things going on in their life (mom's death, Qunari battle, death of the viscount, Tranquil solutions.. etc. etc.) and so does Fenris (trying to find and contact Varania, trying to figure out if and when Danarius will find him and sorting through his own mess.) They can be so wrapped up in their own things that friendship is all they want right now, and they don't NEED more. It is perfectly logical that you can leave love out of it, and still have feelings and a connection with someone.

That is what feels natural about Fenris's 3 year gap to me. There are some things that people have to figure out by themselves, and you cannot help them with these things. You can only be there for them and support them and offer your help to them. You can't push someone into self-actualization or self-realization. It doesn't work that way. It isn't like they have to be in a relationship to actually be close to eachother or help eachother, and so I don't see it as some creepy stalkerish, pining "waiting for you to come around," but more a "I am content with this for now," and at the end of the 3 years my Hawke has a shocking revelation that she hasn't WANTED to move on with anyone else.

Sex is another matter... if your Hawke would need sexual release or what-not then the Rose is a good place, but also self gratification as well is always an option, LOL. Suffice it to say that there are two parts to a relationship the emotional part, and the sexual part as well as everything in between.

You can still have a strong emotional relationship and attachment with a friend or comrade or rival and NOT be in a relationship with them. The relationship just adds the other side to it, and so I can see Hawke being satisfied with friendship and no relationship and not wanting to move on. Not specifically because of Fenris, but because there is a lot going on in Hawke's life at the moment, and love and relationships and moving on to someone else is the furthest thing from their mind when Kirkwall is going to hell in a handbasket.

#46368
darkrose

darkrose
  • Members
  • 467 messages

Fleshdress wrote...

I agree with Heiden, this is being over analyzed. The elf-blooded humans look different in this game for the same reason the elves look different. New art, new ideas. In the first game we don't meet any story line based elf blooded humans, so there was no reason for them to distinguish their differences. We don't really know Feynriels entire bloodline though.


As a writer, it makes me want to rip what little hair I have out, just because I'd really prefer at least a nod to canon consistency. It's not just an art difference; it's completely contradicting what was established previously. 

I don't necessarily stick to canon, but I like to know how AU I'm being.

#46369
Sealy

Sealy
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages
I agree with Arquen, or ejoslin since the premise is the same, three years is an unrealistic gap to be pining for someone, but not unrealistic to be focusing on your own crap. Hawke has a lot to deal with. I can see Fenris still regreting leaving Hawke for three years, and wanting to leave to avoid his percieved embaressment, and kicking himself all the way.I see the first little while being awkward little moments that should have been in Legacy, and after that just appreciating their friendship.

#46370
Harle Cerulean

Harle Cerulean
  • Members
  • 679 messages

Arquen wrote...

LOL -- Solona -- we must share a brain somehow... o.O;;

I feel the same way about the 3 year gap. More than that I feel the 3 year gap is completely justifiable.

To be "madly in love" with someone for 3 years -- no -- I did not see it that way. Hawke's mother dies soon after the break up, and my Hawke at least didn't give a crap about "love" at that point. She was trying to rebuild her family-- she was trying to move on with her own life.

Fenris is still always there, and he isn't going anywhere. There is nothing wrong with them simply being friends and being around each other. I can completely understand being in love with someone, having them end it because of THEIR personal issues, and then being there as a friend without the explicit goal to want more.

Hawke is not necessarily pining over Fenris or waiting or aching for him to come back. Hawke has a lot of other things going on in their life (mom's death, Qunari battle, death of the viscount, Tranquil solutions.. etc. etc.) and so does Fenris (trying to find and contact Varania, trying to figure out if and when Danarius will find him and sorting through his own mess.) They can be so wrapped up in their own things that friendship is all they want right now, and they don't NEED more. It is perfectly logical that you can leave love out of it, and still have feelings and a connection with someone.

That is what feels natural about Fenris's 3 year gap to me. There are some things that people have to figure out by themselves, and you cannot help them with these things. You can only be there for them and support them and offer your help to them. You can't push someone into self-actualization or self-realization. It doesn't work that way. It isn't like they have to be in a relationship to actually be close to eachother or help eachother, and so I don't see it as some creepy stalkerish, pining "waiting for you to come around," but more a "I am content with this for now," and at the end of the 3 years my Hawke has a shocking revelation that she hasn't WANTED to move on with anyone else.

Sex is another matter... if your Hawke would need sexual release or what-not then the Rose is a good place, but also self gratification as well is always an option, LOL. Suffice it to say that there are two parts to a relationship the emotional part, and the sexual part as well as everything in between.

You can still have a strong emotional relationship and attachment with a friend or comrade or rival and NOT be in a relationship with them. The relationship just adds the other side to it, and so I can see Hawke being satisfied with friendship and no relationship and not wanting to move on. Not specifically because of Fenris, but because there is a lot going on in Hawke's life at the moment, and love and relationships and moving on to someone else is the furthest thing from their mind when Kirkwall is going to hell in a handbasket.


Basically what Arquen said, with the addition that it might be harder for Hawke if it weren't so obvious that Fenris cares, but it's quite plain that he does.  Comforting Hawke after All That Remains and wearing Hawke's tokens are ways for Hawke to realize that his/her affection is returned.  In addition, throughout that three year gap, they more than likely have the reading lessons to keep them connected; a private time for just them, with an activity that's special to them.  And sure, it might be difficult to cope with the physical desire aspect (something some Hawke likely have more troubles with than others), but knowing the affection is there and maintaining that special contact of the lessons could make the relationship something satisfying emotionally in the meantime even without physically expressing it.  Certainly some people couldn't be content with that, but I don't believe romantic love must include sex to continue to be love.  All it really needs is reciprocation of emotion and taking special time for each other.  
In fact, one could argue that they really build their love through that time period because their lessons together could help Hawke deal with his/her losses and give him/her a refuge from his/her new fame, and that at the start, they're not necessarily passionately in love, but by the time the gap ends, they've built the foundation of that love into something grand.

The sad part being that that would be fantastic to see onscreen, and not in a timeskip.  Sigh.  :(

#46371
Sealy

Sealy
  • Members
  • 1 178 messages

darkrose wrote...

Fleshdress wrote...

I agree with Heiden, this is being over analyzed. The elf-blooded humans look different in this game for the same reason the elves look different. New art, new ideas. In the first game we don't meet any story line based elf blooded humans, so there was no reason for them to distinguish their differences. We don't really know Feynriels entire bloodline though.


As a writer, it makes me want to rip what little hair I have out, just because I'd really prefer at least a nod to canon consistency. It's not just an art difference; it's completely contradicting what was established previously. 

I don't necessarily stick to canon, but I like to know how AU I'm being.



Lol poor hair.
 
I think this is a very small matter in which Feynriel looks very stange and maybe if he had another elf blooded human (a confirmed one) to compare him to then I might be more concerned but It's possible he just took more elven traits then Alistair because his father had a weaker human bloodline?

#46372
Arquen

Arquen
  • Members
  • 1 280 messages
I just realized this page is entirely lacking of Fenris pics!

I bring offerings...

Posted Image

and

Posted Image

@Harle -- that emotional foundation is also another thing that draws me to the Fenris romance. It really is an emotional foundation moreso than a passionate or sexual foundation. The "love" comes slowly and over time, but that emotional connection is there from early on in the romance. I like to think of the reading times as coveted by both Fenris and Hawke, and helps build up that relationship as well. That way when they finally realize they want to move on to the next level, and rekindle this thing for real.. it is already so strong and solid and at the end it feels like the potential for this amazing relationship.

I also agree it is a shame that a lot of character growth is offscreen. Oh well.. that's what FIC is for right?

Modifié par Arquen, 24 octobre 2011 - 02:50 .


#46373
darkrose

darkrose
  • Members
  • 467 messages

Arquen wrote...
Now, the Crows -- I can't equivocate it with slavery. Even as a Crow the training and abuses must have been horrendous, and I don't doubt it, but after surviving the training he got his own missions and assignments. He actually had an autonomy that Fenris never enjoyed. 


The Crows were a different kind of slavery, but it wasn't any less slavery than what Fenris experienced. Zevran's training was a slower version of what Danarius did to Fenris, in a way: the point was to break the recruits and rebuild them in the way that the Crows thought would be most useful.  Once he'd survived the training, he was told who to kill; his autonomy only extended to how he accomplished his mission. Oh, and if he failed? He's dead. The Rinna story makes it clear that Zevran was allowed autonomy as long as he knew his place. When he started getting uppity, the Crows smacked him down hard and fast. 

I just find it irksome that people create this enigma around Zevran like "he got over it.. so what's your problem, Fenris? Crack a joke, smile, be less broody..." As if it was so easy.


Well, no. And it's not like Zevran is "over it" in any way. The flirting banter is so obviously a diversionary tactic, to keep anyone from getting too close. It's a different coping mechanism that certainly doesn't mean Zev is any less of an emotional minefield than Fenris is. In some ways, I'd argue that he's more broken, because he works very hard to hide it. 

As for the first flirt -- it really isn't making light of his slavery or situation at all. It is a simple statement that is in no way offensively phrased. Saying someone is handsome does not automatically mean "you sexy beast, rawr..." it is just a compliment. A light compliment at that, and it takes him off guard, but doesn't offend him. .


I find that line very awkward because of the inherent power imbalance between a human and an elf. It's mitigated by the fact Fenris is unique, so it doesn't have the same sting it would if he'd been an alienage elf, where the assumption is that sex and menial labor are all elves are good for. Ironically, that's not something Fenris has experienced--that he can remember. A human saying something like that to my Tabris would be lucky if all she did was punch him. ("Oh, I'm sorry--you weren't planning on having children, were you?")

For me, it's also one of the few places where male Hawke's voice actor makes me cringe, because "That would be a waste of a handsome elf" reminds me too much of "Another lovely one, here to keep me company".

#46374
Tashash

Tashash
  • Members
  • 1 040 messages
*On-Topic rant* Fenris! Why the hell is it so hard to write your POV?! Grarhg!!! Writers block GO AWAYYYYYYYY!!!!!

#46375
tankgirly

tankgirly
  • Members
  • 3 836 messages

Yankee23 wrote...

Arcane_Solona wrote...

@Yankee23- Your profile picture (if you call something that moves a picture) made me gasp, made my eyes go bug-like, and made me squee! IS GIDEON EMERY REALLY THAT UNBELIEVABLY FIT, TONED, HOT, DEFINED, SEXY AND PERFECT???Well, of course he is, the evidence is right there! And is that a real tattoo??? Or is that a scene from a movie??

I think I'm going to faint *face falls flat on keyboard*


The gif is a scene from Train. I don't like horror movies, so I've never seen it as tempted as I am by that scene. 

The tattoo is not real and yes, he is that fit, as evidenced by this lovely pic from Mr. Emery's facebook page. Posted Image
Posted Image


I can't find it on his FB page, nor on his twitter.:(