[quote]aldien wrote...
Hehehe I knew this was going to open a can of worms. [/quote]
I didn't. :/
I have to admit that I did warm up to Anders in Awakening. I haven't finished it yet so the jury is still out. I would have happily romanced in him in Awakenings.[/quote]
As would we all, I'm sure. =(
But... he's still a terrorist. We could make excuses for him, mention all his fine qualities, but at the end of the day he kills many innocent people, probably half of hightown and I think the crux of the situation is that he would do it again in the name of justice. He gets the knife from me every time for that reason. He's out of control.
Anders is not initially a terrorist, he becomes one toward the end of the game after literally years of fighting and failing to suppress Justice's influence over his mind, emotions, soul and body.
With that said, I never kill Anders at the end (if I actually got that far in the game. :/) because I think that's letting him off too easy. He killed hundreds of innocent people to start a revolution the world wasn't ready for and now he gets to just hunker over and cop out of dealing with it? **** no! It's like, "No, you get to live with the consequences of your actions and you get to help clean up the mess you made. The entire world is going to hate you, curse you, hunt you and try to kill you, and you know what? You get to live through that. You get to reap what you've sown. I'm not going to let you take the easy way out by killing you."
[quote]Does he? He wants vengence for the life he has to lead, for all the wrongs that have been inflicted upon him. But it's all very egotistical. He's the cause of mages, he's their saviour, he left no compromise and he did all these things and assumed that's what all mages would want. He makes the choice for them, plays Maker and decides who should live and who should die. He has self appointed himself as the person who knows best. Tell me that's not selfish and egotistical?[/quote]
Finish Awakening. Max out your dialogue with both Anders and Justice. Take Anders, Justice and Nathaniel (if you have him) with you in various locations and listen to their party banter. I guarantee it will broaden your perspective; or at least give a better understanding of why I say the things I do.
[quote]And what about Hawke? He can say Hawke wouldn't thank him for his plan but he throws Hawke in the middle of it all in the end. He ruins Hawke's life and the lives of his/her friends if you side with mages. He becomes a martyr if you kill him, a risk if you keep him or let him go. She/he may have been put in the position to fight against either their own sister or brother. Anders forces all of this without thought to others.[/quote]
Act 3 Anders, whose very soul has been so eroded by years of living with Justice vying for control inside his body that neither of them is the same anymore. Anders, even less so. Apparently, if you rival(mance/) him, you can
get through to Anders, who eventually realizes just how far gone he is and how badly he's screwed up. He's not completely beyond reason, but he is so far gone he can barely see the other side. You can probably help him see the other side, but it takes a hell of a lot of effort.
[quote]He helps people in Lowtown and they admire him and you can see from Lerine (Larine?) that they want to keep him secret and protect him. The guys waiting for you outside the shop prove that. He has wormed his way into a beneficial situation. Anders is extremely intelligent, charming when he wants to be and manipulative. He knows how to survive and he knows how to play on people's emotions. [/quote]
I think you're taking Act 3 Anders and accusing him of being like that since day one. Simply put, he's not the same person by the end of Act 3 as he was through the rest of the game. If you pay attention, you notice that he starts out relatively reasonable but only becomes slowly more obsessive and extreme as time goes on. (Thank you Justice.)
[quote]Fenris doesn't have the gift of magic, he doesn't have any coin, he is being hunted, the Dalish are prejudice against his kind, the city elves I think he feels would never understand him, might even be frightened of him if they aren't willing get to know him and he doesn't really comprehend them. Plus, they'd see him as a danger to keep around in the alienage. What he sees is that he has pulled himself out of a very dark brainwashed situation and fought hard to not have himself literally skinned.
He has always done for others, always pleased people and now he is being selfish. Well I say good on him..[/quote]
That's an interesting point. I hadn't thought of it that way. Now that you mentioned it, he has kind of earned the right to get drunk and loaf around his mansion like a bum. =)
[quote]I think all he cares about is wanting to make it better for mages. He says one day we will live in a world where mages can be free. He doesn't say everyone. He sympathises only when it is an injustice to a mage.[/quote]
I didn't say "everyone" either. I said "other people." For all of his faults (and there are plenty, I won't argue that), Anders wants to make the world a better place for other mages, who are also people. I think he cares about the well-being of people in general (as I think you or someone else points out how he says elves should stand up with mages against their oppressors), but I think his main focus is with mages because he personally identifies with them and, let's be honest, what they go through is pretty extreme.
[quote]Hawke is an enabler in the game. She/he helps keep dysfunctional situations going, probably to feel needed or play the hero. Fenris is a realist. Anders is an idealist and Sol is a herbalist

Sorry I couldn't resist. Fenris does help others. He could have abandoned Hawke after Danarius's death but he doesn't. Look at that outside of the romantic relationship, just Hawke and him as friends. He stays at Hawke's side, helps mages even when he doesn't agree with it and agrees when Hawke does help the average person. He also will fight for mages at the end. That's a big deal. He's fighting for the very people who could go out and start another Imperium. Anders reasons are much more selfish in my opinion and he truly uses Hawke to get what he wants all through the game. Fenris always upfront. No missions to go collect strange substances and not say why. No please go talk to grand cleric or I won't be your friend. Oh the guilt! Anders uses every underhanded method in the book. Fenris just tells you like it is and I think that gets to people. [/quote]
Oh please, Fenris flashes those big puppy eyes to guilt Hawke into helping him every chance he gets.
"Anders uses Hawke to get what he wants throughout the whole game." Yes, rescuing his friend and lover Karl from the Gallows, saving dozens of mages from being illegally tranquilized by an abusive templar... what a selfish ****. (Granted, the final quest with the bomb and such is terrible, but again, by that point, Anders is so far drowned in Justice that he barely knows which way is up. He can be made to see the error of his ways, not that it helps...)
[quote]The only way Fenris can truly help someone is to have Hawke as his representitive.[/quote]
I know, that's why the altruist in me whimpers around Fenris.