55380 réponses à ce sujet

[Aermas]

Sorry I didn't intend to sound mean, I thought I was good. Much better than anything I could ever write.



It was just considering the last few pages of Dev pandering, I thought I should say something

[tankgirly]

Is it a good time to reintroduce my Amgarrak theory?

[Aermas]

HolyJellyfish wrote...

Aermas wrote...


Elves weren't immortal because they shot up on lyrium. & what is FFN? (FanFictionNetwork?)

Do you have anything disproving this theory? Because I would love to hear it and create a dialogue.

You cannot disprove a theory. Especially with limited information.

[Cutlasskiwi]

If he doesn't want it on the forum I think he can tell us himself. And didn't he say that reading fanfics where like watching someone sleep with his wife? I don't think he had a problem with people writing them.. But I could be wrong.

[Nyaore]

tankgirly wrote...

Is it a good time to reintroduce my Amgarrak theory?

:3 Let's hear it.

[DadeLeviathan]

@Aermas: Gaider has said before that while he doesn't read it, he has nothing against Fan fiction or fan art.

[tankgirly]

Yellow Words wrote...

...........didn't he say that reading fanfics where like watching someone sleep with his wife?

Now I feel very bad about my ficcies...

[Away]

tankgirly wrote...
Now I feel very bad about my ficcies...

I think he's okay with, I think that just means he doesn't read it. Also, throw that theory at us, I'd love to hear it.

[HolyJellyfish]

tankgirly wrote...

Yellow Words wrote...

...........didn't he say that reading fanfics where like watching someone sleep with his wife?

Now I feel very bad about my ficcies...

Don't feel bad. Keep writing them. It was his way of saying he doesn't read them, not that he disapproves of them.

[Ceridwen]

Auhghghhgggghhhawuughgh

Dat fanfic!

I feel like writing something now.... just have to figure out what. :I

Edit: Ooh, Amgarrak theory? Do tell.

Modifié par kwintessa, 19 décembre 2010 - 02:53 .

[HolyJellyfish]

Aermas wrote...

HolyJellyfish wrote...

Aermas wrote...


Elves weren't immortal because they shot up on lyrium. & what is FFN? (FanFictionNetwork?)

Do you have anything disproving this theory? Because I would love to hear it and create a dialogue.

You cannot disprove a theory. Especially with limited information.

Yep. That's why it is called a theory, so my ideas are just as legimate as yours. And while I don't mind having it shot down, I'd much prefer DA codex & story information backing it up, just as I've used that information to back up my ideas.

[tankgirly]

Hey, Aimo actually did a whole comic strip based on a cut scene with David's premission. He had no problem with them.

Nyaore wrote...

tankgirly wrote...

Is it a good time to reintroduce my Amgarrak theory?

:3 Let's hear it.

I mentioned this in the old thread but no many people support this idea. So I am not sure.

It's about the experiment done in the Amgarrak. My theory was what if Trevinter picked up what they left and perfect it to a degree they can use a mortal flesh as Golem? Would Fenris be one of the first Golem they successfully came up with?

Shale had the same problem, not remembered much about her past prior to become a Golem. Perhaps Fenris was the same?

Tank

[Aermas]

HolyJellyfish wrote...

Aermas wrote...

HolyJellyfish wrote...

Aermas wrote...


Elves weren't immortal because they shot up on lyrium. & what is FFN? (FanFictionNetwork?)

Do you have anything disproving this theory? Because I would love to hear it and create a dialogue.

You cannot disprove a theory. Especially with limited information.

Yep. That's why it is called a theory, so my ideas are just as legimate as yours. And while I don't mind having it shot down, I'd much prefer DA codex & story information backing it up, just as I've used that information to back up my ideas.

So why attack my counter thought that Elves experienced a quickening in their blood because of attachment to humans long before there loss of heritage & knowledge? (Which is in the Codex)

[HolyJellyfish]

Aermas wrote...

Sorry I didn't intend to sound mean, I thought I was good. Much better than anything I could ever write.

It was just considering the last few pages of Dev pandering, I thought I should say something

Well, it comes across as rude and harsh when you call it pandering and think it is your responsibility to correct people who are just enthusiastic and excited. It makes being a fan less fun when you tell us how to be 'correct' fans.

Anyways, its cool. Just be more thoughtful next time.

[DadeLeviathan]

So... about this Fenris guy. He's cool and purdy and stuff....



He has.. hair.. and a... sword.



*tries to steer thread back on topic*

[Lucy Glitter]

 No offence but I doubt any writer would like fanfic tbh. I know I wouldn't if I were them. 

Gaider summed it up very well. It's like watching someone sleep with your spouse.

[tankgirly]

@DadeLeviathan, actually, two swords. David hinted it around page 5.

@Lucy, that's why Anne Rice banned anyone doing any fanfic about her works.

Modifié par tankgirly, 19 décembre 2010 - 02:59 .

[Ceridwen]

tankgirly wrote...

Hey, Aimo actually did a whole comic strip based on a cut scene with David's premission. He had no problem with them.

Nyaore wrote...

tankgirly wrote...

Is it a good time to reintroduce my Amgarrak theory?

:3 Let's hear it.

I mentioned this in the old thread but no many people support this idea. So I am not sure.

It's about the experiment done in the Amgarrak. My theory was what if Trevinter picked up what they left and perfect it to a degree they can use a mortal flesh as Golem? Would Fenris be one of the first Golem they successfully came up with?

Shale had the same problem, not remembered much about her past prior to become a Golem. Perhaps Fenris was the same?

Tank

This is a pretty solid theory. It definitely makes sense, Fenris being a weapon that the Tevinters created. Makes me wonder what such a process would entail.

[Aermas]

I thought Fenris was a twohander warrior?

[Leonia]

Aermas, don't you have soime other threads to barge in on? People are trying to have fun around here and you illogical arguments aren't helping the mood.



As for the immortality of elves, there are even rumours that the elves were never immortal. It's hard to say if anything could have made them immortal or not because there isn't much recorded history from that time in Thedas. We can assume that all the elves who lived in Arlathan were immortal. Perhaps they were always immortal? I would think lyirum could have some effect on this though, maybe the lyrium triggered their quickening? Or corrupted the elves somehow?

[Lucy Glitter]

tankgirly wrote...

@Lucy, that's why Anne Rice banned anyone doing any fanfic about her works.

Youknow everyone got upset with her for that, but tbh I think it's fair. 

I also remember when JK Rowling found out about fanfic and her response was negative and everyone was upset and iunno to me, I would be the same. I think people had to expect that...

[Crimson Invictus]

Lucy_Glitter wrote...
Gaider summed it up very well. It's like watching someone sleep with your spouse.

Though some people are into that kind of thing.

[tankgirly]

@kwintessa, my thought exactly.

[HolyJellyfish]

Aermas wrote...

So why attack my counter thought that Elves experienced a quickening in their blood because of attachment to humans long before there loss of heritage & knowledge? (Which is in the Codex)

I didn't attack it. The only thing you said was 'Elves aren't immortal because they shot up on lyrium'. That doesn't tell me much, except you disagree with my ideas.

The Codex also goes onto say that the Dalish still don't know exactly how elves were immortal save for their inclination towards magic. Having their blood quickened could come from a variety of different reasons, considering this is all lore -- nothing is actually historically accurate, the records were long burned by the Tevinter & Chantry (Or kept under lock and key)

Also, fascinating, this entry --

However, the elves' attempted retreat into isolation only facilitated
the expansion of the Tevinter Imperium and it continued to gain
territory, enslaving any captured elves as it did so. The first
“dreamers” learned the use of lyrium to enter the Fade from elven captives, and these dreamers later became the first of the Imperium’s ruling magisters[7].


Suggesting, Humans learned the power of Lyrium from Elves.

Again, the theory that Fenris isn't simply a weapon experiment. Its the Tevinter's attempt to reclaim Elvish immortality.

[DadeLeviathan]

Lucy_Glitter wrote...

tankgirly wrote...

@Lucy, that's why Anne Rice banned anyone doing any fanfic about her works.

Youknow everyone got upset with her for that, but tbh I think it's fair. 

I also remember when JK Rowling found out about fanfic and her response was negative and everyone was upset and iunno to me, I would be the same. I think people had to expect that...

Plus on the whole, there is more bad fanfiction out there than good fanfiction. Especially in terms of Harry Potter and The Vampire Chronicles >.> Some of it is truly atrocious.