Holy crap, 40 pages or so since I was last here! I just can't keep up.

Ah, well. I'll just have to enjoy this thread whenever I can make it. Awesome that we're approaching 1000 pages before release date, though!
MorningBird wrote...
AstraDrakkar wrote...
Well, usually on the first playthrough, i tend to play from my own perspective. Then i'll playthrough again using the characters perspective.
I like seeing how the decisions i would make would affect the outcome.
lol, I have a REALLY hard time playing as myself, to be honest. I know that a lot of people like to play... what was the term being used? Glorified versions of themselves? And by that, I just mean, "I'll be playing myself, only as a badass swordsman/mage/etc... and I'll become hero OF THE WORLD!"
I have way too much fun creating characters to play as myself. xD
Oh, it's not necessarily so crass as that.
I think that playing a warrior, rogue, or mage version of yourself can be an expression of who you are--something you can't express in the real world that you can be in a fantasy world. Maybe strength of character, cunning, or creativity are traits that a person feels they have inside which they don't know quite how to show in their everyday life, or can't. For instance, if you don't have the money, time, etc. to go to college but you do feel like you are intelligent enough to excel mentally, or talented enough to be an artist but not willing to live off pennies for years, then playing a mage can be therapeutic. It allows you to have that feeling and resolve that wish without needing to do something that isn't a direction you truly want to go down, regarding your life or career.
Playing as a character like yourself can also be a method of self-reflection--paying attention to your decisions and doing what you think you would do in such a situation can help you see an example of who you are in practice. If you then analyze what you did in the game, then you learn something about yourself, including your flaws. Why did I choose the option to punch that guy through that window and down that chasm? It felt hilarious and satisfying, but was it truly a good idea? Should I learn to control my temper better? What about rescuing that kid? That's something I'd want to do in real life, but would I truly have the guts to risk my life for what seems like a lost cause? Should I? These are things you can learn about your values and traits, including your flaws.
It's also just plain easier (for some of us) to play as a character like yourself; more intuitive, more instinctive. You don't have to ask yourself "what would X do?" you only have to think about what you are going to do now. Possibly with a side of, "if I had been born into this family, how would I be different from how I am now?" Once you do that, the choices can feel a bit more visceral.
The investment is also deeper at times. Asking yourself whether
you would kill a powerful, out-of-control child or risk him killing others to save his life (as in DAO) is a little harder than thinking, "okay, this is a good mage, a mage would go to the Circle for help." You really have to bite your lip if you're imagining that
you're truly responsible for whatever happens.
It doesn't have to be so ugly as "I'm going to pretend I'm AWESOME as a form of narcissistic wishful thinking!" Not at all.
I enjoy playing a character based partially on myself the first time because of the view it gives me. To me, it makes the subsequent replays with characters drastically different from me--different gender, orientation, hair color, skin color, eye color, attitude, approach, class (warrior) and so on--somehow easier to decide on and enjoy.
As much as I'm convinced at this point that I'll choose Fenris, going by feeling and just experiencing the game as it is for the first playthrough is also more fun to me than if I made a character I thought fit Fenris first and then Anders, Isabela, and Merrill in succession. I like that I don't know for sure what I'll do in the game and I'll be basing the LI mainly off of the affection I develop for the characters; which I feel most connected to in the context of the story.
Your brain may work a completely different way--maybe you find it easier to connect with created characters. I wouldn't understand that totally, but I can respect it (particularly after my Jade Empire playthrough). This is just how
my brain works. It's not that I don't like making characters (or playing them even when they're different from me, as with Geralt in The Witcher) it's just that my first playthrough usually has a thread of similarity to me, and I enjoy that because it helps me invest and feel as if the events in the game are a little more
real. Then again, I guess sometimes even a little
narcissism could be considered good, clean fun.