Gunderic wrote...
Cutlass Jack wrote...
Gunderic wrote...
You defend Dragon Age 2 regularly and complain about consolization? 
*eyeroll* You really need to try harder than that. Consolization of the menus/interface. DA2 had no particular issues on the PC interface. Worked largely the same as DAO's function-wise.
except the part where my companions' costume slots are greyed out, I guess. My biggest complaint with DA 2's UI.
Anyway, it just seems... unexpected coming from a big DA 2 fan. 
In my view, the quality of UI design for a game has more to do with how convenient and fun it is to use, rather than the degree of similarity or difference with the console version UI. Sometimes bad UI on a PC version of a game can be similar to a console version, but it is not necessarily going to be bad just because it is similar.
I enjoyed DA2 quite a bit, despite a some gripes I had about the inventory system and the way that side quests were handled. I helped to beta test the first patch and probably logged around 200 hours on the game in total.
However, IMO, the UI for the PC version of Skyrim is slightly more convenient and more fun to use than the UI for the PC version of DA2. And a lot more convenient and enjoyable than the UI for Witcher 2, which was a PC exclusive.
I certainly did not find it enjoyable to simply scroll through all the perk tree constellations for hours for either of those games, the way I'm doing with Skyrim's UI.
DA2's incorporation of quick use icons into the HUD was very convenient, however, it reduced the screen real estate a bit. I find Skyrim's hotkey implementation needs some fixes, but I can see the benefit of this very minimal, unintrusive HUD. Ultimately you need more on the HUD in DA2 because it is a party-based game with a few more parallels with turn-based games.
The only UI drawbacks I've noticed seem to be some small glitches that will likely be fixed with the next patch:
(1) remapping key bindings does not work properly for a couple of menu functions like dropping items, taking books, etc.
(2) when you press down from the skills menu or up from the map, it should take you back to the Magic/Map/Skills/Items page.
(3) hotkeys and favorites don't work properly for dual wield melee weapons, particularly when they are 2 of the same kind.
Modifié par naughty99, 14 novembre 2011 - 10:39 .