76 réponses à ce sujet

[shumworld]

I liked to romance Tali more than any other. It felt natural and was one of the few romances that took two games to build upon.

[RAF1940]

shumworld wrote...

I liked to romance Tali more than any other. It felt natural and was one of the few romances that took two games to build upon.

So did Ashley/Kaidan and Liara

Modifié par RAF1940, 21 décembre 2010 - 05:19 .

[belwin]

tali or liara?

tali.
why? shep and tali have known eachother since the first game,
and the romance just feels better. nothing is rushed and  the romance has a good build up to it, and doen't have a sudden vibe to it like some of the other romances do.

with that being said, miranda's romance is the worst imo.

Miranda:"you saved my sister. let's have sex in the engine room."
Shep: "okay."

seems pretty quick, maybe it's just me.
don't hate me miranda lovers.

[GodWood]

Worst Romance.

Jacob then Miranda.



Best

Jack



Tali or Liara

eh, whatever floats your boat.

[RAF1940]

GodWood wrote...

Worst Romance.
Jacob then Miranda.

Best
Jack

Tali or Liara
eh, whatever floats your boat.

I agree that Jacob's was just terrible.

[Quickstrike]

I don't like either of those romance options. I can't stand Liara and I've never understood the fascination with Tali. That being said Liara's romance is easily worse. My first time playing ME 1 I never had any interest in Liara whatsoever. I was just trying to be friendly, but en route to Ilos she shows up at my quarters uninvited and unwanted. Needless to say, I kicked her sorry butt out as quickly as I could. She instantly went from being a character I found to be incredibly annoying to a character I absolutely hate.

[Liyros]

The worst? Jacob.



Between Liara and Tali..I'd have to go with Tali. If it wasn't for LOTSB, I still would have been meh about her romance. It felt rushed in ME1. Tali has been through a lot and still manages to be adorkable.



My favorites romances are Garrus and Jack however.

[hooahguy]

I prefer Liara over Tali. Tali just seems to quick to bed. Its practically one conversation then BAM its sexy time. Shes a little girl who I see more as a sister than a lover.

Liara, on the other hand, is much more mature and can stand on her own.



But I prefer Miri the most.

[antique_nova]

RAF1940 wrote...

Tali really was a crush. Also, she got very mad when she heard you were with Cerberus. She didn't even listen to learn why.

she learned why, to destroy the collectors and because cerberus were the only onbes willing to help. plus she didn't do a Kaiden or Ashley,

Plus i was torn by not having Tali for ME1 and went with Liara. But i like Tali more and Liara isn't far behind, i played the game with seperate saves for both of them. Tali's isn't rushed, while Liara seems to have Shep pushing her slightly in ME1. I didn't the change of her voice from  ME1 to ME2, but i got used to it now.

Modifié par antique_nova, 20 décembre 2010 - 08:47 .

[thesuperdarkone]

 I forgot to mention, if you ever try to ask the forum on whether to romance someone which includes Tali, the pathetic talimancers will ALWAYS choose Tali since they can't accept anyone else's opinions. They don't realize that she WASN'T supposed to be a LI in the first place and Bioware only made her one to appease the pathetic Talimancers and trust me, that fact shows quite a bit throughout her romance. I actually liked Tali in the first game, but now it's all "She always liked you", "You would make a cute couple", "Tali wants you" "Did you know that Tali likes you?" etc. and that just irritates me since they ruined a completely great character into some thing that just wants to sleep with you and shows no actual redeeming qualities other than the sex, which isn't that great in the first place. Trust me when I say that her romance is just plain creepy as she has an unhealthy adoration of you that borders on slightly obsessive. Her LotSB dossier doesn't do that any justice and she acts too young for Shepherd or anyone really. I just wish that they kept her like she was in ME1 and just kept her as that awesome engineer who helps out and ISN'T a LI for no reason. Just my thoughts but choose Liara since her romance isn't rushed and the LotSB ending really gives off a sense of good luck and prosperity for the future, which doesn't happen with ANY of the other LI. Liara is and always will be my Shepherd's one true LI:wub:

[RAF1940]

thesuperdarkone wrote...

 I forgot to mention, if you ever try to ask the forum on whether to romance someone which includes Tali, the pathetic talimancers will ALWAYS choose Tali since they can't accept anyone else's opinions. They don't realize that she WASN'T supposed to be a LI in the first place and Bioware only made her one to appease the pathetic Talimancers and trust me, that fact shows quite a bit throughout her romance. I actually liked Tali in the first game, but now it's all "She always liked you", "You would make a cute couple", "Tali wants you" "Did you know that Tali likes you?" etc. and that just irritates me since they ruined a completely great character into some thing that just wants to sleep with you and shows no actual redeeming qualities other than the sex, which isn't that great in the first place. Trust me when I say that her romance is just plain creepy as she has an unhealthy adoration of you that borders on slightly obsessive. Her LotSB dossier doesn't do that any justice and she acts too young for Shepherd or anyone really. I just wish that they kept her like she was in ME1 and just kept her as that awesome engineer who helps out and ISN'T a LI for no reason. Just my thoughts but choose Liara since her romance isn't rushed and the LotSB ending really gives off a sense of good luck and prosperity for the future, which doesn't happen with ANY of the other LI. Liara is and always will be my Shepherd's one true LI:wub:

I also prefer Liara

[RAF1940]

thachugabug wrote...

Liara got me with LOTSB, and she has the best chance to be in ME 3 compared to the other LIs

I was actually very disappointed with how she behaved towards her romance from ME1, but LotSB made it a lot better.

[RAF1940]

thesuperdarkone wrote...

 I forgot to mention, if you ever try to ask the forum on whether to romance someone which includes Tali, the pathetic talimancers will ALWAYS choose Tali since they can't accept anyone else's opinions. They don't realize that she WASN'T supposed to be a LI in the first place and Bioware only made her one to appease the pathetic Talimancers and trust me, that fact shows quite a bit throughout her romance. I actually liked Tali in the first game, but now it's all "She always liked you", "You would make a cute couple", "Tali wants you" "Did you know that Tali likes you?" etc. and that just irritates me since they ruined a completely great character into some thing that just wants to sleep with you and shows no actual redeeming qualities other than the sex, which isn't that great in the first place. Trust me when I say that her romance is just plain creepy as she has an unhealthy adoration of you that borders on slightly obsessive. Her LotSB dossier doesn't do that any justice and she acts too young for Shepherd or anyone really. I just wish that they kept her like she was in ME1 and just kept her as that awesome engineer who helps out and ISN'T a LI for no reason. Just my thoughts but choose Liara since her romance isn't rushed and the LotSB ending really gives off a sense of good luck and prosperity for the future, which doesn't happen with ANY of the other LI. Liara is and always will be my Shepherd's one true LI:wub:

 

I agree that Tali really fits more as a friend than an LI. However, I kind of forgot about her in ME1.  It was a little sad.

[Ryzaki]

Tali hands down. She's adorable.

[Kronner]

Liara.



I'd romance a Thresher Maw before Tali.

[Spartas Husky]

Tali of course.... I felt an attraction for Liara... the new Liara is a completely different person which I understand why. Nevertheless is as if Liara died and I am looking at the older sister closer to her mother in mentality so.



Tali all the way, the fact that through everything she has not change speaks volumes of her mental fortitude, charisma and overall tenacity. Now dont get me wrong I am not trying to imply Liara is weak for having change but... it does take a certain mentality to still be yourself after hardship.



Like a poem I like says "if you can endure hardship and not let hardship change you, yet learn from it and make it your own, you are a rare one"

[PrinceLionheart]

I honestly don't see what was so bad about Jacob's romance? Save for the Porntastic sex build up, his actually felt like a normal relationship, with him actually showing concern for Shepard's wellbeing.

[JediMB]

Cerberus Operative Ashley Williams wrote...

Xilizhra wrote...

Neither, I am a human.

Wat?

I'm not attracted to other species.

Captain Jack Harkness scoffs at you.

EDIT: Seriously, though, attraction does not care for species. It's about simpler things, like shapes and emotional attachments. And phermones/scent, but that obviously doesn't apply for fictional characters.

Modifié par JediMB, 25 décembre 2010 - 05:32 .

[mineralica]

Let's face it - Liara can't die during two games already, plus she's a Shadow Broker. Tali can be not recruited in ME2 and even dead. So it's likely that Liara will have major role and many dialogues in ME3 while Tali... her role is still questionable.

It's far more pleasant to see LI on major role than have a cameo (trust to Kaidan's fangirl in this question), so assuming all the other variables are equal - Liara.

[clennon8]

They're both adorable. In fact, I like all the female LIs quite a bit. Except for Jack. No man would work that hard.

[DarthCaine]

Liara's ME1 romance was boring as hell and definitely the worst romance in the ME series. However, with LOTSB that was much improved and is probably the best romance in the long run (though I'm a Jack fan, so she's my favorite romance).



Tali, on the other hand, is a 14 year old with a t-shirt Team Shepard. Definitely my least favorite ME2 romance, though I still say every ME2 female LI >>>> every ME1 female LI

[RAF1940]

mineralica wrote...

Let's face it - Liara can't die during two games already, plus she's a Shadow Broker. Tali can be not recruited in ME2 and even dead. So it's likely that Liara will have major role and many dialogues in ME3 while Tali... her role is still questionable.
It's far more pleasant to see LI on major role than have a cameo (trust to Kaidan's fangirl in this question), so assuming all the other variables are equal - Liara.

Very, very true.

[Alienmorph]

mineralica wrote...

Let's face it - Liara can't die during two games already, plus she's a Shadow Broker. Tali can be not recruited in ME2 and even dead. So it's likely that Liara will have major role and many dialogues in ME3 while Tali... her role is still questionable.
It's far more pleasant to see LI on major role than have a cameo (trust to Kaidan's fangirl in this question), so assuming all the other variables are equal - Liara.

The fate of Tali is more variable, ok... but how this have an effect on her romance in ME2? For ME3 we'll see... but up to now I find her romance done better... and I usually romance Liara in ME1, so it's not like I hate her or so, they're far from the others my two favourite female characters of ME. 

[Siansonea]

RAF1940 wrote...

Do you prefer the Liara romance or the Tali romance, and why?


Also, what would you consider to be the worst romance?

Liara, hands down. Liara was the LI for four of my six Shepards [Devon, Simone, Ethan, Martín] in the first game, and two of them stayed loyal to her in the second game. My other two Shepards [Leah, Ashley] romanced Kaidan, and remained loyal to him in the second game. For the most part, ME1 romances > ME2 romances. Of the two Shepards that didn't remain loyal to Liara or Kaidan in the second game [Ethan, Martín], one went for Miranda, and one went for Jack.

I did the Tali romance with a throwaway "douchebag" Shepard, and I'm glad I didn't commit any of my canon Shepards to it. SO juvenile. I never liked Tali Exposition to begin with, and her constant need to be rescued got even older in ME2 than it was in ME1. She can't even keep a squad of soldiers under control. Seriously, I just wanted a "wow, really?" dialog option on Freedom's Progress to let Tali know that she SUCKS as a leader. And yeah, Haestrom wasn't exactly a resounding success either. I wonder how the geth spotted them in the first place. With their hacking expertise, Tali should have been able to mask her team's presence there, especially with the star providing so much radiation to help scramble sensors and whatnot.

Liara, on the other hand, is extremely independent and capable, recovering Shepard's body and keeping it out of the hands of the Shadow Broker, and then dedicating herself to taking down the Shadow Broker, and becoming a power player on Illium in the process. With Shepard's help, she was able to rescue Feron, and in the process take over the Shadow Broker's vast network of intelligence operatives. Tali just can't compete with that. Liara has depth and character, Tali has lovely lady lumps and an unappealing fawning nature toward Shepard. I choose depth and character.

[clennon8]

Come now, Tali is very appealing, and they've given her just as much depth as any other character.



However, I will say that I think Ashley and Miranda are the two best "matches" for a male Shepard. Liara would probably be third.