382 réponses à ce sujet

[dreamextractor]

I'm going to end up stuck with Carver because I want to play a mage first...sigh. W/E since he won't let me have Bethany I'm going to do my best to make him hate me!!!!!! I'll be the most annoying older brother ever.



And hopefully it'll make their relationship interesting, because Carver still seems a little bland to me.

[Dr. wonderful]

...I'm going to save both.



I hope, I can save both.

[Elizajean]

I agree I too would like to sve both lets hopev we have that opption

[Johnny Shepard]

Elizajean wrote...

I agree I too would like to sve both lets hopev we have that opption

Same here. I'm waiting for a Dev telling us if we can. But from what I hear it will be impossible.

[Riona45]

I'm going to get Carver because I'm going to play a mage. Ultimately I have no real preference for either (aside from the fact that the game probably assumes you love both your siblings, warts and all), because I don't really know anything about either of them (neither do most other people here). I *guess* I'm not surprised that people are taking their real-life beliefs, ideals, and desires about siblings and projecting them unto these currently blank-slate characters.

[dreamextractor]

Riona45 wrote...

I'm going to get Carver because I'm going to play a mage. Ultimately I have no real preference for either (aside from the fact that the game probably assumes you love both your siblings, warts and all), because I don't really know anything about either of them (neither do most other people here). I *guess* I'm not surprised that people are taking their real-life beliefs, ideals, and desires about siblings and projecting them unto these currently blank-slate characters.

I think I read somewhere on the forum that Hawke doesn't actually have to love his family

[ThatDancingTurian]

dreamextractor wrote...

And hopefully it'll make their relationship interesting, because Carver still seems a little bland to me.

Yeah, from all of one line we've heard him speak so far.

And the fact that all we know about him is 'brother' and 'warrior'.

Modifié par Aris Ravenstar, 06 février 2011 - 04:58 .

[MarchWaltz]

I hope I can keep both carver and beth in the party, I like having a family sticking together type of thing. Would have beth heal and bro hawke tank.



But yeah, one of them will probably die.

[Riona45]

dreamextractor wrote...

I think I read somewhere on the forum that Hawke doesn't actually have to love his family

Well, if you think you read it on this forum, how could it possibly be wrong?

Modifié par Riona45, 06 février 2011 - 05:04 .

[dreamextractor]

Aris Ravenstar wrote...

dreamextractor wrote...

And hopefully it'll make their relationship interesting, because Carver still seems a little bland to me.

Yeah, from all of one line we've heard him speak so far.

And the fact that all we know about him is 'brother' and 'warrior'.

I'm judging by appearance here, ngl and I don't really care. If any future info we get on him proves me wrong, and he turns out to be interesting then great, but for now I associate his character design with blandness. His appearance just seems a little uninspired to me.

Riona45 wrote...

dreamextractor wrote...

I think I read somewhere on the forum that Hawke doesn't actually have to love his family ../../../images/forum/emoticons/wink.png

Well, if you think you read it on this forum, how could it possibly be wrong?

snippy much? sheesh, forget I said anything.

this is where I read it from, which is really more word of mouth, but I never said I thought I was right. Hence the "I think". Wasn't trying to push anything as a fact.

Modifié par dreamextractor, 06 février 2011 - 05:24 .

[Riona45]

dreamextractor wrote...
this is where I read it from, which is really more word of mouth, but I never said I thought I was right. Hence the "I think". Wasn't trying to push anything as a fact.

Then don't end such a statement with a "smug wink" emoticon (and yes, in that context it came off as smug to me).

Modifié par Riona45, 06 février 2011 - 06:08 .

[Vicious]

I wish you could save them both by telling Aveline and her Husband to shove off and get lost -- resulting in their deaths, but saving both of your siblings.







Yep, people would praise Bioware - be a jerk and save your family [and feel dirty about it later] or try to be the hero and save everyone, and everyone loses something.





Unfortunately the story couldn't accomodate it.

[steelfire_dragon]

Bethany as CArver is a carved up Morrigan wannabe

[ThatDancingTurian]

steelfire_dragon wrote...

Bethany as CArver is a carved up Morrigan wannabe

I'm confused. In what way is Carver any way like Morrigan? If anything Bethany is more like Morrigan, albeit in completely superficial ways like her being a dark-haired apostate with ample cleavage.

[Collider]

Aris Ravenstar wrote...

steelfire_dragon wrote...

Bethany as CArver is a carved up Morrigan wannabe

I'm confused. In what way is Carver any way like Morrigan? If anything Bethany is more like Morrigan, albeit in completely superficial ways like her being a dark-haired apostate with ample cleavage.

I admit, Carver being like Morrigan is among the silliest things I've heard on this forum.

[Riona45]

Collider wrote...

Aris Ravenstar wrote...

steelfire_dragon wrote...

Bethany as CArver is a carved up Morrigan wannabe

I'm confused. In what way is Carver any way like Morrigan? If anything Bethany is more like Morrigan, albeit in completely superficial ways like her being a dark-haired apostate with ample cleavage.

I admit, Carver being like Morrigan is among the silliest things I've heard on this forum.

I'm not even sure what it means ("carved up?").

[untoldsarcasm]

Bethany. Love the idea of two powerful sisters fighting side by side. I only wish my Hawke could be a Mage alongside her :/

[Augoeides]

Carver. Only because of that little voice in me that says: Brother/Brother incest could be hilariously good fun.

[SandyWB]

Visually I like Bethany more. Can't stand the sleeveless thing Carver is wearing. But we know next to nothing about their personality, so it's kind of premature to makea decision.

[Adanu]

Sylvius the Mad wrote...

Lukas Kristjanson wrote...

Mods can do many things but they have their limits, and honestly, they are rarely concerned with what is dramatically correct.

I insist that the player is the final arbiter of what is dramatically correct.

And I'll do whatever I can to make the game accommodate the maximum number of mages.

And I insist that you are wrong.

[otis0310]

We don't know anything about either character, except I think having a sister who is a fellow apostate mage would be interesting. Two apostate mages on the run rather than one and their brother. I just think form a roleplaying perspective it would make a deeper bond between them if they had that in common. So if I could, I'd chose Bethany for that reason.



I just hate having the a game changing decision forced on you like that. And I say game changing because I believe the living sibling stays with you for the rest of the game. So unless Bioware changed their mind because of the negative reaction, which I doubt because it is too late in the design now, we will have to wait for a mod or perhaps dlc.



Unfortunately a mod won't do because I bet bioware never recorded the dialogue necessary for Bethany to refer to your character as a mage, and a mod can't add dialogue.

[panamakira]

Although I've yet to know them well, they are family and I plan on giving importance to that aspect when I play. I really want Carver in my party but I don't want to be mage as a first play. ../../../images/forum/emoticons/sad.png

Edit:
I think because there would be more friction between Carver and Hawke, I want to explore the ups and downs of their relationship but eventually reconcile with him because well he's Hawke's brother. He must be upset of being overshadowed by his big sister or maybe the fact that the chantry is after them and that is something that I find interesting in his character. The sense rivalry that might exist there.

Carver is going to have to wait for my 2nd playthru~

Modifié par panamakira, 12 février 2011 - 03:04 .

[MikuHaru]

I would definitely go with Bethany. The very second I ever heard Carver speak, I wanted to knock him unconscious. Also, he's rather bland looking. It upsets me that I can't be a mage because of my love for Bethany...

[sonsonthebia07]

Bethany for her assets, and that's the only reason as I know nothing else about either of the two.