135 réponses à ce sujet

[Luckywallace]

On my first, day-of-release, blind playthrough I had nobody but Jack die but I didn't do her loyalty mission so that kind of made sense.



I strongly dislike Jack and was actually quite glad that she died - I continue to let her die on my later playthroughs and will be importing that into ME3.

[AlexMBrennan]

It is a bad tactical decision to assign tasks to anyone who isn't loyal

That may or may not be true; Shepard can't see the loyalty spotlights on the squad selection screen, and the loyalty flag doesn't, exactly, measure loyalty.



In any case, bad tactical decisions are not necessarily unrealistic ones (e.g. heroic sacrifice at the start to save Joker who'd probably have been executed for disobeying orders anyway)

[james1976]

AlexMBrennan wrote...

It is a bad tactical decision to assign tasks to anyone who isn't loyal

That may or may not be true; Shepard can't see the loyalty spotlights on the squad selection screen, and the loyalty flag doesn't, exactly, measure loyalty.

In any case, bad tactical decisions are not necessarily unrealistic ones (e.g. heroic sacrifice at the start to save Joker who'd probably have been executed for disobeying orders anyway)

Which falls into roleplaying.

[thedarkcanuck99]

Sorry Thane fans....he's dust....oh, and my assistant Kelly, too. Breaks the heart.

[AdmiralCheez]

Ellen Shepard: Nobody died.
-Tech was Legion
-Leader #1 Miranda
-Biotic was Samara
-Leader #2 was Jacob
-Escort was Mordin
-Final team was Jack and Tali

Dick Shepard: Nobody died.
-Tech was Tali
-Leader was Garrus, both times
-Biotic was Jack
-Escort was Kasumi
-Final team was Jack and Mordin

Butterface Shepard: Everyone died, including Shep.
-Jacob was Tech
-Garrus was Leader #2
-Miranda was Biotic
-Don't remember the rest

Joanna Shepard: In progress, no one will die.
-Will use Kasumi as tech
-Garrus will be Leader, both times
-Escort will be Tali
-Undecided on the rest

HotWings Shepard: In progress, plan on killing off everyone except a small handful to be determined later.

Remaining Sheps are still working on ME1.

Modifié par AdmiralCheez, 27 janvier 2011 - 11:02 .

[TopcatPlayer]

tech expert: Kasumi
2nd fire team leader: garrus
biotic expert: samara
2nd fire team leader: Zaeed (died)
escort: Jacob

All loyal, yet Zaeed and Mordin died, grrrrrrrrrrr
apparently Zaeed isn't that great at leading a fire team even though he was head of the Blue Suns
and apparently Mordin's just a weak ass and dies 1st if your defence isn't strong enough in the group you left behind... which it wasn't because Zaeed decided to get shot in the gut, bastard.

[Commander_Adept]

First time was:
Everyone loyal but Jack and Tali (Didn't like Jack at the time... She's now my favorite, and I failed Tali's loyalty)

Kasumi tech
Garrus both fire teams
Samara biotic
Jacob with Chakwas
I brought Jack and Tali with me to the reaper, thinking that because they weren't loyal, they'd be safest with Shepard, our hero. Apparently not.

I haven't lost Jack again since. Tali... A few times.

[TopcatPlayer]

next time round i'm killing Jack, she's such a ****

[F00lishG]

Jacob as Tech Expert
Garrus attacked by seeker swarms. Miranda as Barrier Specialist
Zaeed as 2nd FTL
Miranda was Unloyal, and took her with me to fight the Reaper

Some say it's for drama but realistically if someone raises their hands to do something, who wouldn't pick him? Then because that person died and you realized you should've listened to your XO, you then trust your XO this time to hold the Barrier because they said they could do it. And then not only do you lose your best friend to seekers, you lose your battle buddy who you gained loyalty early on, like Pre Horizon. Ever since you put that gun to his face and gained his loyalty you two were inseparable in fights. You killed lotsa mercs together and figured he can lead a team operation after all the time working together. And finally your XO dies because earlier on you didn't feel like taking BS from her. She was petty and she was being a bully. So you didn't bother talking to her ever again after you sided with the psycho who you may have to kill later before she goes on a biotic rampage after this mission.

[CaptainZaysh]

First time I tried to keep everybody alive, but ended up losing Jack (didn't leave a strong enough force Holding the Line).

In my canon import:
- Kasumi died trying to seal the door
- Samara was snatched by the seeker swarms
- Thane was mortally wounded during the distraction attack
- Jack was killed by the falling debris

It felt much more like a suicide mission with good people dying at every step.

[Raven4030]

First playthrough:
Mordin dies holding the line

Second playthrough:
Tali dies trying to seal the door.

Some playthroughs later:
Samara was killed off in her loyalty mission because I felt like she was an annoying, self-righteous b****, then I picked Morinth as second fire-team leader so that she'd die because I'm not letting that murderous wench go free.

Going to do a few more playthroughs where I'll let several people die during the suicide mission, mostly for sake of drama (got plenty of 'everybody lives' playthroughs for import to ME3 anyway)

[Rip504]

Obviously I have multiple playthroughs. Many with the entire crew alive and loyal.

Female Shepard killed,Kaiden,Thane,Jacob,and Garrus.Paragon.
Male Shepard killed all male crew,while saving an all loyal female crew. Paragon.
Male Shepard got everyone killed except Tali & Grunt. Renegade.

[comrade8472]

many play throughs...
>some with all alive
>one with crew alive and one dead.
>other's with varying #'s dead
>then one actually had to try and get every one dead last play through so knew what had to be done / (and/or) not done
>Tali dies way too easily even with loyalty and trying to get her to open that door that techs are supposed to be able to/ even not using once and loyal.
(have all DLC)

[HighMoon]

I want to have at least one playthrough as a FemShep where all the females survive and all the men die. Girl power! Woo!

Janette Shepard - Everyone survives.

Candy Shepard - Tali, Jack, Legion and Mordin die.

Chase Shepard - Kasumi, Garrus, Miranda and Grunt die. Sold Legion to Cerberus.

[Kurt M.]

The first time all the crew died, cos I sent them without escort

Further times, and after a visit or two to the wiki, nobody.

Sold Legion to Cerberus

Apart from RP, I've never seen any sense in selling Legion. You sacrifice XP (from his loyalty mission) + a squadmate for 50.000 miserable credits. It should have been at least 100.000 for it to become a little tempting (even more having in mind that you can recover up to 30.000 credits in his loyalty mission).

Modifié par Gladiador2, 08 juillet 2011 - 06:36 .

[gavgav77]

First time poster, long time lurker. 
I just finished my first ever playthrough of ME2, and it was great.

Vents: Legion
1st (Fire) Squad Leader: Samara
Biotic Shield: Samara
2nd (Fire) Squad Leader/Distraction Team: Garrus
Escort: Zaeed
Final Team: Grunt & Jack

Hmm, I had some deaths occur. I assumed that Samara would be a great fire team leader and basically used her for all important parts of the final mission wherever I could.

Modifié par winawer, 09 juillet 2011 - 12:19 .

[SovereignsIndoctoration]

I only played the game twice and that was because I keep on getting stressed to get everyone through XD
But on my first play through I got everyone through. All except Mordin. I'm not sure why he even died in the first place. I had his loyality and I never chose him to be a leader in any of the choices.

On my Second playthrough I ended getting everyone, and managed (luckily) to do it without Jack's loyality. Was paranoid since I couldn't resolve the issue between Miranda and Jack earlier on that playthrough.

[eternalnightmare13]

First Team: Kasumi and Zaeed
Fire Squad Leader #1: Miranda
Vents: Tali
Second Team: Samara (Morinth) and Miranda
Distraction Team Leader #2: Garrus
Biotic Shield: Jacob
Escort: No One - this ain't no rescue mission.
Final Team: Grunt and Thane

Body Count: Samara (Morinth) and the entire crew.

[IBYCFOTA]

First time around I lost Miranda because I sided with Jack in their argument without the points to defuse it. Had I just used a different squadmate to do the suicide mission with she would have survived, but I hadn't done any research beforehand and didn't know any better at the time.

The second time I had everything figured out so no squadmates were lost, although I did lose my crew minus the Doctor because I did too many missions after they were abducted.

Modifié par IBYCFOTA, 11 juillet 2011 - 01:36 .

[Mixtos]

On my first Suicide Mission, I lost the crew. As the other tasks all needed a specialist, I was trying to think of a squad member who was uniquely qualified to defend a large group - I couldn't decide on anyone. I was so paranoid about losing the squad that I didn't send an escort (I know; I suck). Only after the mission did I find out that any loyal member can successfully defend the crew.

Since then, there've been zero casualites in my playthroughs. For my Spacer/Sole Survivor import, I'm planning on losing a few people on purpose; solely for role-playing reasons.

[Arcadian Legend]

 Honestly? First time through it was Mordin. All the times after that no one has died, apart from rotting piles of Collectors, Husks and one Human-Reaper. 

[Unionhack]

First time through I lost Tali, Grunt, and Jacob because I didn't know what the hell I was doing.
On my second time, which was my first time with my now canon Shep, I got everyone out alive.
I purposely made a few die on my Renegade run, though. Jack, Thane, Kasumi, Garrus, Tali, and Zaeed all went down for him.

[Mercedes-Benz]

The Collectors and a Reaper.