The RustMonster wrote...
RosaAquafire wrote...
Damn.
I'm so tired of these threads, my god.
Well now that there's an official romance thread they can't keep making more of those, so let's go to the topic people are passionate about on this forum, and I'll paraphrase, "Teh Chantry is evulz! Mages FTW can mages haz freedom?"
Guest_Burayan_Koga_*
Yaskaleh wrote...
GreyArea wrote...
Yaskaleh wrote...
Once, I would join you in burning the chantry. But I rethought and came to the conclusion that it isn't needed. We just need to reforge it into a new shape. A Grey Chantry, a third andrasteistic church. It would stand in the middle between the Orlesian Chantry and the Imperial Chantry. A faith mostly for humans and with great respect for the dwarven and elven faiths. The legendary Hawke will be it's prophet, just second behind Andraste in importance! All hail the Divine Hawke!
You can't make a new before you destroy the old.
oh, really? Say that to the protestantic movement in the middle ages.
Only if your mage is covered in Nutelladrahelvete wrote...
The RustMonster wrote...
RosaAquafire wrote...
Damn.
I'm so tired of these threads, my god.
Well now that there's an official romance thread they can't keep making more of those, so let's go to the topic people are passionate about on this forum, and I'll paraphrase, "Teh Chantry is evulz! Mages FTW can mages haz freedom?"
The big question is: can my mage romance the Chantry?
bobobo878 wrote...
You see, this is my problem with your logic. We don't know enough about any faction in dragon age to make these claims without filling in huge gaps with pure speculation, yet you insist that your speculation is superior, and anyone who hasn't come to the same conclusion is a fanatic or a lunatic.GreyArea wrote...
Exalted march was just a failure. And in that failure there was one person making it possible. Andraste. Where is Andraste now?
I am sorry to say this but if you are going to believe in "exalted marches" and "mages must be killed" fantasies and obsessions then you will just find yourself being a sex slave to Qun screaming for exalted march.
The RustMonster wrote...
Well now that there's an official romance thread they can't keep making more of those, so let's go to the topic people are passionate about on this forum, and I'll paraphrase, "Teh Chantry is evulz! Mages FTW can mages haz freedom?"
GreyArea wrote...
bobobo878 wrote...
You see, this is my problem with your logic. We don't know enough about any faction in dragon age to make these claims without filling in huge gaps with pure speculation, yet you insist that your speculation is superior, and anyone who hasn't come to the same conclusion is a fanatic or a lunatic.GreyArea wrote...
Exalted march was just a failure. And in that failure there was one person making it possible. Andraste. Where is Andraste now?
I am sorry to say this but if you are going to believe in "exalted marches" and "mages must be killed" fantasies and obsessions then you will just find yourself being a sex slave to Qun screaming for exalted march.
Where has the mighty templar army been during the blights? Show me where it has been and I may say Qun might do something else than facepalm when they see those poormethlyrium addicts.
It was you who begun to speak about allmighty chantry protecting the lands of Qun invasion. Not me. Yet you blame my logic. This is however not surprising if we remember what kind of other thoughts you have.
Modifié par bobobo878, 15 février 2011 - 08:05 .
RosaAquafire wrote...
The RustMonster wrote...
Well now that there's an official romance thread they can't keep making more of those, so let's go to the topic people are passionate about on this forum, and I'll paraphrase, "Teh Chantry is evulz! Mages FTW can mages haz freedom?"
Man, even the innumerous romance threads very occassionally came up with new questions to ask or things to say. This **** is so tired I'm pretty sure nobody could successfully brainstorm something new with three days and an infinite supply of coffee.
slumlord722 wrote...
Someone mentioned earlier, and I am inclined to agree with him, that most all of this Chantry-hate is probably just "the man" syndrome, where of course the Chantry has to be toppled. Why? Because it's in power, man.
More so than that though, I really think people are just taking their real-world vices towards religion and applying it to a made-up one that has been portrayed as a generally positive organization vastly preferential to the chaos that would exist without it.
Yeah all that oppresion of an entire group of people, and lobotomising some of them on little evidence and making them slaves is nothing.slumlord722 wrote...
Someone mentioned earlier, and I am inclined to agree with him, that most all of this Chantry-hate is probably just "the man" syndrome, where of course the Chantry has to be toppled. Why? Because it's in power, man.
Chaos like we've seen in groups with no such restrictions or like in Rivain........... oh wait.slumlord722 wrote...
More so than that though, I really think people are just taking their real-world vices towards religion and applying it to a made-up one that has been portrayed as a generally positive organization vastly preferential to the chaos that would exist without it.
bobobo878 wrote...
GreyArea wrote...
bobobo878 wrote...
You see, this is my problem with your logic. We don't know enough about any faction in dragon age to make these claims without filling in huge gaps with pure speculation, yet you insist that your speculation is superior, and anyone who hasn't come to the same conclusion is a fanatic or a lunatic.GreyArea wrote...
Exalted march was just a failure. And in that failure there was one person making it possible. Andraste. Where is Andraste now?
I am sorry to say this but if you are going to believe in "exalted marches" and "mages must be killed" fantasies and obsessions then you will just find yourself being a sex slave to Qun screaming for exalted march.
Where has the mighty templar army been during the blights? Show me where it has been and I may say Qun might do something else than facepalm when they see those poormethlyrium addicts.
It was you who begun to speak about allmighty chantry protecting the lands of Qun invasion. Not me. Yet you blame my logic. This is however not surprising if we remember what kind of other thoughts you have.
You can say what you want about the Templar, but they do a better job of managing their charges than qunari mage handlers. Believe it or not, treating mages like farm animals does not make them into particularly powerful combatants. The templar are mage police, not a counter-qunari force. The Chantry usually organizes non-templar for fighting them. If I had to choose between fighting a chantry templar and a qunari mage, I'd pick the qunari mage, lyrium addiction or not.
*excessive troll feeding removed*GreyArea wrote...
slumlord722 wrote...
Someone mentioned earlier, and I am inclined to agree with him, that most all of this Chantry-hate is probably just "the man" syndrome, where of course the Chantry has to be toppled. Why? Because it's in power, man.
More so than that though, I really think people are just taking their real-world vices towards religion and applying it to a made-up one that has been portrayed as a generally positive organization vastly preferential to the chaos that would exist without it.
What chaos? You are just wrong if you say there would be chaos without chantry. I expect you to say that if there would not be chantry and we would make one, then people would stop doing crimes because they would just be so chantry-happy staring and loving the eternal flame.
Modifié par bobobo878, 15 février 2011 - 08:48 .
bobobo878 wrote...
Of course you expect him to say that, because you're upset that you can't destroy the church in real life, so you're projecting your warped perception of it onto slumlord and the rest of the "sick chantry apologists" on this site so you can feel like you've accomplished something by "defeating" them.GreyArea wrote...
slumlord722 wrote...
Someone mentioned earlier, and I am inclined to agree with him, that most all of this Chantry-hate is probably just "the man" syndrome, where of course the Chantry has to be toppled. Why? Because it's in power, man.
More so than that though, I really think people are just taking their real-world vices towards religion and applying it to a made-up one that has been portrayed as a generally positive organization vastly preferential to the chaos that would exist without it.
What chaos? You are just wrong if you say there would be chaos without chantry. I expect you to say that if there would not be chantry and we would make one, then people would stop doing crimes because they would just be so chantry-happy staring and loving the eternal flame.
Of course you find it amusing, it's what you wanted all along wasn't it, troll? No, really, what's the name of your real account? Obviously you just created this as an alt account from a different IP location so you can be as condescending to the other people as you like without getting banned.GreyArea wrote...
How very amusing resorting to out of game attacks when you lost all other arguments like they would had been a castle made of sand.
Just FYI, I haven't ever even thought about destroying a church in real life. They don't slay innocent people here where I live.
Modifié par bobobo878, 15 février 2011 - 08:35 .
bobobo878 wrote...
No, really, what's the name of your real account? Obviously you just created this as an alt account from a different IP location so you can be as condescending to the other people as you like without getting banned.GreyArea wrote...
How very amusing resorting to out of game attacks when you lost all other arguments like they would had been a castle made of sand.
Just FYI, I haven't ever even thought about destroying a church in real life. They don't slay innocent people here where I live.
Maelora wrote...
I played all six Origins, and my characters attitude towards the Chantry ranged from 'extreme dislike' to 'virulent hatred'.
Modifié par KawaiiKatie, 15 février 2011 - 08:23 .
KawaiiKatie wrote...
Maelora wrote...
I played all six Origins, and my characters attitude towards the Chantry ranged from 'extreme dislike' to 'virulent hatred'.
Yeeeeeeah.... I even tried to play a Chantry-loving human, but Alistair put a stop to that:
Warden: Wasn't it nice of the Revered Mother to give us her blessing? The Chantry is great!
Alistair: They turn Templars into drug addicts. Drug addicts with really big swords.
Warden: .........that's not right. Someone should stop them.
Alistair: .........blessed art thou who exists in the sight of the Maker....
Modifié par Harid, 15 février 2011 - 08:25 .
Guest_Burayan_Koga_*
Killercheesepuff wrote...
Let's stop it with the whole projection argument. Honestly, it's just an excuse to ignore someones argument despite it's merit. Personally, I think the chantry has done more harm than good I see no evidence of benefits that we have from them. Mages are human as well, you know.
Burayan_Koga wrote...
The Chanrty has done more harm than good and it's time we kicked their asses out of Kirkwall!
C9316 wrote...
Modifié par Gabriel Stelinski, 15 février 2011 - 08:31 .
Gabriel Stelinski wrote...
Burayan_Koga wrote...
The Chanrty has done more harm than good and it's time we kicked their asses out of Kirkwall!
Do you have some insight into the game's story? Something that the rest of us don't?
BTW:C9316 wrote...
C9316 strikes again!
Retour en haut
