Rylor Tormtor wrote...
Joy Divison wrote...
Blacklash93 wrote...
Joy Divison wrote...
There's a lot of people in these forums who need to quit their day-jobs and start a electronic entertainment company if we're ever going to get anything worthy to buy considering Bioware is obviously not up to the job...
We complain because we care. 
Well, yeah, I get that. Complaining before a game is released about a demo that isn't the demo we will be downloading
.
Help me with the logic here...
Here is the logic. Those who have critical remarks are remarking on the information that we have. Now, you may justifiably say that this isn't entirely fair, since we have not seen the entire game. However, thos who are critical can only comment on the information they have, not on information they don't hoave, so, when game play like this is revealed, it is a new piece of information that one can discuss, examine, and yes, even critique. As for us getting a different version, you are absolutely correct that we will apparently not be playing the same build as the one in these videos. You cannot be so naive or fanatical as to beleive that the version we will get, which will have more polish, will be SIGNIGANTLY different from these videos in any MEANINGFUL way. Updated textures, more informative tool tips and such (and, for the love of the Maker, please, PLEASE, please fire the Hurlock Solid Gold Dancers), but Hawke is not all of a sudden going to become a quanarii or we are not going to get a new class or such.
Different people have different expectations. If yours have been met, then life is good for you. Beleive, Bioware doesn't the vapid defense of a legion of mindless followers, they are perfectly able to deal (and often very successfully, which sets them apart from many other game companies) with those who are critical of their work. People who are critical about these are not doing this for hell of it. They have been customers and consumers of Bioware products for many years (as have some of the more ardent supporters have I am sure), and they "complain" as you simply put it because they have a genuine affection for the company and their products. They could simply disappear and you could have your forum full or fan appreciation threads for companion characters or polls for squad make-ups and such, but, in my opinion, I think ultimately Bioware's products would suffer. That is not to say that I ever see my comments making much of difference, but there are long time members of these boards that have made real contributions in the past.
There's always a fine line between valid criticisms and realistic expectations.

It's good to provide proper feedback in order to improve the product,but ultimately the responsability is up to the developer and we have no control over that.
It's up to Bioware to hire the best artists,game designers and engineers they can and if they fail to do so,complaining is rather pointless.If Bioware doesn't have a tradition of luring great game designers,nothing I can do about it.If Bioware doesn't employ the best game designers,it's just normal thay you will see their games with numerous flaws (overnerfing the rpg aspect of ME2,poor boss battles,repetitive combat,poor UI in the first ME,horrid inventory interface,dreadful sidequest planets,Mako,etc) or the inability to properly adjust some aspect of a flawed mechanic (which I am sure will be present in DA2 as well).
There's no doubt in my mind that among the western game industry,most wouldn't think of working for one of the few rpg developers as their first or second pick (most would probably prefer to work for Blizzard,Valve,Bungie,Sony,Rockstar and create a nice shooter with a super polished 7-8 hours singleplayer experience).
That's why Bioware deserve credit despite that,as they don't have super elite game designers and thus must continually learn from their mistakes (just like Naughty dogs who had to improve a lot from Uncharted 1 to 2).