244 réponses à ce sujet

[AlexXIV]

No they are all evil and so are you and your thread.

[Albatroz]

I have made it known several times that I am pro-Chantry. I think that while the organization may be morally grey, what isn't in Dragon Age? The Chantry serves the greater good of all of Thedas, and the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.

[DARBanks]

I like the chantry and believe it does good work. Yes, there is corruption and stuff in it, but I believe overall its good.

[kjdhgfiliuhwe]

AlexXIV wrote...

No they are all evil and so are you and your thread.

Don't forget they have cooties as well.

[TJPags]

I do not think the Chantry is evil at all.



Annoying, perhaps, but evil? Nope.

[AlexXIV]

kjdhgfiliuhwe wrote...

AlexXIV wrote...

No they are all evil and so are you and your thread.

Don't forget they have cooties as well.

That's not so bad, I had worse.

[Threeparts]

I think most people that dislike the Chantry are against the concept of the institution and what it does, rather than the individuals associated with it. I'm sure there are some wonderful Templars who adore their kids and spouses, volunteer at the Orphaned Kitten Society on their days off, and think most mages are pretty swell and consider their job as caretaking, rather than imprisoning.

That doesn't change what people dislike about the concept of the Chantry and Templar organisations, just how they feel about the individuals.

[Killroyomega]

No, most people in the Chantry are intolerant bigots who were raised to be that way and the Chantry basically supports it. Anyone who questions their faith is somehow the most evil being ever and should be destroyed.

The few who aren't blindly following their religion are smart enough to realize things otherwise and they will (usually) openly admit they don't really believe everything the chantry says.

Modifié par Killroyomega, 19 février 2011 - 04:26 .

[TJPags]

Threeparts wrote...

I think most people that dislike the Chantry are against the concept of the institution and what it does, rather than the individuals associated with it. I'm sure there are some wonderful Templars who adore their kids and spouses, volunteer at the Orphaned Kitten Society on their days off, and think most mages are pretty swell and consider their job as caretaking, rather than imprisoning.
That doesn't change what people dislike about the concept of the Chantry and Templar organisations, just how they feel about the individuals.

You're probably right.

I personally see it the opposite way.  The organization is fine, it's a few people within it who may be suspect.

Now, I've not met any person associated with the Chantry who I thought was evil.

But I suppose there could be one or two hiding somewhere.

Maybe that Cullen guy from the Tower quest . . . .

[Dante Angelo]

Not everyone in the chantry is evil just 77% of them are 21% percent are good and the rest are there for the cake

[Eveangaline]

I doubt random andrastians are bad. But the church itself seems to have some corruption.

Plus, they're pretty attack happy. You ever do the quest that sets up a circle of magi in orzamar? They consider doing a crusade against another country because that country, which has almost no followers of their religion, doesn't follow their religions code. THat's clearly evil.

Modifié par Eveangaline, 19 février 2011 - 04:31 .

[MasterSamson88]

 I think there are good people in the chantry, it's just got way too much power for a international organization. It's also far too miltaristic.

[Erinpedz]

I th8ink its the same as anything... it's getting judged externally by the extermists within in.. same as the mages are tarnished by the apostates and malecifar.

So personally I think given a choice in the game I'd try and keep the chantry intact but still give mages more freedom than they have.

[Dante Angelo]

mrsph wrote...

Cullen was a severely traumatized man. I don't think anyone would be right in the head after forcing to endure what he endured.

Maybe next time Cullen makes an appearence he looks like this

[Nimpe]

Chantry is evil and stupid

[marshalleck]

The RustMonster wrote...
 The Chantry serves the greater good of all of Thedas, and the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.

Okay, Spock. 

This reasoning has never horribly backfired and led to all manner of atrocities before...

Modifié par marshalleck, 19 février 2011 - 04:39 .

[Zabaniya]

There was that old Chantry sister who talked about the Maker's ham in Denerim... she's obviously hiding ulterior motives.

[TJPags]

mrsph wrote...

Cullen was a severely traumatized man. I don't think anyone would be right in the head after forcing to endure what he endured.

Lots of people have been traumatized.

Not all did what he did.

[AustinKain]

It was emperor Kordilius Drakon I of Orlais who formalized the cult into a religion and created the frist Chantry.



So the Chantry is a Orlaisean cult and therefore it is evil.

[Big I]

I don't have a problem with Andrastians, only with their corrupt Chantry.

[Zabaniya]

AustinKain wrote...

It was emperor Kordilius Drakon I of Orlais who formalized the cult into a religion and created the frist Chantry.

So the Chantry is a Orlaisean cult and therefore it is evil.

Evil, but with outrageous fashion.  Especially their shoes.  They're such ridiculous shoes.

[Albatroz]

TJPags wrote...

mrsph wrote...

Cullen was a severely traumatized man. I don't think anyone would be right in the head after forcing to endure what he endured.

Lots of people have been traumatized.

Not all did what he did.

Different people react differently to trauma. It all depends on the personality of the victim and what their personal breaking point happens to be.