Aller au contenu

Photo

Dragon Age 2 Demo feedback thread


8659 réponses à ce sujet

#901
angry_peon

angry_peon
  • Members
  • 96 messages
I can see, why people who liked the good old round based party rpgs, and Dragon Age for it's (partial) return to that system, are put off by DA2.

I personally liked the demo very much, and I don't regret pre ordering the game.

But I pretty much like any sub-genre of rpg anyway.

#902
MorrowRail

MorrowRail
  • Members
  • 15 messages
Tremendously disappointed.  If the original DA was the spiritual successor to Baldur's Gate, this is the spiritual successor to Jade Empire.  Almost everything I liked about DA is changed for the sake of simplicity and the things I didn't care for (like the art direction) have been changed in ways I wouldn't have suggested.

Who cares what I think?  Nobody, obviously, and I'm sure you'll sell a ton of copies, just like you did with Mass Effect 2, but while I enjoyed that game because I had no real stake in Mass Effect, I can't help but feel a little betrayed.  Naive?  Certainly.  Still, I'd hoped the demo would quiet my doubts and it's left me thinking I won't buy a game I'd had marked down as an automatic purchase.  Whatever.  There's always Skyrim.

#903
panamakira

panamakira
  • Members
  • 2 751 messages

stephen1493 wrote...

If you aren't consistent in the way you're talking to someone, it really felt like your Hawke had 3 different personalities running around inside his head.


Yep. I noticed I was making Lady Hawke a bit inconsistent. I like that you can get different combination in the personality you're trying to role play, and that add re-playability value I think.

#904
TormDK

TormDK
  • Members
  • 1 152 messages
I had a few artifacts running the demo at 1080p on PC, but other than that it felt pretty decent.



So I'll keep my preorder, even with the stunt EA pulled with the elite version - Bioware remember to slam EA's marketing people next time there's a social event at work :P

#905
orjerby

orjerby
  • Members
  • 5 messages
Why in dx9 i can choose only low or normal? i cant choose high and very high...
WHY?
and i cant even choose dx10.

#906
shedevil3001

shedevil3001
  • Members
  • 2 988 messages
i loved it, even if i died with my fave class *rogue* but mages wow awesome, i cant wait for the game to be released. fantastic job bioware :} *hopes nathaniel is in da2 somewhere* :}

#907
Jonk84

Jonk84
  • Members
  • 5 messages
360



I dug it. I've played through it twice, once as a warrior and once as rogue. I can't wait to get my grubby mits on it.



My only question is will the Codexes (Codi?) work the same way as they did in the first one? I really enjoyed all the backstory and the depth of the game but the best part was when you picked up a codex you could hit select and it took you directly to the newest codex. I really hope the quick access feature stays.



Actually, I guess I have two questions; how many downloads are you up to? I want those two unlockables!

#908
lorderezar

lorderezar
  • Members
  • 20 messages
All I can say is WOW! The Rogue and Warrior feel like completely different classes than what they were in Dragon Age: Origins. Both are much more fun to play and I had a blast especially with the Rogue, which was the weakest class in Origins. Great job, can't wait to get the whole game.

#909
Rojar_Paren

Rojar_Paren
  • Members
  • 16 messages
biggest thing that annoyed me was the ground was covered with graphic artifacting. (hope it isnt my 6 month old 470...) funnily enough the artifacting vanished whenever there was a cutscene in the same place, and yes I got the newest drivers.



pc version

#910
Melca36

Melca36
  • Members
  • 5 810 messages

Varhjhin wrote...

I can see, why people who liked the good old round based party rpgs, and Dragon Age for it's (partial) return to that system, are put off by DA2.
I personally liked the demo very much, and I don't regret pre ordering the game.
But I pretty much like any sub-genre of rpg anyway.


I agree. I was not expecting a direct sequel and the changes in the skill trees really improve the gameplay.

People just hate change.

#911
groundhogie

groundhogie
  • Members
  • 173 messages
My opinion... only one rogue playthrough so far.

The combat is fun and I can see it being much more tactical on higher difficulty settings and character levels, the combat animations in particular I found much better than Origins... no more running towards an enemy with that stick-up-your-arse shuffle. I had some stuttering animations when my PC ran though which got on my nerves.

Graphically, well, I was playing with DirectX 9, 1680 x 1050 resolution with 2x AA and I found it decent enough. Game graphics are at the bottom of the pile for me when judging a game however so others may not be as content with it as I was, but then those folks likely have better graphic cards than me. The blight lands was very, very brown... but then it's blighted aint it? Dialogue was solid, nice to see Flemeth Janeway back for the sequel.
:P

I had one crash at the very end of the demo so I wasn't able to chat with Isabella but other than that it ran smooth and stable. My pre-order is staying, err, ordered.

#912
almasy919

almasy919
  • Members
  • 34 messages
Ooooh, the stench of entitlement just blew me over. Bioware has no duty to make sure their games cater to one subset group of RPG gamers (an annoying one at that) just because they seem to have some eternal hard on for BG.

Still waiting for PSN to update.

Modifié par almasy919, 22 février 2011 - 10:52 .


#913
Karaya One

Karaya One
  • Members
  • 7 messages
Dear All:

Played the PC version of the demo for an hour as a male mage; as background, I played through the PC version of DA:O three times. Not that
impressed with the new direction of the franchise. I enjoyed DA:O and,
until reading about the planned changes for the game, was also looking forward
to DA 2. I recognize that this is only a demo, and obviously lacks some
features, but the game seems much too simple and much more of a click-fest (or
button-mash for the console-inclined) than DA:O. Although certain portions
of the game do look superior to DA:O , simple walking animations still look
stiff and the death animations -- which I thought would be quite the spectacle
given the attention being given to the new 'visceral' style of the game -- were
dull as the magic effect would cloud the enemy(ies) and the magic 'effect' would
then be replaced cloud of blood. From what I saw, nothing was on par to
when Alistair first executed a finishing move on the Ogre at the top of
Ostagar. Moreover, the camera is pretty annoying and the inability to zoom the
camera in probably my biggest complaint with the game.

Again, I don't want to kill the game because it's only a demo, but it did
seem like the spell system was simplified and the overall number of spells was
reduced. Leaving aside the substance of the new spell system, I strongly
dislike the new menu system for the spells; as with many other aspects of the
game, a greater than emphasis seems to have been placed on style rather than
substance or functionality. Also, the new mage attacks, although flashy,
eventually began to become as boring as the older animations. 

Although, given the level of vitriol, I am chary to wade into the argument
as to the dumbing-down of the game, I will say that I profoundly
disappointed with Bioware's decision to fundamentally alter many aspects of the
game. Unlike others, I am not suggesting that there is only a single way
to play an RPG and I respect people who dislike BG II (or even
DA:O) and are finding the demo quite enjoyable. Although I can only speak
for myself, the problem is that I was expecting so much more not only
because the game is supposed to be a sequel to DA:O (a great game in its own
right) but because it's developed by Bioware. I still remember being 13
years old and saving up enough money to get BG II and later ToB and
sinking so many hours into those games. The amount of abilities, options and
spells was staggering; I think people get angry about the changes in DA 2
because they resent being forced to either play something radically different
from traditional RPGs or having to suffer the inferior graphics and other idiosyncrasies
(to put it politely) of older games like BG II or IWD. I'm left
wondering why can't Bioware simply develop a modern version of BG II?

Put differently, if DA 2 was being developed by someone other than Bioware,
I wouldn't have the same reaction. I would read about the game, play
the demo and, finding it not to be my cup of tea, move on and play something
else.  Moreover, I think certain aspects of DA2 are entertaining; for
example, there is something to be said for having a game where the player can
utterly massacre the opposition (like the first scene from the demo) as, in
moderation, it is quite fun. The reason I, and I suspect many others,
am writing on the forum is that I was hoping for so much more because DA2 is a
Bioware game. This anticipation was only heightened when the game in question
was the sequel to the game that was perceived by many to be the spiritual
successor to one of the greatest games (and greatest RPG) of all time.

Perhaps I am just romanticizing the past and clinging to things that no
longer exist. That I would spend my limited time writing this demonstrates how
much this issue affects me and I suppose that venting about the
disappointment I am experiencing provides a sort of catharsis. I do
wonder, however, whether I should hold Bioware in the same standing as I was
profoundly disappointed with the changes in ME2 and, from my brief experience
with the demo, am disappointed by DA2.

I probably will purchase DA2 sometime in the future but will probably wait
until there is a sale or some other discount. I think, for the time being,
I'll be happier with a reinstall of BG II and the Darkest Day...



Regards,


(edited to fix some funky formatting)

Modifié par Karaya One, 22 février 2011 - 10:53 .


#914
Amioran

Amioran
  • Members
  • 1 416 messages

Siven80 wrote...

[PC]

Ok, at the start of, and during cutscenes the game kept pausing for a sec or 2 and then loading, i assume its a bug and have posted in the tech forum about that anyway.


Try to use DX11 render. It happens in some machines with DX9 (happened to me too) in first part of the demo.

I guess it only happens if you have a DX10/11 card and you use DX9, maybe only for Win Vista/7 (don't have XP to try).

Modifié par Amioran, 22 février 2011 - 10:55 .


#915
stephen1493

stephen1493
  • Members
  • 908 messages

almasy919 wrote...

Ooooh, the stench of entitlement just blew me over. Bioware has no duty to make sure their games cater to one subset group of RPG gamers (an annoying one at that) just because they seem to have some eternal hard on for BG.

ummmm this is a feedback thread.

Bioware wants to hear criticism man.

Modifié par stephen1493, 22 février 2011 - 10:53 .


#916
TormDK

TormDK
  • Members
  • 1 152 messages

Rojar_Paren wrote...

biggest thing that annoyed me was the ground was covered with graphic artifacting. (hope it isnt my 6 month old 470...) funnily enough the artifacting vanished whenever there was a cutscene in the same place, and yes I got the newest drivers.

pc version


Aye, same - I have an 480GTX though.

#917
jamskinner

jamskinner
  • Members
  • 339 messages

Bhav wrote...

Twaddlefish wrote...

 I just personally think it's time to move to other developers, RIP Bioware.


Like who? It's not like Bethesda are leading lights in the area of not taking stuff out of games...


http://us.blizzard.com/diablo3/

http://www.thewitcher.com/

http://www.magickagame.com/

http://www.guildwars2.com/en/

Just to name a few.

oh so diablo is considered and RPG but not DA2.  Sure is a lot of choice in diable games.  Kill a billion enemies
and hope one of them randomly drops something I need.  Haul a bunch of useless stuff around just for the money.  Dang, that sure sounds like a lot of fun.  Also absolutely no dialogue options. Yea.

#918
Indriju

Indriju
  • Members
  • 21 messages
Im just going to add my two cents quickly because most people have already said what I think far better than I could.

Good: Combat animation, combat in general (at least on a PC/ Rogue class) and graphics worked well.

Bad: The massive ****** on Isabela (im a dude and even I dont want to see that. It feels like Bioware, a dev ive loved almost every game they've put out, have perceived that their target audience is no longer "high brow" hardcore RPG gamers but juvenile, acne encrusted boys sitting in their bedroom playing games with the door locked. Even the way the demo ended, the promise of sex felt like some marketing head thought that one up. Disappointing, and that makes me incredibly sad. Maybe im reading too much into it...I dunno, but it is what it is I guess. I didnt like the running animation, the pathing was messed up (as someone mentioned about the archers) and Im thinking that the reason the story suddenly became all disjointed and choppy was because it was a demo, yes? I mean...theres no way they would release the game with a rush through of plot like that....is there?

#919
Guest_makalathbonagin_*

Guest_makalathbonagin_*
  • Guests
i love it :D

#920
Ulathar

Ulathar
  • Members
  • 2 842 messages
I played as a Rogue which I usually don't do or rather try, but cancel after a while because I don't like the style. Surprisingly, though, playing as an archer was rather fun here. So, well done BW, well done.



I'll still play Mage first, though :D

#921
Mengtzu

Mengtzu
  • Members
  • 258 messages
Having played the demo it's clearly the same underlying system but with superior playability and much better class balance.



I'm now extremely eager to see a toolset update, because I would LOVE to make boss encounters for this iteration of Dragon Age.

#922
Aldaris951

Aldaris951
  • Members
  • 364 messages
Demo is horrible. Bad voice acting except for flemmith. We are suppost to care forcharacters that die when we only see them for 2min? Origins was the last good game this bioware team made. Awakening and witch hunt were awful too.

#923
Raraptor

Raraptor
  • Members
  • 176 messages
After playing all the classes I can honestly say I love each one. Rogue was a surprise, I found it dull in DAO but here it's a LOT more fun to play. The gameplay is fast-paced and lots of fun. I might actually play as a rogue my first play through for a change. Thanks Bioware, you guys are awesome!

#924
sharktejo

sharktejo
  • Members
  • 1 messages
The first game is way better, i still hope bioware resolves a lot of issues before the release because this is so bugged that it hurts, the pc controls with mouse + keyboard are so lagged that the char, always do the wrong moves at the wrong time, the graphics it seems that were choped down so more players can play the game in low end machines, but at least you should work the scenarios better. and the loadings between scenes, really? that is something from the past, i never saw a bioware sequel that disapointed me, but i'm afraid that this will be the one.

I'm still hoping this demo is based in a pre-beta version and the final version will be way better, because now i'm afraid of pre-order this one until some good reviews are out.



No Kudos for this one. (at least right now)

#925
RPatton82

RPatton82
  • Members
  • 9 messages
I thought the demo was fantastic but I thought it was confusing story as where all this going as I thought you get to explore your town with seeing father, mother,etc. in their city like 1st DA before they fought their way out of the city to the mountain.



I think they skip the story part and randomly mix the story to make it confusing , right?