135 réponses à ce sujet

[DivineSolid]

I agree. I just cant let sweet, cute Beth die. Sorry Carver... your the scapegoat.

[cactusberry]

I like Carver better than Bethany.

And I like Mages best.

Win-win for me.

[Cazlee]

He's a good brother and soldier, and he's handsome too. Shame that all the men died in my female Hawke run. D:

[2kgnsiika]

disregard this

Modifié par 2kgnsiika, 24 février 2011 - 01:36 .

[LPPrince]

Carver dies- Bethany sounds like she's about to burst out crying at the end of her sentence about Carver not wanting his sacrifice to be in vain.



Bethany dies- Carver's all like, "Whatever broseph/brosephine."

[Hellosanta]

Queen-Of-Stuff wrote...

Is Carver really that bad, though? I mean, he seemed a bit grumpy, but considering their situation that's understandable. Whenever I click on him, he says things like "you should catch your breath while you can" and "I'll keep watch if you need to stop for a while". Doesn't seem like things a complete douche would say.

I like Bethany and think her design is more eyecatching than Carver's, but I'll still roll a mage for my first playthrough.
And second.
And maybe third.

Yeah, right-clicking him in the field, was one of the thing i enjoyed in the demo. I just had that feeling of Carver trying to be strong in such desperate situation.

[2kgnsiika]

I really hated this mechanic because it takes control away from the player in a patronizing way. It also imposes completely useless limitations on the way you can play the game. BW games are supposed to be about meaningful choices and consequences. I hope it's just a demo thing and in the actual game you get to choose.

[Hellosanta]

2kgnsiika wrote...

I really hated this mechanic because it takes control away from the player in a patronizing way. It also imposes completely useless limitations on the way you can play the game. BW games are supposed to be about meaningful choices and consequences. I hope it's just a demo thing and in the actual game you get to choose.

I'm sorry but it will be in the main game as well. Dev said this mechanic served for party balance as well as plot maker.

[Cazlee]

Yeah, due to the nature of the upcoming war, it seems very important that either you or your surviving sibling is a mage to make your decisions tough.

Modifié par Cazlee, 24 février 2011 - 02:03 .

[Grunk]

He's not bad. I think he looks like he's kin to the Addams family, though. Honestly, for me it came down to the outfits. I think Bethany's outfit looks cooler.



Ideally, though, I'll be using Merrill. Unless she doesn't have heal spells.



But I guess I could have two mages. Ehh. I dunno.

[Cros1404]

I actually like Carver better. He just seems more fun to me. Bethany looks like one of those people, who takes stupid things seriously, so you have to be nice all the time around her... and being nice is no fun for me.

or maybe i just want to be different...

Modifié par Cros1404, 24 février 2011 - 02:18 .

[My Avatar is a Lizard]

Deathispink wrote...

I like Bethany better than Carver? 

Have you not heard her voice?

[TwistedComplex]

In other news Kaden is STILL dead on Vermire because everyone hates the male companion

[LexXxich]

I will play mage, at least the first time, but in DA2 they are quite less fun compared to Origins. Archer rogues got all the oomph.

[Hellosanta]

TwistedComplex wrote...

In other news Kaden is STILL dead on Vermire because everyone hates the male companion

Since I'm female player, I prefer the male companion than the female

[DivineSolid]

Hellosanta wrote...

TwistedComplex wrote...

In other news Kaden is STILL dead on Vermire because everyone hates the male companion

Since I'm female player, I prefer the male companion than the female

What she said... but reversed. 

[Fidget6]

TwistedComplex wrote...

In other news Kaden is STILL dead on Vermire because everyone hates the male companion

Actually I think Ash gets a lot more hate than Kaiden. I personally think Kaiden is the hottest LI that's ever been offered in any Bioware game. 

[kjdhgfiliuhwe]

Let's put it this way. I blame Carver 100% for why it took so long to escape from Ostagar and reach Lothering so late. It's obvious Bethany feels the same way. If one of the siblings has to die, I'll choose the incompetent one.

[Clonedzero]

Bethany seems like the nice, sweet supportive sister. I.E boring.



Carver however seems like he'll challenge your decisions, and has that whole "im secretly super jealous of your super powers magic abilties" thing going on. making for a much more interesting relationship.



so i like carver alot more. once i recruit anders or merril bethany is getting benched with my warrior. however on my mage i might keep carver in there the whole time (might just be because im not crazy about fenris lol)

[31416]

Fidget6 wrote...

31416 wrote...

So Bethany dies if you play mage.. Good to know. I think I go back to DA:O while waiting for Witcher 2

If she didn't there would be four mages. You could have a party consisting of all mages! So it's best for party balance really.

So a player could choose to have a less than optimal party composition. We can't have that!!

I like the freedom to choose according to my likes/dislikes and no because of the demands of game mechanics. Sometimes in DA:o you had to pick a party to do a certain task (kill a dragon etc.), but fortunately not very often. I want the right to choose badly.

Modifié par 31416, 24 février 2011 - 03:14 .

[GunClubGirl]

I actually enjoyed playing mage the most, but won't in the full game because I like Bethany. I will probably have her in my party most of the time.

[DraCZeQQ]

kjdhgfiliuhwe wrote...

Let's put it this way. I blame Carver 100% for why it took so long to escape from Ostagar and reach Lothering so late. It's obvious Bethany feels the same way. If one of the siblings has to die, I'll choose the incompetent one.

i like your style! 

[LPPrince]

An all mage party would get messed up real quick.

[Elsariel]

I will play mage first because I think Carver's antagonism will be interesting. Also, I think being a mage in DA2 might lend some complexities given what little I know of the plot.