Grumpy Old Wizard wrote...
Baelyn wrote...
He/She-Hawke is an APOSTATE....not classically trained Circle magi...I think the fighting style much more fits this background...Apostates didn't learn the proper "manners" someone like Wynn would expect. He grew up in a rough life (as far as we can tell) and had to teach himself how to fend for himself so a staff/fighting style would make much more sense than acting exactly like someone who had been trained from 5 years old in an isolated tower about history and classical magic.
Apostate mage does not imply gish and has nothing to do with "proper manners." Apostate merely means a mage not trained by the circle. An "unsanctioned" mage.
You are misunderstanding my intent with "manners" hence why I quoted it as it was to be used loosely. An earlier poster made a statement about how Wynn would feel about mages engaging in combat in this staff fighting style as if to imply that they were being sloppy and not being proper in their use of magic. I would think of it as how someone who learned how to fend for himself on the street with a blade in contrast to a knight who was trained in the proper stances and steps, a polished swordsman.
An apostate could consist of several different backgrounds...for example with Anders...someone who was in the Circle but defected and escaped in which case he did have some formal training (albeit his rogue attitude may contribute to his fighting style but this has yet to be seen). Where as in Hawke's situation, someone with magical ability who has been hidden away from the Circle their entire life that has had to basically learn on his own and fend for himself. I imagine a young Hawke who still hasn't truly mastered the art of magic trying to defend his family in whatever way he can and developing this style.
Of course all of this is conjecture and ultimately it comes down to what style you prefer in a mage, but I don't think that anyone can argue that this doesn't "fit."