4Aces wrote...
I think you misinterpreted what I was saying - I was refering to the people saying that they were going to use their mage in melee based on the demo. They would go down very quickly in a real battle. I did not study all the rogue skills so I did not see the threat redirection. How the heck does that work?!
I was comparing it direcly to the other classes. Perhaps you should take a look at them, and then realize that the enemy is based on them as well. So you will be facing the darkspawn equiavlents of warrior and rogue, so having either one of them as the primary character (barring some great top tier spells) will be much more effective and therfore desirable for people to play. You seem to think that I was unduely negative, but I was just comparing what I saw in both text descriptiong and effectiveness on the battlefield.
My rogue was just as good as the mage at low levels, and was better at high (when the mage was turned into a pincushuion by a few bolter). The warrior was the master at all levels with better abilities, taking much less damage, and having faster, more successful stun attacks. Sure it is a part affair, so having a healing mage as 'backup' is a good idea. Wasting the main character on one is not what I had in mind. Also remember that you cannot change the armor on companions (runes possibly but not the really good stuff anymore). So mage seems to be much less appealing in DA2 though if you only ever play them, that is fine. Just spend a bit to raise your health and do not act surprised if they go down faster than in DAO. At least they cut the injury kits. 
@addal67 - Fireball does not do nearly as much damage nor does it set people on fire (duration damage) as the standard. I used cone of fire all the time since it not only did immediate damage, but stacked the duration damage on top. So cone of cold to freeze, cone of fire to light them up, and a fireball just as they begin to thaw which not only knociks them down but gives them a second set of duration fire damage. If they were still alive then a cone of electricity and just about everyone is down, and the rest will soon be (as they burn X 2). It was low level and worked very well. Now we have to buy burning for our fire.
Firestorm is random. That is not better. It is different. It has less particles on the screen so there is less lag, so that is good. But I would not say it is better. It does not seem to do the same damage that firestorm used to, but being random makes it tricky once again. I suspect that you need the pyromancer addon (another point gone) to get the full damage that we had with firestorm. Once we get into the ERFs I am sure someone will do a database analysis of this and we will know for sure. All I am saying is what I saw between DAO (finished last week) and DA2's demo (played multiple times yesterday).
I owned the field with the 2HD warrior. I took the second orgre and many of the Hurlocks by myself - just to see if I could. In my first playthough I got caught by the potion bug (telling the female templar to drink a heath potion does not always work as her tactics override it) and my mage had to finish it off (about 10% of its health left). It cost me 5 heath potions and twice I nearly died. The freezing spells did not last long, and the damage was minimal (I think the staff was better and outright spell damage due to the high rate of fire). I was actually glad to see the nerfed the ogre since it did not perform the grab & pummel animation or else I would have been mage salsa. Pommel strike turmps Freezing in both chance to succeed and duration.
Fireball indeed is not as good as it was. That said we still have not fully speced it and it did set them aflame for a short period of time(sometimes), for very little damage.
Firestorm actually worked very well. It rains fireballs down randomly that knock people down and set the aflame. On top of that it had a fast casting time so it's a win win in my book.
I might be able to build a tank mage, that focuses on spell damage, depending on certian spells and specialization combos. There is still hope at least heh.