170 réponses à ce sujet

[blaidfiste]

Nope. Playing the demo, trying to get at least 3 good DAO playthroughs in before release.

[Obadiah]

Game got a 94 in this month's PC Gamer. Can't be all bad.

[astreqwerty]

completely..not buying for sure

[rob_k]

Suron wrote...

so very high 80's to low 90's is "mediocre"????

ok then.....

I"m not that impressed by the demo either..nor do I like a lot of the changes and shortcuts and dumbing down.

but you're seriously grasping here aren't ya

Anything over a 90 is a paid for review.

Anything below a 90 is mediocre.

Didn't ya know? (Some logic the web has)

I think there's one other review of 84, from a german magazine. Still, only 3 reviews would indicate it's too premature to make a judgement. Plus, I don't even think 84 and 88 are bad.

Honestly though, I don't think Twisted was saying they were mediocre. I could be wrong, but I don't think he was.

[Emyer]

My interest has been going down the more is revealed about the game, the fact that this game completely disappeared from my map for a while until I saw a news in a site that said a demo was out should speak for itself, that said I haven't completely lost interest for it, it's just not a game where I'm counting the seconds till release, I'll probably get it eventually after launch or with all the DLC bundled in an "Ultimate Edition"

[Dutch105]

xnoxiousx wrote...

Obadiah wrote...

Game got a 94 in this month's PC Gamer. Can't be all bad.

Call of duty black ops got a high score as well so whats your point?

Not within PC Gamer UK.  They scored it 64.  Conversely, Dragon Age 2 scored 94.

[Black-Xero]

xnoxiousx wrote...

Obadiah wrote...

Game got a 94 in this month's PC Gamer. Can't be all bad.

Call of duty black ops got a high score as well so whats your point?

What's your point? Many loved Black Ops.

[Zaknaberrnon]

I will wait for the full game to form my opinion. the demo es from a pre-beta or beta version of the game and definitely not a good source to establish your opinion from.

I for one liked the demo quite a bit, even though i do agree the darkspawn IN THE DEMO are generic and uninteresting. but hey its a demo, wouldn't be suprised if in the game they are more or less like in DAO.

[Albatroz]

xnoxiousx wrote...

Obadiah wrote...

Game got a 94 in this month's PC Gamer. Can't be all bad.

Call of duty black ops got a high score as well so whats your point?

CODBLOPS is a fun, well made, extremely polished game and deserves a high score. Just because you don't like it doesn't make it a bad game. I don't like FPSs that much (because I'm horrible at them) but I still recognize BLOPS as a good game. Its the same with DA2. You may not like the direction the game is headed, but that doesn't stop it from being a good game, it just makes it a game you're not fond of.

[Obadiah]

xnoxiousx wrote...

Obadiah wrote...

Game got a 94 in this month's PC Gamer. Can't be all bad.

Call of duty black ops got a high score as well so whats your point?

Since Call of Duty: Black Ops is good, perhaps Dragon Age 2 is as well.

[Black-Xero]

xnoxiousx wrote...

Black-Xero wrote...

xnoxiousx wrote...

Obadiah wrote...

Game got a 94 in this month's PC Gamer. Can't be all bad.

Call of duty black ops got a high score as well so whats your point?

What's your point? Many loved Black Ops.

Many people like justin beiber does that mean he deserves album of the year?

Why not? He's liked by many so he must be good in their eyes.Just because you hate him doesn't mean everyone has to.I don't enjoy his music but I don't mind him singing or being famous.It's what he does and he likes it.

[The Elder King]

rob_k wrote...

Suron wrote...

so very high 80's to low 90's is "mediocre"????

ok then.....

I"m not that impressed by the demo either..nor do I like a lot of the changes and shortcuts and dumbing down.

but you're seriously grasping here aren't ya

Anything over a 90 is a paid for review.

Anything below a 90 is mediocre.

Didn't ya know? (Some logic the web has)

I think there's one other review of 84, from a german magazine. Still, only 3 reviews would indicate it's too premature to make a judgement. Plus, I don't even think 84 and 88 are bad.

Honestly though, I don't think Twisted was saying they were mediocre. I could be wrong, but I don't think he was.

The two german review rated DA2 87 and 88. Swedish PC Games rated DA2 85. Plus the UK PC Gamer (or Games) review that rated it 94

[Black-Xero]

xnoxiousx wrote...

So i guess hilter was also a great man and we should also follow his views if we go by what you say.

It depends on your view about his goals and/or his actions.

Modifié par Black-Xero, 27 février 2011 - 04:29 .

[The Elder King]

Great, now we're comparing a singer with a dictator. Way to go. :S

[John Epler]

Congratulations, thread. You've managed to Godwin discussion about review scores.

I am speechless.

Locking, as this has turned into bickering, but still. Wow.

[Obadiah]

xnoxiousx wrote...

Black-Xero wrote...

xnoxiousx wrote...

Black-Xero wrote...

xnoxiousx wrote...

Obadiah wrote...

Game got a 94 in this month's PC Gamer. Can't be all bad.

Call of duty black ops got a high score as well so whats your point?

What's your point? Many loved Black Ops.

Many people like justin beiber does that mean he deserves album of the year?

Why not? He's liked by many so he must be good in their eyes.Just because you hate him doesn't mean everyone has to.I don't enjoy his music but I don't mind him singing or being famous.It's what he does and he likes it.

So i guess hilter was also a great man and we should also follow his views if we go by what you say.

Dunno, did PC Gamer give Hitler a 94?

[rob_k]

Bad example, X.

Besides, the guy has no place being mentioned on the forum.

Also, reviews are opinions. What would you rate Origins? If you'd give it a high score, I could just quite as easily say what you did about Black Ops.

Opinions are fun, aren't they? (And yes, I enjoy Origins and would probably rate it high as well. I just wanted to make a point.)