Aller au contenu

Photo

Where are the reviews?


74 réponses à ce sujet

#26
Darji

Darji
  • Members
  • 410 messages

Chris Priestly wrote...

iamrawn wrote...

Seriously?! Gamespot, IGN, Gametrailers? Is EA keeping the review hidden cos it's bad or saink?


I love this.

Yes, it IS a big conspiracy. You are SO smart to have caught us. Well done Mulder.




:devil:

It may be not tre in this case I dont know but you guys must admitt that this kind of stuff happens alot with reviews. And its not only the if my game gets a high rating you can publish it before the actual embargo ends its also about bribes. For example the Halo3 850$ reviewer version.

Honestly I dont understand how you people can think that holding back reviews until the release date is good for sales. Of course if you think your game is bad and wont get the scores you wanted then I would hold it back to. But not if you are confident with your work.

Modifié par Darji, 07 mars 2011 - 08:17 .


#27
MadLaughter

MadLaughter
  • Members
  • 329 messages
Formspring.com/jeffgerstmann

go there. Veteran reviewer of major site says that they didn't even get a review copy, and thar it seems to be a trend with EA when they have a lot riding on their games.

#28
Lethys1

Lethys1
  • Members
  • 521 messages
A game that PC Gamer gave a 94/100 will not get terrible reviews from other sites.

#29
Reconfire89

Reconfire89
  • Members
  • 117 messages

Chris Priestly wrote...

iamrawn wrote...

Seriously?! Gamespot, IGN, Gametrailers? Is EA keeping the review hidden cos it's bad or saink?


I love this.

Yes, it IS a big conspiracy. You are SO smart to have caught us. Well done Mulder.




:devil:



You just dun gone and made me want to watch the X-Files, Mr. Priestly.

I hope you're happy. >:(

#30
Jamie_edmo

Jamie_edmo
  • Members
  • 270 messages

Chris Priestly wrote...

iamrawn wrote...

Seriously?! Gamespot, IGN, Gametrailers? Is EA keeping the review hidden cos it's bad or saink?


I love this.

Yes, it IS a big conspiracy. You are SO smart to have caught us. Well done Mulder.




:devil:


X-Files Reference lol

#31
anzurose

anzurose
  • Members
  • 57 messages
Haha, you guys... the reviews will come, don't stress. The websites are probably just still under embargo from EA.

#32
Darji

Darji
  • Members
  • 410 messages

TelvanniWarlord wrote...

Darji wrote...

TelvanniWarlord wrote...

ah yes, any review that doesn't match anyone's pre conceived notions of the game must either be..

a) complete BS
OR
B) a bias review w/ a bribe attached


Somehow I think that even if all the reviews were positive, the nay sayers would still be nay saying.

No but not most reivews thats get out early and have such a high score a bull****. We already know the actions developer take for good reviews and how you can publish your review earlier than others.

Many policies are if you rate it 90 or so you can release it early if not you have to wait.


Not the case always; one German review gave the game an 87 and was pretty harsh in it's specifics.



In germany a 87 is a pretty good score in a PC magazine. They dont throw 9 and 10 at every game like most US magazines and essepcially console ones.

#33
ToJKa1

ToJKa1
  • Members
  • 1 246 messages

TelvanniWarlord wrote...

ah yes, any review that doesn't match anyone's pre conceived notions of the game must either be..

a) complete BS
OR
B) a bias review w/ a bribe attached

Somehow I think that even if all the reviews were positive, the nay sayers would still be nay saying.



From my experience (shamelesly quoting a person from another forum ^_^):

Positive reviews of games I like = Quality, honest reviews.

Positive reviews of games I don't like = Reviewer was bribed.

Negative reviews of games I don't like = Proves I was right.

Negative reviews of games I like = Reviewer doesn't know anything/mad he wasn't bribed/was bribed by another publisher.

#34
Wygrath

Wygrath
  • Members
  • 297 messages

Chris Priestly wrote...

iamrawn wrote...

Seriously?! Gamespot, IGN, Gametrailers? Is EA keeping the review hidden cos it's bad or saink?


I love this.

Yes, it IS a big conspiracy. You are SO smart to have caught us. Well done Mulder.




:devil:


This proves it. You're helping to hide the truth with your subterfuge. 

I've now come to the shocking conclusion that Bioware has become a part of the Shadow Government that is trying to bring about the New World Order and put all the potential dissenters in concentration camps.

This is the first of many strikes that will lead to Armageddon. I'm just glad that I've seen the truth in time to put a stop to your evil ways. 

#35
android654

android654
  • Members
  • 6 105 messages
http://www.pcgamer.c...rd-in-pc-gamer/

Our Dragon Age 2 review is in, and we’ve given it a score worthy of an Editor’s Choice award, calling it “darkier, sexier, better.

Satisfying, lightning-fast combat and spectacular spacial moves helped Dragon Age 2 to take the PC Gamer Editor’s Choice award, but the game excelled in other areas, too. A conversation system that doesn’t restrict you with an arbitrary morality meter and the huge, evolving city of Kirkwall help to fill Dragon Age 2 with “more character and vitality than any title in recent memory”.


Bioware never fails to deliver. Just like Me2 dominated 2010 in every RPG corner, DA2 is going to annihilate any competition that comes out before December 31 (supposed release date for ME3).

#36
Baelyn

Baelyn
  • Members
  • 785 messages

Darji wrote...
No but not most reivews thats get out early and have such a high score a bull****. We already know the actions developer take for good reviews and how you can publish your review earlier than others. 

Many policies are if you rate it 90 or so you can release it early if not you have to wait.


Care to provide some proof with that statement? Just sayin.

#37
PhrosniteAgainROFL

PhrosniteAgainROFL
  • Members
  • 453 messages
Dunno... I'm kind of worried considering that the game became gold a few weeks ago... Why weren't review copies sent to the gaming sites?

Modifié par PhrosniteAgainROFL, 07 mars 2011 - 08:25 .


#38
TheConfidenceMan

TheConfidenceMan
  • Members
  • 244 messages
http://ramraider.blo...ge-embargo.html

#39
Atilius the Hun

Atilius the Hun
  • Members
  • 117 messages

Chris Priestly wrote...

iamrawn wrote...

Seriously?! Gamespot, IGN, Gametrailers? Is EA keeping the review hidden cos it's bad or saink?


I love this.

Yes, it IS a big conspiracy. You are SO smart to have caught us. Well done Mulder.




:devil:


That's it!  I'm defriend you, defriending Bioware, EA, Santa Claus and my grandma.  It's the end of the world as we know it.  The game has to be horrid if there are no major site reviews out there by now!

#40
Illthar

Illthar
  • Members
  • 119 messages

Chris Priestly wrote...

iamrawn wrote...

Seriously?! Gamespot, IGN, Gametrailers? Is EA keeping the review hidden cos it's bad or saink?


I love this.

Yes, it IS a big conspiracy. You are SO smart to have caught us. Well done Mulder.




:devil:


Sais the guy with the "illuminati" avatar.....



:devil:;)

#41
JFarr74

JFarr74
  • Members
  • 1 238 messages
There are already 3 reviews for the game listed on Wikipedia. Here they are:

PC Gamer UK magazine highly praised Dragon Age II mentioning the improved combat system, dialogue wheel, skill-trees, and solid storytelling as its strong points. The game earned their "Editor's Choice" award and was stated to be, "The best RPG of this decade? Nine more years will tell, but for now, yes." Official Xbox Magazine gave the game a 9 out of 10 mentioning that although it was slightly altered from its predecessor, the game "offers some of the deepest, nerdiest, most worthwhile 40 to 60 hours you'll ever love losing sleep over."

PC Gamer gave it a 94% and PSM gave it a 9/10.

#42
android654

android654
  • Members
  • 6 105 messages

TheConfidenceMan wrote...

http://ramraider.blo...ge-embargo.html


That was almost 2 years ago, for origins. Five years of work and development makes sense to want to secure as much success as possible. But there's no mention of anything like that for DA2.

Modifié par android654, 07 mars 2011 - 08:29 .


#43
Zlarm

Zlarm
  • Members
  • 143 messages

Chris Priestly wrote...

I love this.

Yes, it IS a big conspiracy. You are SO smart to have caught us. Well done Mulder.




:devil:


You make fun of this and yet it's not unheard of for game companies to work out deals with review sites so that if the review is 8 or less they are not released until later.....

Not saying that this is the case here but it's not an invalid concern.

#44
Darji

Darji
  • Members
  • 410 messages

Baelyn wrote...

Darji wrote...
No but not most reivews thats get out early and have such a high score a bull****. We already know the actions developer take for good reviews and how you can publish your review earlier than others. 

Many policies are if you rate it 90 or so you can release it early if not you have to wait.


Care to provide some proof with that statement? Just sayin.

Sure. If you remeber the Kayne and Lynch disaster. Or I think even Assasins creed had this policy. You can read it alot nowadays.

Recently Two worlds two comes in my mind.

The allegations against Topware are numerous, so it would be best to
simply list them. The following is a rundown of the various stories we
have uncovered over the past few days; do bear in mind that these are
allegations.





* European reviewers have accepted ad buys from Topware in exchange for favorable reviews.


* Topware was caught by IGN attempting to influence the rating score
of IGN's GameStats and inflating Two Worlds II's ranking.


* GameReactor was pressured to take down its Two Worlds II review
because it used preview code to write it. The rub is that more favorable
reviews released at the same time as GameReactor's were not asked to
remove their reviews, despite being based on the same code.


* Topware employees have been writing Amazon reviews, posting
YouTube comments, and posing elsewhere as members of the public to
generate positive feedback on its own products.


* Threats of legal action against one reviewer were made without the
permission of management, and rest entirely on the head of the PR
department. A reviewer was accused of pirating a copy of Two Worlds II
for his negative review, despite having been sent code.


* Destructoid itself was planned to be approached with a bribe.
Topware paid for a Two Worlds II site skin, but withheld half the pay.
The other half was allegedly planned to be paid in exchange for an
8.5/10 review from us.


www.destructoid.com/allegations-sleaze-treachery-a-tale-of-two-worlds-194521.phtml   

And this is really no exception in these day. And the comment from gersterman is also a proof
 that EA is holding reviews back because of the controversial changes this series has made.

And this seems also to apply to origins back than.

Modifié par Darji, 07 mars 2011 - 08:31 .


#45
PhrosniteAgainROFL

PhrosniteAgainROFL
  • Members
  • 453 messages

android654 wrote...

TheConfidenceMan wrote...

http://ramraider.blo...ge-embargo.html


That was almost 2 years ago, for origins. Five years of work and development makes sense to want to secure as much success as possible. But there's no mention of anything like that for DA2.


Not to mention that Origins ended up being a fantasitc game.

#46
RainyDayLover

RainyDayLover
  • Members
  • 1 331 messages

TheConfidenceMan wrote...

http://ramraider.blo...ge-embargo.html


Yeah, but did you read the edit at the end of the post?

#47
David Gaider

David Gaider
  • BioWare Employees
  • 4 514 messages

anzurose wrote...
Haha, you guys... the reviews will come, don't stress.


BUT MY NEED FOR INSTANT GRATIFICATION SAYS THAT ISN'T TODAY OMG

#48
Mick301981

Mick301981
  • Members
  • 91 messages

Chris Priestly wrote...

iamrawn wrote...

Seriously?! Gamespot, IGN, Gametrailers? Is EA keeping the review hidden cos it's bad or saink?


I love this.

Yes, it IS a big conspiracy. You are SO smart to have caught us. Well done Mulder.




:devil:


Off-topic but Scully > Mulder.

Just sayin :P

#49
ACDimps

ACDimps
  • Members
  • 323 messages

David Gaider wrote...

anzurose wrote...
Haha, you guys... the reviews will come, don't stress.


BUT MY NEED FOR INSTANT GRATIFICATION SAYS THAT ISN'T TODAY OMG


I want to be a dragon!!

#50
The Lesser Evil

The Lesser Evil
  • Members
  • 553 messages

David Gaider wrote...

anzurose wrote...
Haha, you guys... the reviews will come, don't stress.


BUT MY NEED FOR INSTANT GRATIFICATION SAYS THAT ISN'T TODAY OMG


Sir, we're going to have to ask you to calm down.