So, something I was considering a few pages back, when you guys were discussing the best route for Anders was Hawke's conscious or unconscious decisions on how to deal with the situation.
We, as the players, can see the changes the Anders goes through between both Friendship and Rivalry, platonic and romanced relationships, templar and mage conclusions. Hawke, obviously, has no awareness of what could have happened had he or she handled Anders in a different manner.
I'm trying to recall the different conversations that my canon Hawke had with Anders on-screen, and how she would have understood the mechanics of the possession. She's not a mage, and therefore has no experience with fade spirits or abominations that aren't flesh beasts that need to be killed on sight. Given how much Anders contradicts himself when speaking of the possession, it's hard for me to come up with a firm opinion on what she might think - possibly she'd be just as frigging confused as I am sometimes.
That said, I think she'd mostly take Anders at his word that he knows what he's doing, and trusts that the choices he's making are his own. It might be oversimplifying, but I can see how a magically untrained Hawke would assume that the only times the spirit is affecting Anders' judgement is when he's got his blue glow on. If he looks normal, then obviously everything is fine. His opinions and hatred of the Circles might be extreme, but plenty of non-possessed people have extreme opinions too. Mood swings? Also totally normal, if frustrating.
Regardless of what would be "best" for him, would she understand that he and the spirit
could conflict at all - let alone that she could have chosen to exacerbate the condition - if she believes that he has full control over his faculties as long as there aren't any physical symptoms?
I need to replay to recall conversations on the topic, and there are the unknown years inbetween to account for, but I could very easily believe that Hawke could have no idea of just how much the possession is able to influence Anders, and is therefore not really able to objectively choose what is best for him in the end.
Also, I want to complain about how much Anders contradicts himself when talking about J/V and how it affects him, and whether that's in character or just sloppy writing, but that's a deer to paint another day.
Modifié par Threeparts, 26 avril 2011 - 10:33 .