57020 réponses à ce sujet

[highcastle]

Queen-Of-Stuff wrote...

highcastle wrote...

That's a good point. Truthfully, I usually send him away at this point because I love the reunion scene at the Gallows and because I see my Hawkes having that initial reaction only to immediately regret it and...alright, getting off topic.

I don't mean to butt in on your conversation or anything, but does anyone have a video of the reunion scene after sending him away? I didn't send him away, because the only healer mage and all that, and I'd rather not play through that bit of the game again.

I didn't see anything on youtube, but perhaps my search fu failed me. At any rate, you're only without Anders for a short period of time. I played as DPS mage, didn't even have a heal spell, and  I still did just fine without him for those couple of areas until you pick him up again. Though in truth, you only get a few more lines of dialogues. He asks if it's alright that he came back, and there might be one more line before it reverts to the same stuff as if you'd kept him. I just like doing it this way because it seems like gut reaction a couple of my Hawkes would have upon finding out the extent of Anders' lies and manipulations.

[ipgd]

Ryzaki wrote...

Again I don't see it that way. 

/shrugs 

It's not that one comment on its own. It's a combination of pretty much everything with him. 

@highcastle: I disagree. Starting a revolution without a foundation to me isn't smart. 

I need to stop getting into these debates. 

Can we move on to something else? Like Andersbutt or something? 

I am not sure why you post if you don't expect people to, uh, respond to you

[Ryzaki]

ipgd wrote...

I am not sure why you post if you don't expect people to, uh, respond to you

 

I only wanted to know if anyone else felt the same. 

Not really a debate just a y/n answer.   

After all the "oh it must be a day ending with "day" comments came from me being too debatey." 

Edit: And Varric is hilarious. "oh you're a mage Hawke...you know about weird ****."  

Modifié par Ryzaki, 31 mai 2011 - 01:13 .

[Miri1984]

ipgd wrote...

Ryzaki wrote...

Again I don't see it that way. 

/shrugs 

It's not that one comment on its own. It's a combination of pretty much everything with him. 

@highcastle: I disagree. Starting a revolution without a foundation to me isn't smart. 

I need to stop getting into these debates. 

Can we move on to something else? Like Andersbutt or something? 

I am not sure why you post if you don't expect people to, uh, respond to you

Um... yeah! This? What I wanted to say.

[ipgd]

Ryzaki wrote...

I only wanted to know if anyone else felt the same. 

Not really a debate just a y/n answer.   

After all the "oh it must be a day ending with "day" comments came from me being too debatey." 

Edit: And Varric is hilarious. "oh you're a mage Hawke...you know about weird ****."  

I'm sure you're well aware that the people who post here like to go beyond 'y/n answers'. And so do you, evidently, so I'm not sure why you say you don't want to argue or say you're done arguing after eveeeerryyyy post you make and then... keep arguing !?!

[Ryzaki]

ipgd wrote...
I'm sure you're well aware that the people who post here like to go beyond 'y/n answers'. And so do you, evidently, so I'm not sure why you say you don't want to argue or say you're done arguing after eveeeerryyyy post you make and then... keep arguing !?!

Did I argue? I was only trying to clairfy my position. Sorry though. Don't mean to cause a debate. 

As for going beyond y/n yes I'm aware of that. I should've clairified that as well. 

[highcastle]

Debates are a large part of this thread. And for the most part and in my general experience, everyone tends to keep a civil tongue on them. There's really no reason to fear sparking one of them--they tend to provoke pretty interesting responses. And I at least enjoy hearing other interpretations.

Part of Anders' purpose is to be divisive. Any time you have a character this complex who does something as big and as world-changing as what he did, it's going to make waves--both in the game world and outside it. So talking about it is kind of the point. Not wanting to participate in the debate is one thing, but don't apologize for starting one. It's cool, I think most of us enjoy it, and I don't think anyone's taking offense (or I hope not anyway).

I know on a personal note that talking to others with views different from my own at least helps me articulate my points...to myself if no one else.

[Miri1984]

@Ryzaki So... next time you'd better write:

"I think Anders is crazy! If you wish to reply, please only agree or disagree with me but don't say anything apart from that because it might spark discussion or debate!"

Modifié par Miri1984, 31 mai 2011 - 01:26 .

[ipgd]

Ryzaki wrote...

ipgd wrote...
I'm sure you're well aware that the people who post here like to go beyond 'y/n answers'. And so do you, evidently, so I'm not sure why you say you don't want to argue or say you're done arguing after eveeeerryyyy post you make and then... keep arguing !?!

Did I argue? I was only trying to clairfy my position. Sorry though. Don't mean to cause a debate. 

there I'm more refering to all of your other posts ever

 the "I'm done arguing wait no i'm not now i'm done arguing wait no i'm not now i'm done arguing wait no i'm not" is a thing you do

[Ryzaki]

Miri1984 wrote...

@Ryzaki So... next time you'd better write:

"I think Anders is crazy! If you wish to reply, please only agree or disagree with me but don't say anything apart from that because it might spark discussion or debate!"

 

I probably should've just made a poll then. I wasn't trying to discourage discussion or debate but merely get a count of how many felt he was insane/sane. 

@igpd: Point. Its a bad habit of mine that I need to break. I am used to debating (minus the "i should stop.") part so I slip into it easily. 

@highcastle: I feel the same way. I just don't feel like being called the "one who b***** because it's a day ending with day again."

Modifié par Ryzaki, 31 mai 2011 - 01:30 .

[Miri1984]

@Ryzaki I would stalk your poll and debate with you in the comments. *nodnodnodnod*

[ipgd]

Ryzaki wrote...

I probably should've just made a poll then. I wasn't trying to discourage discussion or debate but merely get a count of how many felt he was insane/sane.

It's not that simple, though

He's certainly not neurotypical, but he's hardly on the level of psychosis. 'Insane' is a loaded term.

[Ryzaki]

Miri1984 wrote...

@Ryzaki I would stalk your poll and debate with you in the comments. *nodnodnodnod*

 

I have a personal stalker now? Sweet.   

@igpd: Maybe. 

[Miri1984]

@Ryzaki what I'm trying to say is that Ipgd is right - sanity/insanity isn't easily quantifiable, and pretty much depends on your point of view. YOU think Anders is insane because you're coming from the point of view of Ryzaki-Sanity, which is different from Miri1984-Sanity and Ipgd-Sanity. There is no sane, "control" Anders to compare him to, because once you take away the things that you say are making him insane he's no longer Anders and the argument becomes meaningless.

[Ryzaki]

Miri1984 wrote...

@Ryzaki what I'm trying to say is that Ipgd is right - sanity/insanity isn't easily quantifiable, and pretty much depends on your point of view. YOU think Anders is insane because you're coming from the point of view of Ryzaki-Sanity, which is different from Miri1984-Sanity and Ipgd-Sanity. There is no sane, "control" Anders to compare him to, because once you take away the things that you say are making him insane he's no longer Anders and the argument becomes meaningless.

 

I see your point now. 


Offtopic: URGH. I HATE YOU ATI. 

This is the fifth time this week my comp has greyscreened and going back to catalyst 11.3 doesn't work.  Fixed the GSOD issue my ***. Never again will I buy an ATI card. 

[Jean]

I listened to Mage Pride and the first thing I thought is how much it reminded me of Ashenvale and that pretty night elf song it plays there what is this i am losing my grip

[Amondra]

Batteries wrote...

I listened to Mage Pride and the first thing I thought is how much it reminded me of Ashenvale and that pretty night elf song it plays there what is this i am losing my grip

I thought the same thing!!!:happy:

[eleridragon]

Amondra wrote...

Batteries wrote...

I listened to Mage Pride and the first thing I thought is how much it reminded me of Ashenvale and that pretty night elf song it plays there what is this i am losing my grip

I thought the same thing!!!:happy:

I've almost completely quit that game now, I miss the old Ashenvale and Darkshore 

[Amondra]

eleridragon wrote...

Amondra wrote...

Batteries wrote...

I listened to Mage Pride and the first thing I thought is how much it reminded me of Ashenvale and that pretty night elf song it plays there what is this i am losing my grip

I thought the same thing!!!:happy:

I've almost completely quit that game now, I miss the old Ashenvale and Darkshore 

I haven't played in forever(I stopped playing too) but I do love the soundtrack.

[ashyraine]

So I'm a ****** poor artist but I decided to give this a go. Ever since we found out Anders has no butt (at least in game) I wondered if maybe Justice erm... filled in as it were. And this monstrosity was born:


Due to my lack of scaling and perspective Justice has a bubble booty haha

[MG800]

ashyraine wrote...

So I'm a ****** poor artist but I decided to give this a go. Ever since we found out Anders has no butt (at least in game) I wondered if maybe Justice erm... filled in as it were. And this monstrosity was born:


Due to my lack of scaling and perspective Justice has a bubble booty haha

Damm, I don't care about everything else, the concept is brilliant !

[eleridragon]

ashyraine wrote...

So I'm a ****** poor artist but I decided to give this a go. Ever since we found out Anders has no butt (at least in game) I wondered if maybe Justice erm... filled in as it were. And this monstrosity was born:

<snipped awesome>

Due to my lack of scaling and perspective Justice has a bubble booty haha

Magically delicious but touching it would be unjust, so unfair!

*hugs Ashy*

[elenilote]

eleridragon wrote...

ashyraine wrote...

So I'm a ****** poor artist but I decided to give this a go. Ever since we found out Anders has no butt (at least in game) I wondered if maybe Justice erm... filled in as it were. And this monstrosity was born:

<snipped awesome>

Due to my lack of scaling and perspective Justice has a bubble booty haha

Magically delicious but touching it would be unjust, so unfair!

*hugs Ashy*

::group hug:: 

It is lovely ashy, really is! 

[CulturalGeekGirl]

The upthread discussion of sanity made me think of one of my favorite quotes ever: 

"And, isn't sanity really just a one-trick pony anyway? I mean all you get is one trick, rational thinking... but when you're good and crazy, the sky is the limit."

Somehow I can hear Awakening Anders saying that, while DA2 Anders... he lives it.

Modifié par CulturalGeekGirl, 31 mai 2011 - 06:51 .