Aller au contenu

Photo

The Anders Thread: Flash Fic Contest! Details on Pg. 2274


57020 réponses à ce sujet

#44051
Guest_Queen-Of-Stuff_*

Guest_Queen-Of-Stuff_*
  • Guests

highcastle wrote...

I don't know how much antibiotics count as the "good stuff," but hey, I'm feeling pretty good! :D


... Antibiotics? :(

Aw. And here I was getting all excited and everything. I suppose I'll have to put all of my hippie gear back in place and resort to simply burrowing my face in my kitten's fur.

#44052
highcastle

highcastle
  • Members
  • 1 963 messages

Queen-Of-Stuff wrote...

highcastle wrote...

I don't know how much antibiotics count as the "good stuff," but hey, I'm feeling pretty good! :D


... Antibiotics? :(

Aw. And here I was getting all excited and everything. I suppose I'll have to put all of my hippie gear back in place and resort to simply burrowing my face in my kitten's fur.


Kittens are far superior to drugs. Anders would agree.

http://yamisnuffles....-Mage-208703612Posted Image

by Yami, of course.

Modifié par highcastle, 11 juin 2011 - 08:12 .


#44053
Nivilant

Nivilant
  • Members
  • 226 messages
Wow, it has been waaay too long since I stopped by. The place has grown! Huzzah!

I wondered how many people had remained Fanders for this long.

#44054
Guest_Queen-Of-Stuff_*

Guest_Queen-Of-Stuff_*
  • Guests

highcastle wrote...



Kittens are far superior to drugs. Anders would agree.

http://yamisnuffles....-Mage-208703612Posted Image

by Yami, of course.


And Anders provides a valid point :lol:

CulturalGeekGirl wrote...

Feel free to dig up any of my
rants at any point, that's what they're there for. I always feel
terribly egotistical if I dig something old of mine up, but if someone
else does it, it's great.


Awesome. Here it is! Also, do you know you wrote 1 177 words on this rant? Damn, girl, you're on fire.


CulturalGeekGirl wrote...



In terms of character development, I think it was one of the most stunning and revelatory
plot developments in any RPG I've ever seen.



In DA:A we have snarky, charming Anders who wants nothing more than some small
measure of freedom. Basic rights, like the ability to choose what food he eats
and to maybe find a girl to settle down with. He's even willing to take up the
mantle of the grey wardens to do it, content to just appreciate the smell of
pies and freedom between darkspawn hunts. Then, during the bridging short
story, you learn that the Chantry wouldn't even let Anders have THAT much
freedom, saddling him with a Templar warden to harass and control him (I'm
betting that jerk is the one who made him give away his cat.) Finally, he gets
tired of waiting for the Templars to come up with a new reason to execute him,
and joins with Justice, with the hope of freeing future mages from the same
torment.



I think that Anders knew that joining with Justice would give him the will to
fight back, rather than just running. I think he had finally realized that
running wasn't ever going to actually work. Even allowing himself to be
pressed into Warden service and tainted by darkspawn nightmares forever had
only won him a few short months of friendship and freedom before the Templars
arranged to have him crushed under their heel again. I think Anders realized he
didn't have the strength to do anything but run, and that he needed Justice to
do more than that... DA:A Anders was a lover, not a fighter.



Now, even inhabiting a corpse, Justice had access to some of its memories, the
desires of its old life. Inhabiting Anders, Justice is hit full force with
decades of memories of injustice. Anders had been able to view these memories
through a veil of humor, selfishness, stubbornness and self-preservation, which
had kept him remarkably well-adjusted for someone submitted to that much
psychological torment. Justice has no such filters; he's hit with the
wrong-ness of everything that has happened to Anders full force, and there is
only one way to respond: with Vengeance.



I think that Anders knew that merging with Justice would allow him to fight
back, but he didn't realize that it would prevent him from using any of his
coping mechanisms that allowed him to maintain some kind of psychological
distance from everything that had happened to him. His ironic detachment had
prevented him from ever having to deal with the fact that he'd never have a
family, never fall in love, never be able to just live, but as Justice/Anders he
was incapable of ever forgetting it, incapable of laughing it away with vain
hopes and daydreams of his next escape. Every waking moment, he's confronted
with the reality of it, the injustice of it.



Even then, he tries to exercise self-control, maintaining some of his humanity
even with Justice's constant pressure to take more direct action. Initially he
restricts himself to healing people, helping mages to escape, and distributing
pro-mage literature. All the while, Justice is still seeing and experiencing
all the injustice Anders suffers, and obsessing over it. After seven years of
trying every possible peaceful solution, nothing has improved. Even the Anders
part of the personality realizes that the small, reasonable efforts mean
nothing: nothing will ever change for mages as long as the Chantry is preaching
that mages are proof of the Maker's hate, and no amount of clinics or
manifestos are going to ever change that.



Friended Anders admits this to Justice, and agrees that they have to do
something desperate, drastic. He's been living the lie that there is another
way, that he is something other than the cause of mages, but now he has to
admit that he can't fight against it anymore. The inability to ignore injustice
against mages has stripped away all his defenses, and he finally has to admit
that all his reasonable attempts have accomplished nothing. He has a choice -
accept that all mages forever are doomed to be denied a normal life, love, and
happiness because peaceful change will not and cannot work... or take the only
action he can see that might give future mages a chance at everything he has
been denied. With a spirit of Justice inside you, this choice isn't a choice at
all. There is only one way to proceed, and the Chantry goes up.



Rivaled Anders has been molded to believe that his inability to ignore
injustice is a weakness, a failing, and a curse. He now believes that it would
have been better if he had never joined with Justice, never left the Wardens,
maybe never even left the tower. He is walking evidence of the weakness of
Mages, proof positive that they do not deserve the freedom he has always hoped
for. Here, he is at war with himself, with the Justice-focused part determined
to get vengeance for everything that has been done to mages, while the
Anders-focused part believes that, by becoming an abomination, he may have
retroactively justified all that he has suffered. There is nothing left for him
to do but die. Justice wins the battle long enough to plant and set off the
bomb, and the Chantry goes up.



Now, no matter which way he has played so far, the player has the final choice.
He can choose the cause of mages or the cause of the templars, and he can kill
or spare Anders. There is a reason you have to choose your side before you pull
out the knife... so Anders can see the results of what he has done.



At this point he has lost any illusion that he has an existence beyond the
cause of mages. If you kill him, justice is done and he both pays for his crime
and dies a martyr. If you spare him and make him fight against the mages, the
part of him that believes he is cursed and weak takes over, and he cooperates
with you, knowing he must die soon because he cannot control the monster inside
of him. If you spare him and let him join you to fight the templars, you allow
him to scrabble together some hope that he may someday have an existence beyond
the cause, that this was all worth it.



It's incredibly powerful, and the fact that there are all these different
endings, with small changes giving Anders' story a profoundly different
conclusion... it's great storytelling, and it actually serves as a perfect
example of a situation where the narrative capabilities of games are greater
than the narrative capabilities of other media. In any other telling of the
story, we would only see one of these ends, and could only guess at the others.
Here, we can see all the possibilities, and shape which one becomes reality.



Of course, if you don't care about his cause, or about Anders, I can see how it
would be maddening.


Modifié par Queen-Of-Stuff, 11 juin 2011 - 08:23 .


#44055
berelinde

berelinde
  • Members
  • 8 282 messages

SurelyForth wrote...
... I would not have minded even more levity in Act 1 (or maybe I just wish Howden had slightly better comedic timing, because some of his comedy lines in Act 1 fall short for me)...

Hmm, that's one of the things that kicks my sympathy gland into overdrive. The comedy lines do fall flat. He's trying to be funny and it isn't working. Not well, anyway. He is broken and nothing in the world can fix it. YMMV, but I think it's brilliant that the comedic timing isn't as good as it was in Awakenings. I don't know whether this happened by design or by chance, but it definitely works for me.

About the voice, I don't know. I'm sure that Greg Ellis would have done a fine job with DA2 Anders, but I think I might actually prefer Adam Howden here. His voice seems more serious, or at least more emotional. It worked.

#44056
Arquen

Arquen
  • Members
  • 1 280 messages
You know what I always wondered was who's idea it was to merge in the first place. I mean we always think about Anders helping out Justice, but Justice in Awakenings seems so put off by the thought of transferring bodies.

I wonder what happened to make them come to this kind of decision. Also, was Justice already so consumed by his desires that he was afraid of returning to the Fade? Why was the merger necessary in the first place?

#44057
Sable Rhapsody

Sable Rhapsody
  • Members
  • 12 724 messages

highcastle wrote...

Kittens are far superior to drugs. Anders would agree.


As a new kitten parent, I 100% agree.  I got a beautiful little three month old orange tabby kitten from the shelter exactly one week ago.

Posted Image

Meet...Ser Pounce-a-lot! :D  He's finally stopped being scared of the camera, so I can get a few pictures of him to post.

Posted Image

#44058
CulturalGeekGirl

CulturalGeekGirl
  • Members
  • 3 280 messages
Ooh, it was this one. I'd forgotten about this one. And yes, I do tend to go on. I'm also going to clean up the formatting a bit, because I hate the curse of the Bioware Boards formatting problem.

Queen-Of-Stuff wrote...

Awesome. Here it is! Also, do you know you wrote 1 177 words on this rant? Damn, girl, you're on fire.


CulturalGeekGirl wrote...

In terms of character development, I think it was one of the most stunning and revelatory plot developments in any RPG I've ever seen.

In DA:A we have snarky, charming Anders who wants nothing more than some small measure of freedom. Basic rights, like the ability to choose what food he eats and to maybe find a girl to settle down with. He's even willing to take up the mantle of the grey wardens to do it, content to just appreciate the smell of pies and freedom between darkspawn hunts. Then, during the bridging short story, you learn that the Chantry wouldn't even let Anders have THAT much freedom, saddling him with a Templar warden to harass and control him (I'm betting that jerk is the one who made him give away his cat.) Finally, he gets tired of waiting for the Templars to come up with a new reason to execute him,and joins with Justice, with the hope of freeing future mages from the same torment.

I think that Anders knew that joining with Justice would give him the will to fight back, rather than just running. I think he had finally realized that running wasn't ever going to actually work. Even allowing himself to be pressed into Warden service and tainted by darkspawn nightmares forever had only won him a few short months of friendship and freedom before the Templars arranged to have him crushed under their heel again. I think Anders realized he didn't have the strength to do anything but run, and that he needed Justice to do more than that... DA:A Anders was a lover, not a fighter.


Now, even inhabiting a corpse, Justice had access to some of its memories, the desires of its old life. Inhabiting Anders, Justice is hit full force with decades of memories of injustice. Anders had been able to view these memories through a veil of humor, selfishness, stubbornness and self-preservation, which had kept him remarkably well-adjusted for someone submitted to that much psychological torment. Justice has no such filters; he's hit with the wrong-ness of everything that has happened to Anders full force, and there is only one way to respond: with Vengeance.

I think that Anders knew that merging with Justice would allow him to fight back, but he didn't realize that it would prevent him from using any of his coping mechanisms that allowed him to maintain some kind of psychological distance from everything that had happened to him. His ironic detachment had prevented him from ever having to deal with the fact that he'd never have a family, never fall in love, never be able to just live, but as Justice/Anders he was incapable of ever forgetting it, incapable of laughing it away with vain hopes and daydreams of his next escape. Every waking moment, he's confronted with the reality of it, the injustice of it.

Even then, he tries to exercise self-control, maintaining some of his humanity even with Justice's constant pressure to take more direct action. Initially he restricts himself to healing people, helping mages to escape, and distributing pro-mage literature. All the while, Justice is still seeing and experiencing all the injustice Anders suffers, and obsessing over it. After seven years of trying every possible peaceful solution, nothing has improved. Even the Anders part of the personality realizes that the small, reasonable efforts mean nothing: nothing will ever change for mages as long as the Chantry is preaching that mages are proof of the Maker's hate, and no amount of clinics or manifestos are going to ever change that.

Friended Anders admits this to Justice, and agrees that they have to do something desperate, drastic. He's been living the lie that there is another way, that he is something other than the cause of mages, but now he has to admit that he can't fight against it anymore. The inability to ignore injustice against mages has stripped away all his defenses, and he finally has to admit that all his reasonable attempts have accomplished nothing. He has a choice - accept that all mages forever are doomed to be denied a normal life, love, and happiness because peaceful change will not and cannot work... or take the only action he can see that might give future mages a chance at everything he has been denied. With a spirit of Justice inside you, this choice isn't a choice at all. There is only one way to proceed, and the Chantry goes up.



Rivaled Anders has been molded to believe that his inability to ignore injustice is a weakness, a failing, and a curse. He now believes that it would have been better if he had never joined with Justice, never left the Wardens, maybe never even left the tower. He is walking evidence of the weakness of Mages, proof positive that they do not deserve the freedom he has always hoped for. Here, he is at war with himself, with the Justice-focused part determined to get vengeance for everything that has been done to mages, while the Anders-focused part believes that, by becoming an abomination, he may have retroactively justified all that he has suffered. There is nothing left for him to do but die. Justice wins the battle long enough to plant and set off the bomb, and the Chantry goes up.


Now, no matter which way he has played so far, the player has the final choice. He can choose the cause of mages or the cause of the templars, and he can kill or spare Anders. There is a reason you have to choose your side before you pull out the knife... so Anders can see the results of what he has done.

At this point he has lost any illusion that he has an existence beyond the cause of mages. If you kill him, justice is done and he both pays for his crime and dies a martyr. If you spare him and make him fight against the mages, the part of him that believes he is cursed and weak takes over, and he cooperates with you, knowing he must die soon because he cannot control the monster inside of him. If you spare him and let him join you to fight the templars, you allow him to scrabble together some hope that he may someday have an existence beyond the cause, that this was all worth it.

It's incredibly powerful, and the fact that there are all these different endings, with small changes giving Anders' story a profoundly different conclusion... it's great storytelling, and it actually serves as a perfect example of a situation where the narrative capabilities of games are greater than the narrative capabilities of other media. In any other telling of the story, we would only see one of these ends, and could only guess at the others. Here, we can see all the possibilities, and shape which one becomes reality.

Of course, if you don't care about his cause, or about Anders, I can see how it would be maddening.



#44059
BlueMew

BlueMew
  • Members
  • 262 messages

highcastle wrote...
I judge him as one single character (despite his "extra passenger"). When I say I like Anders, I mean all of him, everything we see of him in both games. This being said, I think he's a more compelling character in DA2, but the full weight of his tragedy could not be felt without experiencing DAA. I know there are people (not many on this thread) who complain that Anders went from being fun and joking to "emo" and dark. First of all, there's as much darkness in Awakening!Anders as there is in DA2!Anders. He just hides it a bit more with a caustic sense of humor.

Second, it shows a great deal of growth to have a character who repressed so much of his own suffering suddenly confront it and allow it to change him. Whether you think it's a change for the better or the worse is up to you. Originally I looked at it as a tragedy: Anders sacrificed large chunks of himself to jenga the Chantry. Now, though, I'm starting to look at it as a positive growth. Anders confronted the organization that had oppressed and tortured him in his earlier years, and he not only struck a tremendous blow against them, but he (at least in my playthrough) lived through the experience. This Anders may finally be able to heal.

Couldn't have put it better.

I have two cats, a beautiful smart grey female and an amazingly stupid black male.

#44060
CulturalGeekGirl

CulturalGeekGirl
  • Members
  • 3 280 messages

Arquen wrote...

You know what I always wondered was who's idea it was to merge in the first place. I mean we always think about Anders helping out Justice, but Justice in Awakenings seems so put off by the thought of transferring bodies.

I wonder what happened to make them come to this kind of decision. Also, was Justice already so consumed by his desires that he was afraid of returning to the Fade? Why was the merger necessary in the first place?


We don't know for sure, but in the short story there is this tantalizing quote: 

Suddenly it comes back to me. Justice's voice, my voice, speaking through the rotting face of the body he once claimed. "It is time. You have shown me an injustice greater than any I have faced. Do you have the courage to accept my aid?"

So I'm guessing that at some point justice saw what Rolan was doing to Anders, or heard Anders talk about it and just... decided. Decided he had to help him, and made the offer. Because... injustice.

That short story makes me so mad. Seriously, I know why the Warden disappears now, or why my Warden disappears. Because after she found out what really happened to Anders (and oh, I am betting her sniveling lieutenants worked really, really hard to prevent her from finding out) she was like "Screw THIS crap," and wandered off to find some people who weren't absolute monsters to work with.

/ahem

/cough.

#44061
Amondra

Amondra
  • Members
  • 1 597 messages
Good Afternoon everyone. So what's the debate right now, or is all calm for the moment?

#44062
Addai

Addai
  • Members
  • 25 850 messages

CulturalGeekGirl wrote...

Addai67 wrote...

Okay... I know I'm trolling, but I have to ask... why would you ("you" as in a reasonably grounded, mature PC) ever consent to be in a relationship with someone like this?  Arm's length, okay, but a romantic relationship with someone so codependent and with no sense of self?  Is it to fix him?  Exploit him?  Those are the only two reasons i can come up with, and this is even apart from the whole abomination thing.


Perhaps... because you love them?

I'm the worst person to ask about this... I'm more Zevran than Anders, when it comes to my history of past relationships, but love isn't about being reasonable or rational. It's about being in god damned bloody love and nobody can take that from you.

Being in love is when all the songs suddenly make sense, and Anders makes so very, very many songs make sense. Most of them sad songs that I could never imagine identifying with. But you bleed just to know you're alive, yeah?

The reason I stressed "grown up relationships" is because to my ears this is a teenage mentality.  A grown up should know that you do not get romantically involved with  the unemployed drug addict (or whatever RL correlation for an unstable guy in deep sh*t you'd like to draw) simply because he has redeeming qualities.  You're not going to fix him, and chances are good he's going to drag you down with him.
At least the writers show how that sort of thinking usually pans out.  :unsure:

But, I appreciate the replies from everyone.  I was just puzzled at the appeal.  I still am, but that's fine.  For the record, I agree all the LIs are f'ed up and though I liked Fenris' romance, it walks the line, too.  I just have to blink and ignore the three-year timeout or the fact that he's living in a mansion with ten year-old corpses. lol

#44063
Amondra

Amondra
  • Members
  • 1 597 messages

Addai67 wrote...

CulturalGeekGirl wrote...

Addai67 wrote...

Okay... I know I'm trolling, but I have to ask... why would you ("you" as in a reasonably grounded, mature PC) ever consent to be in a relationship with someone like this?  Arm's length, okay, but a romantic relationship with someone so codependent and with no sense of self?  Is it to fix him?  Exploit him?  Those are the only two reasons i can come up with, and this is even apart from the whole abomination thing.


Perhaps... because you love them?

I'm the worst person to ask about this... I'm more Zevran than Anders, when it comes to my history of past relationships, but love isn't about being reasonable or rational. It's about being in god damned bloody love and nobody can take that from you.

Being in love is when all the songs suddenly make sense, and Anders makes so very, very many songs make sense. Most of them sad songs that I could never imagine identifying with. But you bleed just to know you're alive, yeah?

The reason I stressed "grown up relationships" is because to my ears this is a teenage mentality.  A grown up should know that you do not get romantically involved with  the unemployed drug addict (or whatever RL correlation for an unstable guy in deep sh*t you'd like to draw) simply because he has redeeming qualities.  You're not going to fix him, and chances are good he's going to drag you down with him.
At least the writers show how that sort of thinking usually pans out.  :unsure:

But, I appreciate the replies from everyone.  I was just puzzled at the appeal.  I still am, but that's fine.  For the record, I agree all the LIs are f'ed up and though I liked Fenris' romance, it walks the line, too.  I just have to blink and ignore the three-year timeout or the fact that he's living in a mansion with ten year-old corpses. lol


Because the best lines to draw with him is someone who is mentally unstable, mostly Bi-polar.  With what you say a grown up should know never to get into a relationship with them as it is clear they are not stable or all there at times.  And these people with such issues should be grown up enough to know they shouldn't be in them, because there good qualities don't make up for the fact, that they are something they can no longer control?

To love someone like Anders takes a special person of a different kind of maturity and understanding that most don't have.  You accept they are broken and when they start to fall apart, you will be there to help.  Or are you of the idea, that not everyone deserves to be loved?

#44064
Guest_Queen-Of-Stuff_*

Guest_Queen-Of-Stuff_*
  • Guests

CulturalGeekGirl wrote...

Ooh, it was this one. I'd forgotten about this one. And yes, I do tend to go on. I'm also going to clean up the formatting a bit, because I hate the curse of the Bioware Boards formatting problem.


You had forgotten it? I'm not sure whether to find that impressive or terrifying. There's only one thing about DA2 I could see myself working up a rant about, and only because it's an argument that's been made so many times and I'm equally irked every time someone brings it up.

berelinde wrote...

SurelyForth wrote...
... I
would not have minded even more levity in Act 1 (or maybe I just wish
Howden had slightly better comedic timing, because some of his comedy
lines in Act 1 fall short for me)...

Hmm, that's one of the things that kicks my sympathy gland into overdrive. The comedy lines do
fall flat. He's trying to be funny and it isn't working. Not well,
anyway. He is broken and nothing in the world can fix it. YMMV, but
I think it's brilliant that the comedic timing isn't as good as it was
in Awakenings. I don't know whether this happened by design or by
chance, but it definitely works for me.

About the voice, I don't
know. I'm sure that Greg Ellis would have done a fine job with DA2
Anders, but I think I might actually prefer Adam Howden here. His voice
seems more serious, or at least more emotional. It worked.


Well put. This is exactly how I saw it as well.

Amondra wrote...

Good Afternoon everyone. So what's the debate right now, or is all calm for the moment?


I asked whether or not Awakenings Anders was missed and how... uhm, how you view the progression from his old self to his DA2 self. Primarily to kick some life into this thread, because it had gone a little quiet and awkward and I didn't quite like that. And my plan worked! So, do you have any thoughts on the subject?

#44065
ipgd

ipgd
  • Members
  • 3 110 messages

Addai67 wrote...

At least the writers show how that sort of thinking usually pans out.  :unsure:

See, that's exactly why I like him.

It is a very self-aware narrative.

Modifié par ipgd, 11 juin 2011 - 09:07 .


#44066
Addai

Addai
  • Members
  • 25 850 messages

SurelyForth wrote...

Addai67 wrote...

SurelyForth wrote...

See, I think that if you friendmance him you're merely helping him find himself (or helping him find balance with himself and Justice) and he'd be able to survive without Hawke.

Perhaps this is why I don't get it- because I can never be okay with the Justice merger.  I did have a Hawke who ended up at max friendship with him, but only because she was helping mages and as to his personal issues was more like "you don't think this is a good idea, do you?  okay, well, I'll go stand over here now" sort of neutral in their conversations.


See, I understand why he did it. If his short story is to be believed, he was basically backed into a corner by the decisions of his WC to put him under templar guard at all times. The Wardens are supposed to be free from the Chantry, so the fact that he could be opressed even there (and after he'd proven himself a model Warden with the Hero/Orlesian Commander) pretty much convinced him that there was no way for a mage alone to prove his worth. 

And his motives for merging were noble, I think. He didn't want mages to just be wild, but he wanted them to have access to training AND their families, he wanted parents to be able to keep their children without fear of imprisonment. It was everything that was taken from him and his mother, and the turn from self-possessed, self-preservation above all else Awakening Anders to the Anders who is willing to sacrifice normalcy (which is pretty all he wants out of life) to take on basically the biggest government-type organization in the known world is pretty impressive. 

So he wanted to accomplish something, but he'd need the help. He trusted Justice, who wanted to help, and he sacrificed himself for a cause much larger than himself. He was naive, but I personally admire him for taking that risk, considering.

PS. This is not What I Would Do Or Think In Real Life. In VG World, With Magic And ****...I can handle the crazy and even see that he's not absolutely bat**** under some circumstances. IRL? No.

This is so like the stories about why people submit to demon possession that I can't not see it as the same thing.  I can have sympathy for it, though less than I sympathize with someone who submits to possession out of pure survival instinct.  The fact that he thought about it and made a choice, and that he had options otherwise, makes it less sympathetic.  And since I play mages who've been schooled from day one on the dangers of possession, I can't mentally work out how they'd see it as anything less than a really bad thing, especially since Hawke never knew Justice in "the good ol days" and from the minute she meets Anders, he is talking in ominous tones about the spirit.

#44067
Zjarcal

Zjarcal
  • Members
  • 10 841 messages

Addai67 wrote...
The reason I stressed "grown up relationships" is because to my ears this is a teenage mentality.  A grown up should know that you do not get romantically involved with  the unemployed drug addict (or whatever RL correlation for an unstable guy in deep sh*t you'd like to draw) simply because he has redeeming qualities.  You're not going to fix him, and chances are good he's going to drag you down with him.


I guess that depends on whether you think a f*cked up person can or cannot be fixed. You already show an attitude of "that will never work", whereas others may feel that it can be possible to do that (and I've seen cases, rare as they may be).

Modifié par Zjarcal, 11 juin 2011 - 09:11 .


#44068
Amondra

Amondra
  • Members
  • 1 597 messages

Queen-Of-Stuff wrote...

CulturalGeekGirl wrote...

Ooh, it was this one. I'd forgotten about this one. And yes, I do tend to go on. I'm also going to clean up the formatting a bit, because I hate the curse of the Bioware Boards formatting problem.


You had forgotten it? I'm not sure whether to find that impressive or terrifying. There's only one thing about DA2 I could see myself working up a rant about, and only because it's an argument that's been made so many times and I'm equally irked every time someone brings it up.

berelinde wrote...

SurelyForth wrote...
... I
would not have minded even more levity in Act 1 (or maybe I just wish
Howden had slightly better comedic timing, because some of his comedy
lines in Act 1 fall short for me)...

Hmm, that's one of the things that kicks my sympathy gland into overdrive. The comedy lines do
fall flat. He's trying to be funny and it isn't working. Not well,
anyway. He is broken and nothing in the world can fix it. YMMV, but
I think it's brilliant that the comedic timing isn't as good as it was
in Awakenings. I don't know whether this happened by design or by
chance, but it definitely works for me.

About the voice, I don't
know. I'm sure that Greg Ellis would have done a fine job with DA2
Anders, but I think I might actually prefer Adam Howden here. His voice
seems more serious, or at least more emotional. It worked.


Well put. This is exactly how I saw it as well.

Amondra wrote...

Good Afternoon everyone. So what's the debate right now, or is all calm for the moment?


I asked whether or not Awakenings Anders was missed and how... uhm, how you view the progression from his old self to his DA2 self. Primarily to kick some life into this thread, because it had gone a little quiet and awkward and I didn't quite like that. And my plan worked! So, do you have any thoughts on the subject?


LOL.  I like the change.  It's dramatic, and like we have talked about on here before, he seems bi-polar even in Awakening.  So it's like seeing both ends of the scale, who people react like that.  Granted the voice in his head now is actually another voice, but for people like that, they really think it is one, so same then.  Just you know one is in a game has Justice living in him with out paying rent and can cast fireballs...

I liked it also because, merging with a spirit has to be tiring, mostly one like Justice.  It changes how you view the world.  I think Anders is more sensitive to the unjustices around them then before.

I just don't see him being all smiles after all of it. I also think he is more mature now then before, just as stubborn.

#44069
KnightofPhoenix

KnightofPhoenix
  • Members
  • 21 527 messages

Zjarcal wrote...

Addai67 wrote...
The reason I stressed "grown up relationships" is because to my ears this is a teenage mentality.  A grown up should know that you do not get romantically involved with  the unemployed drug addict (or whatever RL correlation for an unstable guy in deep sh*t you'd like to draw) simply because he has redeeming qualities.  You're not going to fix him, and chances are good he's going to drag you down with him.


I guess that depends on whether you think a f*cked up person can or cannot be fixed. You already show an attitude of "that will never work", whereas others may feel that it can be possible to do that (and I've seen cases, rare as they may be).


I think we should be reminded that we are not talking about an "ordinary" f*cked up person.  But a f*cked up mage with a spirit inside that is becoming something awfully close to a demon. That guy can explode at any second and I think the game should had had Anders accidently lash out on you, like he almost killed Elle. He's not only a danger to Hawke, he's a danger to everyone around him.

Modifié par KnightofPhoenix, 11 juin 2011 - 09:15 .


#44070
ipgd

ipgd
  • Members
  • 3 110 messages

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

I think we should be reminded that we are not talking about an "ordinary" f*cked up person.  But a f*cked up mage with a spirit inside that is becoming something awfully close to a demon. That guy can explode at any second and I think the game should had had Anders accidently lash out on you, like he almost killed Elle. He's not only a danger to Hawke, he's a danger to everyone around him.

I think "becomes a manipulative leech that takes advantage of your status for his personal gain and then ultimately blackmails you into becoming complicit with an act of iconoclasm and murder" is enough, really. Him outright attacking Hawke would lack subtlety.

Modifié par ipgd, 11 juin 2011 - 09:20 .


#44071
Nivilant

Nivilant
  • Members
  • 226 messages
Vengeance isn't really subtle, so that probably wouldn't matter much.

#44072
KnightofPhoenix

KnightofPhoenix
  • Members
  • 21 527 messages

ipgd wrote...

KnightofPhoenix wrote...

I think we should be reminded that we are not talking about an "ordinary" f*cked up person.  But a f*cked up mage with a spirit inside that is becoming something awfully close to a demon. That guy can explode at any second and I think the game should had had Anders accidently lash out on you, like he almost killed Elle. He's not only a danger to Hawke, he's a danger to everyone around him.

I think "becomes a manipulative leech that takes advantage of your status for his personal gain and then ultimately blackmails you into becoming complicit with an act of iconoclasm and murder" is enough, really. Him outright attacking Hawke would lack subtlety.


Except some apparently approve. Or they don't like that Anders didn't tell them, because if he did, they would have totally helped him. I don't think they grasp what Anders has become.

#44073
Guest_Queen-Of-Stuff_*

Guest_Queen-Of-Stuff_*
  • Guests
I have to wonder what kind of normal person would want to get involved with a person like Hawke, anyway. She somehow manages to find herself knee-deep in the **** of every suspect character's business in the city as well as personally attracting the ire of a hundred and fifty thousand gangs of bat**** crazy Kirkwallers who brutally savages anyone and everyone with the audacity of taking a stroll on the beach or walking outside their home after dark. Who bothers worrying about the messed-up-ness about anyone who might walk into your love-life when you might easily end up in a ditch with ten arrows sticking out your back at any moment?

#44074
kromify

kromify
  • Members
  • 1 292 messages

Sable Rhapsody wrote...

Posted Image

Meet...Ser Pounce-a-lot! :D  He's finally stopped being scared of the camera, so I can get a few pictures of him to post.


he's adorable!!! he looks so playful - ready to swipe at the camera or something!

i miss my pets. :crying: being at uni i don't have a large place and it would be unfair to get my own pet. back home we have 2 cats and a dog; the cat at the top of the food chain is evil and manipulative and terrorizes the other 2. but in a very amusing way. she purposly sits where the dog wants to go knowing the dog won't go within a 5 ft radius of her, and things like that :pinched:

pets are a hoot! :happy:

#44075
CulturalGeekGirl

CulturalGeekGirl
  • Members
  • 3 280 messages

Addai67 wrote...

CulturalGeekGirl wrote...

Addai67 wrote...

Okay... I know I'm trolling, but I have to ask... why would you ("you" as in a reasonably grounded, mature PC) ever consent to be in a relationship with someone like this?  Arm's length, okay, but a romantic relationship with someone so codependent and with no sense of self?  Is it to fix him?  Exploit him?  Those are the only two reasons i can come up with, and this is even apart from the whole abomination thing.


Perhaps... because you love them?

I'm the worst person to ask about this... I'm more Zevran than Anders, when it comes to my history of past relationships, but love isn't about being reasonable or rational. It's about being in god damned bloody love and nobody can take that from you.

Being in love is when all the songs suddenly make sense, and Anders makes so very, very many songs make sense. Most of them sad songs that I could never imagine identifying with. But you bleed just to know you're alive, yeah?

The reason I stressed "grown up relationships" is because to my ears this is a teenage mentality.  A grown up should know that you do not get romantically involved with  the unemployed drug addict (or whatever RL correlation for an unstable guy in deep sh*t you'd like to draw) simply because he has redeeming qualities.  You're not going to fix him, and chances are good he's going to drag you down with him.
At least the writers show how that sort of thinking usually pans out.  :unsure:

But, I appreciate the replies from everyone.  I was just puzzled at the appeal.  I still am, but that's fine.  For the record, I agree all the LIs are f'ed up and though I liked Fenris' romance, it walks the line, too.  I just have to blink and ignore the three-year timeout or the fact that he's living in a mansion with ten year-old corpses. lol


Just to clarify, I am a full grown adult, and a doctor (I am not a doctor). I'm probably about five years older than the average Bioware boards poster, based on an informal survey we took in the Garrus thread a few months ago. My opinions on this come from a long line of boringly stable relationships that end in boringly amicable decisions that it's not worth seeing each other anymore. I'm old enough be able to objectively appreciate the value of drama, and, I think, old enough to survive it.

The thing is, Anders' situation fundamentally different from normal mental illness because he basically has an avenging angel inside him. I put a lot of stock in the supernatural (as well as in Supernatural. That show was excellent). If a guy who was an honest-to-god vampire showed up and gave me some drama, I would go with him... not because I have a thing for vampires (I don't. I have a thing for angels and fey. There's a difference), but because of the novelty of it... the idea that something magical and untouchable and unique was after me. Even if I end up drained of all my blood, I end up drained of all my blood by something beyond the ken of mortal men. I'd rather die at the hands of something mysterious and interesting than live a life of mundanity. I'd rather touch the life beyond the veil than die not knowing anything beyond a cubicle.

(Note for clarification - I don't actually believe that there are physically vampires and angels and ghosts and all that. But if I was presented with solid evidence of them, I would be delighted. I would embrace the idea, while actively questioning it, but I wouldn't be that idiot in the move who spends the entire film staring at the wizard and saying "but here HAS to be a RATIONAL explanation for it." The rational explanation is that magic exists and it's totally badass.)

Back to the idea of the appeal, beyond the idea of touching something truly beyond this world. I'd say it's like the idea of being in a relationship with Robert Downey Jr. That guy... he is messed up. But as messed up as he is, none of his crazy drug-fueled binges ever resulted in him actually hurting anyone other than himself. And with that screwed-up-ness comes a great deal of talent, a dynamite sense of humor, and a good dose of humility. I would still totally date Robert Downey Jr, in real life, with all his baggage. I would NOT date Charlie Sheen. There's a difference there that's hopefully obvious?

Now, you could argue that Anders has hurt people in his lyrium-fueld binges. That's true, but you're in a world where you routinely kill ten thugs before breakfast. I understand that some of that is gameplay/story separation, but Thedas is just not here.

I agree with what Amondra said, about dating someone who is bi-polar. I've got severe ADD, which can someitmes manifest symptoms similar to minor bi-polar, so I'm very sympathetic toward bi-polar people. I actually once talked someone out of committing suicide, which is still pretty much my proudest achievement in life. We weren't dating at the time (just. no.), but what if we had been? Some people are just natural therapists, natural healers, natural listening ears, natural support systems. It's those people who should be dating the crazy.

You're welcome?

Modifié par CulturalGeekGirl, 11 juin 2011 - 09:25 .