Oh my, the least I supposed to do is to drag my ME affection to this thread. 8P
I promiss to bring more on-topic as I finish my game. Not sure about how much I got left an how much time will I have to play...
Plus Kaidan on ME2 was.. not fun. I only liked him after playing ME1, which I did after ME2.
You know, if bringing DA analogues - you could say something like "Alistair in DA2 was...not fun. But then I played DAO.". ME2 was really very painful for anyone who did not pick Liara from the very start of ME1. And for me - ME1 is still something beyond any compares. The way that game got me involved....probably it might not sound healthy, I know, but something tells me that people in this thread won't judge me.
DAO did not hit me much. I liked how it was done - perfect game mechanics and nice system, but all the characters were too..."fantasy" for me. Good (or even perfectly) written and alive within their own world - but still not much real. But as I used to be a big fan of live D&D games and loved NWN - I liked it. And I stumbled apon DA2 discount on origin. I knew most of DAO fandom hated it, so I was curious - what was it all about. I guess I could write a little essay about what I liked and disliked (being absolutely not biased and rather indifferent..first) about the game in general, but we're supposed to talk about Anders here. 8)
My first reaction on both Anders and Fenris was like "OMG!!111". As an archer rogue I wanted to have melee co-tank to assist Aveline and I also needed healer mage. And you all know that those are exactly two of them (I don't have DLCs). Their constant and dumb antagonism drove me crazy. In DAO my "dream team" was Alistair+dog(changed to Oghren in progress)+Wynne. Here I had no options, because there is no other healer mage and no other heavy melee (and at my current play there is no other melee at all - Isabella ran away). While in DAO I could pick from Sten, dog, Oghren or, probably, even Zev or make dw Leliana....Varric is impossible without his Bianca anyway.
As I mentioned, I was initially heading to rivalmance Fenris, so - I had to keep him close. And flirted just for fun with rest, having nothing special in mind. I have no idea how it happened that at some point in chapter 2 Fenris got huge + friendship instead of rival. And I could not start his "questioning beliefs". And Anders was mostly friendly, but I aslo had no Idea that teasing him may bring such an unexpected...uhm..events. I did not really expect to see him waiting for me in my mansion, you know. 8P I even wanted to reload. But then I thought that it was Hawke's destiny, and also - I knew not how long will it take me to make proper numbers for Fenris. And I don't like metagaming, to be honest, especially on first play.
What "hit" me first about Anders - cut scene after fighting that white lily necromaniac. I did not expect to see something like that. Not after how BW handled ME3 post-thessia Alenko's "dialogue". I guess that was a moment when I felt it...personal. After that I was not indifferent player-spectator any more. I can not say I fell in love or lost my head, and I would not wish to compare him with my long time (compared to DA) ME love. But that's what made him for me, I think. What made him...rather "real" and believable. His chapter 3 quests made me nervous and sad. I don't know what's on his mind - but I already do not like it. So - there were already some tears for me, no matter how BW end all of it.
And I had to leave Fenris aside. Not because of his anti-mage stuff (though, I got tired from it a little bit), but because I love Varric too much. Two archers, tank and mage healer - not a very typical setup, but Aveline tanks nice. Much better than Fenris alone. Though I somehow feel that Alistair and Oghren did tanking job better (and yes - I know how to manage tactics). In DAO I rarely got any aggro. I'd prefer to see old combat system, but that's all different topic.
ps: ah, so typical for me, was going to drop few lines and ended with a little wall of text. Sorry if I bored you. <-)