I have two questions:
First: How does party line-up work? What I mean by this is, when you have a companion to your right, to your left, and behind you, what dictates where each companion stands? The order in which you selected on the party selection screen? How much they do or don’t like you? Their class? Totally random? I ask because I originally thought it was based on the order in which you pick them, but some recent events make me not so sure.
Several pages back, someone mentioned that, during battle, Anders ran and hid behind their warrior. Definitely has an awesome level of cuteness in that he fell in behind his “protector”. I haven’t had that happen yet, alas, but there’s always hope. But anywhos, that little story made me remember something very strange/interesting that occurred on my first playthrough – rogue Lady Hawke who friend-manced Anders. Now, I pretty much had a set party that game and I ALWAYS selected them in the same order – Anders, Merrill, then Varric. And they ALWAYS stood in the same places: Anders was, quite literally, my right-hand man; Merrill stood on my left, and Varric had our backs.
But, after I completed the Act 3 “Justice” quest and Anders donned his “funeral attire”… where he stood changed! All four of us walked out of his clinic and, suddenly, Anders was standing all the way in the back of the party and Varric had taken his place at my right! I did the “gather your party” thing, wanting to “fix” it and get Anders back at my right side (I’d grown used to him always standing there beside me), but no matter what order I selected them in, Anders insisted on standing in back. AS IF HE WERE TRYING TO DISTANCE HIMSELF FROM HAWKE. That, combined with him pulling away emotionally as well, made that whole act really depressing and disturbing. I have no idea if that was… a glitch or something, or if the designers actually thought about the story elements and made that happen, but it was goosebump-inducing.
Second question: Can someone please help me in thinking up a warrior Lady Hawke to rival-mance Anders? I’d like to see how romancing him that way goes, even though I know going into it that it’s the more painful route, but I’m having a hard time justifying the character herself. I don’t want her to be cruel to him 24/7 because, really, what’s the point? If Anders is so desperate that he’ll put up with her emotional abuse, that’s very sad. But if she’s really so against everything about him, how can she love him? At the same time, if she’s just pro-templar/mages-belong-in-the-Circle non-stop, HOW can she possibly justify herself? Her sister’s a mage, plus there are two mages in her party… if she’s pro-templar and/or anti-mage, why doesn’t she just march all three of them down to the Gallows?
I’m just… having a difficult time coming up with a mindset for a Hawke that would rival-mance Anders. To me, any Hawke that is pro-templar is a massive hypocrite. I’m already playing a massive hypocrite pro-templar 2H male Hawke (anti-mage, yet rival-romancing Merrill; boy has issues) at the moment in order to get the pro-templar/viscount achievements, but the only way I can stomach it is knowing he’s a total jerk to, well, everybody (wanted to see what Aggressive Hawke was like, after playing Sarcastic Hawke for my rogue). He just forced Feynriel to go to the Circle last night and I honestly felt BILE RISING IN MY THROAT the whole time (which does not bode well since this character will be the one and only shanking of Anders… I may actually vomit after that scene, gah).
*sigh* So, has anyone come up with a good “rival-mance Anders” Hawke that makes sense? I’ll take any advice I can get. About the only way I can see it making sense is if she starts out pro-mage because of her sister… then, maybe, make Bethany a Grey Warden… then, after seeing about 80% of the apostates she helps in-game turn to demons/blood magic/abominations, she starts to waver… then, her mother’s death-by-crazy-apostate sort of seals the deal and turns her pro-templar, feelings for Anders aside. Only problem with that is… that kind of playthrough would net friendship points with Anders, then rivalry points, and I fear it would just stick him in the neutral position that way. Plus, being all pro-mage my first playthrough, that had Anders at 100% friendship by the very beginning of Act 2, so then I’d be stuck. Any suggestions? Or am I doomed to play a hypocritical Hawke I can’t stand just to see the Anders rival-mance?
Sorry for the wall of text!