80 réponses à ce sujet

[CroGamer002]

Why does this comic still exist?


There is so much failure on every single page.

Modifié par Mesina2, 10 mars 2011 - 08:39 .

[Ghost Warrior]

Fiery Phoenix wrote...

I hope this is the last comic. Seriously. Like, just stop it already; I'd much rather stick to the likes of Drew's novels.

+1

[Whereto]

MY EYES NOOOOOOOO. Anyway not a fan

[2kgnsiika]

When the first promotional image was released last summer, I was so excited... Sigh.

Evolution is the Phantom Menace of Mass Effect.

[Tyrannosaurus Rex]

2kgnsiika wrote...
Evolution is the Phantom Menace of Mass Effect.

What does that make Redemption then?

[2kgnsiika]

Lizardviking wrote...

2kgnsiika wrote...
Evolution is the Phantom Menace of Mass Effect.

What does that make Redemption then?

Ok, Redemption is the Phantom Menace and Evolution is Attack of the Clones.

My biggest problem with these comics is that the plot is crap and they waste a good opportunity on really expanding the ME universe. Instead of having these things happen in new places, everything of importance in the galaxy seems to happen on Illium, the Citadel or Omega. It's like the known galaxy is only comprised of a few places, but when we play ME2, we see that in the Terminus alone there are multiple colonies with billions of inhabitants.

[Elvis_Mazur]

I just hope there are no rectcons in the third part.

[ZombifiedJake]

Very poor quality, and to think that I was considering getting these once they were all released.

[Jebel Krong]

i'll just quote what i wrote on my blog about this:

Shocking artwork this issue - Omar francia's work has been better than before up till now, but some of these pages are terrible. Unfortunately the story is continuity-breaking and awful, also in-line with the previous Mass effect comic series'. One way to ruin a franchise is with poorly thought out tie-in media, unless BW are careful this is heading in that direction...

[GHOST OF FRUITY]

Hmm. I think i'm happier being ignorant of these comics existence. Too much information isn't always a good thing.

[roflchoppaz]

Someone, break the artist's arm and never let him to the drawing board again.

It's for his own, and our, good.

Modifié par roflchoppaz, 10 mars 2011 - 04:50 .

[Liec]

 BRAINS

[Denize]

- possible SPOILERS -
Why is Ben Hislop (more evolved husk or reaper avatar) taking orders from Saren? Husks or reaper avatars are usually under command of reaper - Paul Grayson, Saren (Sovereign), Collector general (Harbinger).

[Fiery Phoenix]

We don't know how Timmy ended up on a turian ship again, do we?

[Zulu_DFA]

Fiery Phoenix wrote...

We don't know how Timmy ended up on a turian ship again, do we?

I think we should pretend Issue #2 was just TIM's dream.

[Fiery Phoenix]

Zulu_DFA wrote...

Fiery Phoenix wrote...

We don't know how Timmy ended up on a turian ship again, do we?

I think we should pretend Issue #2 was just TIM's dream.

No, seriously, let me get this straight: Issue #2 ended with Tim on Illium, right? Starting with Issue #3, it looks like he was captured and is onboard a turian ship for a second time. Is it possible that this happened in the gap between the two issues?

[Babli]

Ah look its another comic...

[Captain Crash]

  "IGN is proud to present an exclusive first look at the issue"

I wouldnt be! [smilie]http://social.bioware.com/images/forum/emoticons/uncertain.png[/smilie]  

I wonder what kind of travesties this issue will do on the universe.   Surely it cant be worse then #2 right? ...

Modifié par Captain Crash, 10 mars 2011 - 05:43 .

[Bad King]

2kgnsiika wrote...

Lizardviking wrote...

2kgnsiika wrote...
Evolution is the Phantom Menace of Mass Effect.

What does that make Redemption then?

Ok, Redemption is the Phantom Menace and Evolution is Attack of the Clones.

My biggest problem with these comics is that the plot is crap and they waste a good opportunity on really expanding the ME universe. Instead of having these things happen in new places, everything of importance in the galaxy seems to happen on Illium, the Citadel or Omega. It's like the known galaxy is only comprised of a few places, but when we play ME2, we see that in the Terminus alone there are multiple colonies with billions of inhabitants.

I can see it now, ME3 will comprise of  Earth a London suburb, Omega, and Ilium. And we will magically bump into every NPC we've previously met in the series in one bar.

Oh lord, please don't let this be true.

Modifié par Bad King, 10 mars 2011 - 05:49 .

[CroGamer002]

Denize wrote...

- possible SPOILERS -
Why is Ben Hislop (more evolved husk or reaper avatar) taking orders from Saren? Husks or reaper avatars are usually under command of reaper - Paul Grayson, Saren (Sovereign), Collector general (Harbinger).

Bad writing.

[Zulu_DFA]

Fiery Phoenix wrote...

Zulu_DFA wrote...

Fiery Phoenix wrote...

We don't know how Timmy ended up on a turian ship again, do we?

I think we should pretend Issue #2 was just TIM's dream.

No, seriously, let me get this straight: Issue #2 ended with Tim on Illium, right? Starting with Issue #3, it looks like he was captured and is onboard a turian ship for a second time. Is it possible that this happened in the gap between the two issues?

Have you missed something? Saren ambushed TIM on Illium with the Turian cultists and Ben-cultist grabbed him by the throat.

I could live with another Idiot Ball having been passed to TIM (It's a trap, lol, let's go into it... Aaarrrrgh!!! IT'S A TRAP!!! BASTARDS!!!!!!!).

But what I refuse to understand is what has been the point? Of this running in circles... Nothing really serous takes place in between two TIM's Turian chair sessions, which could not hve been conveyed via some kind of news report. Were we supposed to burst in tears seeing the good kid Ben Hislop huskified at the last page of Issue #2? Seriously???

It's not exaclty a plot hole, it's a PLOT EPIC FAIL.

[Angmir]

Well I am from Poland and i read like 10 comics in my life (wolverine rox ), but I dont think this Evolution is so bad.
Compared to ME: Redemption the art is great, and the dilaogs are 3 times better. Schematic story is the mayor flaw on it, but so was with ME: Redemption.

following someone - ambush - run - following - ambush - run - and so on. 

And i must say I am positivly suprised that this have some Reaper related storry in the backbround, when I first saw preview of part 1 I had worries this would be mainly about First Contact War, I am glad this will be related more to games. (saren etc.)

Again I say - this is about the Evolution as a whole not just on this preview, which is bit disapointing.

I dont like the idea of sentient husks thought - I didnt read Revelations so I dont know what this avatars are.

[Fiery Phoenix]

Zulu_DFA wrote...

Have you missed something? Saren ambushed TIM on Illium with the Turian cultists and Ben-cultist grabbed him by the throat.

I could live with another Idiot Ball having been passed to TIM (It's a trap, lol, let's go into it... Aaarrrrgh!!! IT'S A TRAP!!! BASTARDS!!!!!!!).

But what I refuse to understand is what has been the point? Of this running in circles... Nothing really serous takes place in between two TIM's Turian chair sessions, which could not hve been conveyed via some kind of news report. Were we supposed to burst in tears seeing the good kid Ben Hislop huskified at the last page of Issue #2? Seriously???

It's not exaclty a plot hole, it's a PLOT EPIC FAIL.

Let's just say: There is a reason I never bother with comics of any type. Can't Walters write actual novels like Drew? As far as I'm concerned, these comics are not only God awful, but are also insulting to the entire Mass Effect franchise and what it is supposed to be. I would have believed it if we were told they were the work of some 16-year-old's over at DeviantArt or such.

[Dexi]

I've seen very talented 16yo on DeviantArt

WHATS WITH ALL THE BOOB'N'ASS SHOTS???

[Dexi]

Oh and I never read the comics... but I guess that's TIM, dunno who's that blonde Miranda... But if I heard right, these stuff happens shortly after the First Contact War...

If so, how is TIM speaking turian? O.o I mean, they uploaded english to translators that fast?