158 réponses à ce sujet

[electroban]

Hey Bioware, how about giving your Baldurs Gate IP to Bethesda? Then I don't have to worry you shafting one of the best PC titles of all time into consolation hell.

Thank you!

[Karan Vess]

I don't quite follow your reasoning.

[woooooooor]

If Bethesda had control then we'd at least be able to mod it into something good.

Modifié par woooooooor, 10 mars 2011 - 12:10 .

[AkiKishi]

Depending on how things with DS turn out. Obsidian is my first choice for Baldurs Gate 3.

DS3 to one click or not to one click that is the question.

[Vengeful Nature]

BobSmith101 wrote...

Depending on how things with DS turn out. Obsidian is my first choice for Baldurs Gate 3.

DS3 to one click or not to one click that is the question.

Agreed, Obsidian would be my first choice as well. Some of those guys used to be Black Isle.

It's not going to happen, though. Something about not having the rights. IIRC, Atari have the rights to all DnD stuff. Might be Interplay, actually. Not sure.

Also, Throne of Bhaal was technically BG3, just shortened a little and made an expansion pack. I think Gaider confirmed this a while back.

Modifié par Vengeful Nature, 10 mars 2011 - 12:17 .

[The Elder King]

Bethesda does differenT types of RPGs.

Modifié par hhh89, 10 mars 2011 - 12:15 .

[AkiKishi]

Vengeful Nature wrote...

BobSmith101 wrote...

Depending on how things with DS turn out. Obsidian is my first choice for Baldurs Gate 3.

DS3 to one click or not to one click that is the question.

Agreed, Obsidian would be my first choice as well.

It's not going to happen, though. Something about not having the rights. IIRC, Atari have the rights to all DnD stuff.

Well there was a rumour about IWD3 they would need the rights to make that anyway. IWD would also be a good dry run for BG3.

If you can get IWD right, then it's just a case of adding the NPCs and being more story focused. Both areas Obsidian excel at.

Modifié par BobSmith101, 10 mars 2011 - 12:17 .

[electroban]

hhh89 wrote...

Bethesda does differenT types of RPGs.

Yes they do but whose looking for an exact remake?

If Bethesda remade Fallout 2 into Fallout 3

Im fine with letting them do whatever to Baldurs GAte 3

[Nightshade IX]

If memory serves me right, throne of Bhaal had a very satisfying conclusion. So BG 3 would be unlikely. Although I would be very excited about a sequel to a game that turned me into a Bioware fanboy.

[The Elder King]

electroban wrote...

hhh89 wrote...

Bethesda does differenT types of RPGs.

Yes they do but whose looking for an exact remake?

If Bethesda remade Fallout 2 into Fallout 3

Im fine with letting them do whatever to Baldurs GAte 3

But Bethesda games are completely different from BG types of games, it will not be a BG. I'd prefer Obsidian over Bethesda.

Modifié par hhh89, 10 mars 2011 - 12:21 .

[keyip]

electroban wrote...

Hey Bioware, how about giving your Baldurs Gate IP to Bethesda? Then I don't have to worry you shafting one of the best PC titles of all time into consolation hell.

Thank you!

Bethesda are doing exceptionally well stuffing up their own games thank you very much. In fact, as bad as the reaction has been to Bioware's new game, it's nowhere near as bad as the community backlash Bethesda suffered over the tripe they called Oblivion. A significant number of the forum were banned, forum names were censored (which was utterly ridiculous), the community devs went into hiding for what seemed like months and the community forums ended up being policed with an iron fist.

It must have takenhalf a year for the forums to settle, very funny stuff

[adi4444]

i also think obsidian first choise for me....and after them is bathesda and cd project..

bioware rpg day are gone

[Barbosa]

I think BG IP is owned by Atari, can't be sure though, but definitely not Bioware.
I am one that would love them to do a new BG, many devs from the initial game are still around, question is how much creativity and freedom would they have to do such thing, and after the DA2 disaster one can only tell that Minsc would be “converted” into an Elf princess with gloomy eyes and serious breast power…
My vote would go for Bethesda/Obsidian

Modifié par Barbosa, 10 mars 2011 - 12:24 .

[El Codge]

electroban wrote...

Hey Bioware, how about giving your Baldurs Gate IP to Bethesda? Then I don't have to worry you shafting one of the best PC titles of all time into consolation hell.

Thank you!

A lot of Morrowind fans would probably LOL at that comment.

Obsidian need to learn to get their games finished by the release date before they're given the keys to BG3.

[Maderek]

electroban wrote...

Hey Bioware, how about giving your Baldurs Gate IP to Bethesda? Then I don't have to worry you shafting one of the best PC titles of all time into consolation hell.

Thank you!

Bethesda? BETHESDA?

The game would be terrible.

[chaosapiant]

If ANYONE make BG3 I'd be pissed. It came to a very satisfactory conclusion, and there is no way we could get another DND RPG with the same protagonist using 2nd edition rules. It would be a spin off at best, just using the name, and thus really doesn't need to be made.

[AkiKishi]

chaosapiant wrote...

If ANYONE make BG3 I'd be pissed. It came to a very satisfactory conclusion, and there is no way we could get another DND RPG with the same protagonist using 2nd edition rules. It would be a spin off at best, just using the name, and thus really doesn't need to be made.

Baldurs Gate is a city as much as it's the Baal Saga. Just like the various Waterdeep games.

[Dardove]

Barbosa wrote...

I think BG IP is owned by Atari, can't be sure though, but definitely not Bioware.
I am one that would love them to do a new BG, many devs from the initial game are still around, question is how much creativity and freedom would they have to do such thing, and after the DA2 disaster one can only tell that Minsc would be “converted” into an Elf princess with gloomy eyes and serious breast power…
My vote would go for Bethesda/Obsidian

Yes, Atari currently holds all publishing rights for Dungeons and Dragons game and that would include Baldur's Gate.

[nisallik]

How could anyone want Bethesda to touch the Baldur's Gate series...

I wouldn't mind Obsidian trying to make a sequel, but my first choice would be BioWare.

[Vengeful Nature]

BobSmith101 wrote...

chaosapiant wrote...

If ANYONE make BG3 I'd be pissed. It came to a very satisfactory conclusion, and there is no way we could get another DND RPG with the same protagonist using 2nd edition rules. It would be a spin off at best, just using the name, and thus really doesn't need to be made.

Baldurs Gate is a city as much as it's the Baal Saga. Just like the various Waterdeep games.

Except BG2 took place in and around Athkatla, and BG:ToB took place in and around Saradush. Baldur's Gate was the Bhaalspawn saga.

Also, you were saying above, a new IWD would be incredible.

Modifié par Vengeful Nature, 10 mars 2011 - 12:35 .

[El Codge]

Creative Assembly should do Faerun: Total War.

This post really doesn't belong in this particular forum though.

[MikeSunrider]

electroban wrote...

hhh89 wrote...

Bethesda does differenT types of RPGs.

Yes they do but whose looking for an exact remake?

If Bethesda remade Fallout 2 into Fallout 3

Im fine with letting them do whatever to Baldurs GAte 3

So, if they are allowed to strip BGII down for BGIII, why are you anything about anything Dragon Age related? Just seems weird.

[OKDaddio]

I'd love to see Obsidian do BG3 - anyone else, no.

[Barbosa]

nisallik wrote...

How could anyone want Bethesda to touch the Baldur's Gate series...

I wouldn't mind Obsidian trying to make a sequel, but my first choice would be BioWare.

Not trying to jump into Bethesda's defence but they have a very professional approach to whatever they do, and when they do it, they do it better.
Ok, they're not good with story telling but they just have to give a job to David Geider... 

[Vengeful Nature]

El Codge wrote...

Creative Assembly should do Faerun: Total War.

This post really doesn't belong in this particular forum though.

Sod that, they should do Thedas: Total War.



I'll be in my bunk...