MColes wrote...
On the box itself, it says you have to register the game using an EA account in order to activate it. If you can't fullfill that requirement, don't buy it. If you computer doesn't meet system reqs, don't buy it. Don't open it, return it, put it back on the bloody shelf. Buying a copy of WoW doesn't mean, you get to play for free. You still are required to pay, just like it says on the box. For DA2, it says you have to do an online activation. It's simple and clear cut. It's not something that is exclusive to EA or BioWare. If some guy cheats at MW2, he can be banned (yea right, but roll with it). He paid for it, it's his game, he owns the physical disc. He still agreed to their services. It's a ****, but it's the world we all live in.
Fair Use Act in the United States makes this an illegal act. A company cannot ban you from using a product you've purchased and brought home. They can ban you from the forums, sure, but they cannot ban you from using a product. Activiation is not a function of the game he purchased, EA uses it as copy protection, but it is not legal to require it in order to play the game at all.
This is why when Microsoft and Sony both banned moded consoles, what they did was prevented them from connecting to the live services. The users violated the terms of service, but neither MS nor Sony can legally brick the consoles, just prevent them from accessing online services. This topic, if permitted to continue, would effectively be bricking his game, which isn't legal.
The EULA is irrelevant, a contract that violates law is invalid. This issue, if it were to persist, would destroy the software industries tenuous hold on the theory of "Leasing software", as no court will uphold it. This is not a fight EA wants to get in.