i sided with the mages, i first told anders to go but when i got to the gallows he was there, i thought i would prob need healing so when i talked to him again i told him to stick around.. im going to play a non mage char and side with the templers. I was kindof dissappointed with the mages.. I stead up for them and they go on and use freaking blood magic.
Did anyone else kill Anders?
Erstellt von
sevenplusone
, Mär 12 2011 03:53
Nach oben
#27
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 05:20
DarkSpider88
-
- Members
- 1.504 Beiträge
manny01422 wrote...
i sided with the mages, i first told anders to go but when i got to the gallows he was there, i thought i would prob need healing so when i talked to him again i told him to stick around.. im going to play a non mage char and side with the templers. I was kindof dissappointed with the mages.. I stead up for them and they go on and use freaking blood magic.
Bethany didn't and that alone tells me I made the right decision.
#28
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 05:28
Parrk
-
- Members
- 333 Beiträge
I let him go. I really would have liked to have had to opportunity to kill Sebastian during that scene though. He jsut really annoyed me with his incessant whining coupled with snooty faux-piety.
It kinda pissed me off when I had to tell anders to leave....again before the grand enchanter fight.
I can't see being pro-templar. I may do it once for the achievement, but then delete the save. Meredith gives the order for genocide and they start carrying it out......
There are at least 10 occasions in the game that should dispell any notion of the templars as noble or well-intentioned. Magic gets out of hand when mages turn to blood magic and begin hurting others. At that point though, they have self-identified and can be dealt with.
Mages are born/created as they are. I don't think that the Chantry has a very firm grasp on what that says about the Maker.
It kinda pissed me off when I had to tell anders to leave....again before the grand enchanter fight.
I can't see being pro-templar. I may do it once for the achievement, but then delete the save. Meredith gives the order for genocide and they start carrying it out......
There are at least 10 occasions in the game that should dispell any notion of the templars as noble or well-intentioned. Magic gets out of hand when mages turn to blood magic and begin hurting others. At that point though, they have self-identified and can be dealt with.
Mages are born/created as they are. I don't think that the Chantry has a very firm grasp on what that says about the Maker.
Bearbeitet von Parrk, 12 März 2011 - 05:35 .
#29
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 05:30
Emperor Mars
-
- Members
- 587 Beiträge
I sided with the mages and killed him. The Hawke I was playing was trying to be diplomatic and Anders ****ed all that up to hell...plus he kinda deserved it.
#30
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 05:36
Lea-Anne
-
- Members
- 64 Beiträge
I didn't in my first play through. I am still desiding what faction I want my actual game to have since both are clearly genosidal mainiacs.
I like Sebatian a lot, but Anders has always been a favorite in Awakenings.
It was a real dick move, and I am thinking that my actual Hawke will side with the templars since they seem to be the only ones who really enmasse keep their crap straight. Most of the mages in the end went all crazy and I questioned what it was all for.
But I wanted that damned trophy...
I like Sebatian a lot, but Anders has always been a favorite in Awakenings.
It was a real dick move, and I am thinking that my actual Hawke will side with the templars since they seem to be the only ones who really enmasse keep their crap straight. Most of the mages in the end went all crazy and I questioned what it was all for.
But I wanted that damned trophy...
#31
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 05:40
Reginthorn
-
- Members
- 223 Beiträge
Yes I killed Anders. This character annoyed me to no end!
#32
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 05:51
What?
-
- Members
- 583 Beiträge
I killed him in a heartbeat. I hate Anders so much in DA2.
#33
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 05:54
Soulcheg
-
- Members
- 93 Beiträge
Parrk wrote...
Meredith gives the order for genocide and they start carrying it out......
And Orsino knew about white-lily killer. You could not save Leandra because of him and his lie.
Just reloaded and sided with mages, just to compare both endings. And first thought - "FFFFFUUUUUUUU, they copypasted not only all locations, but all final fights too". Same random fights, same bosses fights. I sided with mages - why they atack me? Why Orsino had to used this trasformation and moreover, why he had to atack me, though i was protecting him? I cannot find logic in that, so my choice is Templar' side. And between let Anders go, and punish him for his crime i can choose only one decision - death sentence.
- Aren gefällt das
#34
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 05:56
panamakira
-
- Members
- 2.751 Beiträge
I romanced him, so I couldn't kill him. Even when I do another playthrough I can't kill him anyway and I don't agree with his crazy~
#35
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 06:06
Jman5
-
- Members
- 414 Beiträge
I liked Anders... at first. Great Support role? Yes please! Gray Warden? Cool!, he heals the poor? Awesome! Oh, and did I mention he's all about justice?
However as the game progressed, he grew more and more annoying. He Complained at every opportunity about the inequalities of mages. Look I get it, you don't like the Templars. Can we just talk about the weather?
Whenever I had Merrill and Anders in the same party, he seemed to spend every possible moment pointing out how terrible a person she is. Part of the reason I let her do what she wanted with the mirror was in a hope that she would be right and Anders would be wrong. Or at least I could fix things in the end. Well that didn't happen. Keeper got possessed, and we ended up slaughtering the entire Dalish camp down the last man, woman and child. Of course this made Anders get on his Soapbox and **** even more. (woops)
He also tried flirting with me at one point which was kind of weird. Sorry buddy, I don't swing that way. (-15 rivalry)
The worst of it all, was that I kept him in my group and stuck with him to the end simply because I needed a good healer. After blowing up the chantry, the **** got off scott-free because I needed him for the final leg of the game.
However as the game progressed, he grew more and more annoying. He Complained at every opportunity about the inequalities of mages. Look I get it, you don't like the Templars. Can we just talk about the weather?
Whenever I had Merrill and Anders in the same party, he seemed to spend every possible moment pointing out how terrible a person she is. Part of the reason I let her do what she wanted with the mirror was in a hope that she would be right and Anders would be wrong. Or at least I could fix things in the end. Well that didn't happen. Keeper got possessed, and we ended up slaughtering the entire Dalish camp down the last man, woman and child. Of course this made Anders get on his Soapbox and **** even more. (woops)
He also tried flirting with me at one point which was kind of weird. Sorry buddy, I don't swing that way. (-15 rivalry)
The worst of it all, was that I kept him in my group and stuck with him to the end simply because I needed a good healer. After blowing up the chantry, the **** got off scott-free because I needed him for the final leg of the game.
Bearbeitet von Jman5, 12 März 2011 - 06:09 .
#37
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 07:00
alaska the 1st
-
- Members
- 102 Beiträge
I really did like Anders but when he killed the grand cleric templar side sealed and I told him to run, but Seb got me to kill him. After that I really thought I had to kill Bethany, thankfully no.
#38
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 07:06
Nocturnius89
-
- Members
- 91 Beiträge
What he did surprised the hell out of me. The Grand Cleric DEAD! I wanted to kill him for that. I liked the Grand Cleric, she was very religious and neutral. She did not deserve that fate.
#39
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 07:29
StripedStocking
-
- Members
- 93 Beiträge
Yeah, I killed him. I wished I could do that since Awakening, so it wasn't sad at all, quite the opposite actually. The only reason I hesitated for a bit was, cause I thought, Merrill might get angry xP.
And I also liked the Grand Cleric, she was pretty cool, so that made it even easier. Sided with the Mages btw, Meredith was seriously screwed up
.
And I also liked the Grand Cleric, she was pretty cool, so that made it even easier. Sided with the Mages btw, Meredith was seriously screwed up
.
#40
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 07:50
Chuvvy
-
- Members
- 9.686 Beiträge
Hell no, guy's a badass. I wish he had told me his plan, I would have helped much more.
#41
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 08:12
JimmyG
-
- Members
- 16 Beiträge
I executed him and dumped his body in the sewer where it belongs. Acts of terrorism do not fly with this Hawke.
#42
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 08:19
Fidget6
-
- Members
- 2.437 Beiträge
Anders was my love interest, but I was actually really pissed he did that, so I did tell him to leave, but I didn't kill him, which caused Sebastian to leave, since he demanded Anders had to die. Anders came back for the final battle though, and the romance continued. Oh, and I sided with the mages of course.
#43
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 08:41
Vhaius
-
- Members
- 282 Beiträge
I told him to leave, sided with the mages and found him standing next to Orsino. Awkward.
#44
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 09:06
trh5001
-
- Members
- 214 Beiträge
I sided with the mages and killed his b**** a** for lying to me about the ritual to separate himself from justice.
#45
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 09:12
staindgrey
-
- Members
- 2.652 Beiträge
Out of curiosity... If you decide not to aide him in his quest to set that stuff in the Chantry, does he blow it up anyway?
I was going to play through again and not let him do that, see if there was a massively different ending. But I have yet to find anyone whose playthrough didn't include Anders being a ****.
I was going to play through again and not let him do that, see if there was a massively different ending. But I have yet to find anyone whose playthrough didn't include Anders being a ****.
#46
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 09:17
Zalitara
-
- Members
- 209 Beiträge
I killed the son of a **** and laughed. He killed the one person in the chantry/templars who wasn't dick. Meridith seemed like she was just about to see reason and he ****ing blows a bomb killing innocents? Seriously? He has the blood of hundreds of people on him.
Bearbeitet von Zalitara, 12 März 2011 - 09:23 .
#47
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 09:17
trh5001
-
- Members
- 214 Beiträge
staindgrey wrote...
Out of curiosity... If you decide not to aide him in his quest to set that stuff in the Chantry, does he blow it up anyway?
I was going to play through again and not let him do that, see if there was a different ending. But I have yet to find anyone whose playthrough didn't include Anders being a ****.
Its the major final catalyst for the rebellion /templar massacre I think he just leaves the party and does it anyways.
#48
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 09:21
Hoax86
-
- Members
- 144 Beiträge
I was pro-mage all the way on my first playthrough, but I killed him without a moment's regret. Start wilfully killing innocents and you lose any right to live.
#49
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 09:21
syn010110
-
- Members
- 16 Beiträge
I didn't kill him because I needed a healer. ><
Why the hell didn't Merrill get the Creation tree? Why does healing in this game have to be so underpowered and potions on such a long cooldown?
Ugh what a mess. I've never been so conflicted over a game. I want to like DA2 so much but I can't help but find glaring flaws.
Why the hell didn't Merrill get the Creation tree? Why does healing in this game have to be so underpowered and potions on such a long cooldown?
Ugh what a mess. I've never been so conflicted over a game. I want to like DA2 so much but I can't help but find glaring flaws.
#50
Geschrieben 12 März 2011 - 09:31
RosaAquafire
-
- Members
- 1.187 Beiträge
Sided with templars and killed him. That was an in character choice, though, not my personal view.
My personal view? I frankly have NO IDEA how to feel about mages vs. templars, but I do think that what Anders did was wrong. That was terrorism, plain and simple. Elthina was the only person in Kirkwall who undebatably deserved to survive to the end. She was kind, generous, and reasonable. And she knew that there was a chance she'd die, but she stayed in the Chantry anyway, even when Leliana offered her an easy way out, because she wouldn't leave the people and she wouldn't let the cauldron boil over.
She was such a good person that Anders HAD to kill her to get the holy war he wanted. I thought Anders was an AMAZINGLY well written character and I absolutely loved him ... but he deserved to die for what he did. He bombed a civilian target. That's that.
My personal view? I frankly have NO IDEA how to feel about mages vs. templars, but I do think that what Anders did was wrong. That was terrorism, plain and simple. Elthina was the only person in Kirkwall who undebatably deserved to survive to the end. She was kind, generous, and reasonable. And she knew that there was a chance she'd die, but she stayed in the Chantry anyway, even when Leliana offered her an easy way out, because she wouldn't leave the people and she wouldn't let the cauldron boil over.
She was such a good person that Anders HAD to kill her to get the holy war he wanted. I thought Anders was an AMAZINGLY well written character and I absolutely loved him ... but he deserved to die for what he did. He bombed a civilian target. That's that.
