298 réponses à ce sujet

[tanerb123]

8/10 so far.

[vigna]

I'd rather not have loot than have the trash loot.

[velcrolemur]

If it were a standalone game, I would give it an 8.

Compared to DA:O, it is a 6. Story is not as good. Characters not as good. World does not have the same depth. Constant reminders that this was a rushed game.

If I see another ornate ring I'm gonna throw my controller.

[Jamesnew2]

Well it seems their is a lot more positivity where you actually have to own the game to post in this forum. Hope bioware notice this.

[Merci357]

7/10.

On comparison to the lastest BioWare games, JE is also 7/10, ME is 8/10, ME2 is a 9/10, and DA:O also a 9/10.

[Vajraja]

7/10 I've posted a lot about what I've disliked. 7 is still a decent game imo. I would never rate any of Bioware's games below a 9.5, even NWN.

Modifié par Vajraja, 15 mars 2011 - 05:44 .

[SoulRebel_1979]

Originally a 6.5, but after playing it more and more and finally beating it, I'm bumping it up to a 7.5.

[Jamesnew2]

Xerin wrote...

I haven't finished the game yet, but I've been pleasantly surprised. I read the negative feedback on the boards before playing, and didn't have high hopes. The storytelling is still fantastic (I read all the lore, and really enjoy the content of the cut scenes), and I find myself as emotionally involved as in DA:O.

My only complaint are the frequent freezes, especially during cut scenes. Hopefully they can get this fixed soon.

tbh if your on pc id say it wasnt up for the task. I mean my high end is running it smoothly. so i dont think ya blame em just be annoyed that you need an upgrade... if ya on the console then i wouldnt know tho.

[Chadthesad]

Graphics 10/10
Gameplay/Combat 8/10
Storyline 9/10
Characters 9/10
Soundtrack 6/10
Level design 4/10

The game is a solid sequel. Many of us will agree the repetitive use of interior and exterior layouts wasn't par. Bioware took a risk, and they'll learn from it. The inventory and UI are cleaned up. The combat is simply better than it's predecessor, then animations are even better. I would've liked to have seen genelocks and other variations of Darkspawn. Please, work on some different Darkspawn. Make them gruesome once more.

[bluecapsule6]

About an 8/10 (DAO was a 9/10 for me, and ME2 was a 9.5/10). Still a good game, but this was the worst Bioware RPG I've ever played, not counting the Sonic RPG.

Modifié par bluecapsule6, 15 mars 2011 - 05:48 .

[sjrskl]

7.5 / 10 i liked the game the story was interesting, game play was good and characters were excellent but it was just not the quality I'm used to with Bioware. the re-use of environments and the disjointed feel at times dragged it down a bit. i have had only one bug/issue but that was resolved in the 1.01b patch so no problem there.Unfortunately the game did not completely feel right (finding it difficult to describe) but i allready gave this game a review so this is the short version.

[BiowarEA]

blueruin wrote...

BiowarEA wrote...

Graphics -- 5.5/10
Gameplay -- 4.0/10
Sound -- 6.0/10
Story -- 2.0/10
Replay Value -- 4.5/10
--------------------
Total Score -- 9.8/10

Haha... how does this make any sense?

Makes exactly as much sense as the professional critic reviews did. 

[mnomaha]

Well, somewhere between 5 and 6.

-stupid trash..what's up with the trash?
-lack of companion dialogue at their "homes"
-very short story

-interesting story. It was engaging, which is important to me in my games
-great graphics, even on DX9

Honestly, it felt more like an expansion pack than a full game. The lack of companion conversations frustrated me to no end. But I did like it more than I thought I would at first. I still feel a bit let down, especially with the elves, but I will eventually get past that. It felt short and rushed and the loot was crap.

[Arkynomicon]

A strong 7/10.

Played it on PS3 and it felt much more user-friendly then previous game. I like the story a lot and it's nice to play a fantasy RPG that is about political intrigue rather then fighting the hordes of darkness and some Lovecraftian dragon.

Things that I didn't like is the obvious copy-pasted environments, eye-straining to read when I played it on a standard-definition TV and that it had so much more potential to be a truly memorable game if it had stayed longer in development.

[Demonicom]

Combat: 5/10 I kinda like the new system but I *need* auto-attack
Story: 8/10 (including companion quests/main quests)
Graphics: 9/10 (giant LED TV and HDMI cable ftw)

Overall: 7.3/10

Things that make me sad:
Copy/paste dungeons/caves/areas to explore
No auto-attack (unless I am completely incompetent and can't find the option to turn it on)
No explaination on items when picked up
Super waves of enemies

I am going to replay this after I finish, so I guess replay value is decent as well.

Oh right, I forgot the most important like--My character finally has a voice!!

Modifié par Demonicom, 15 mars 2011 - 05:49 .

[RinpocheSchnozberry]

I'm going 9/10.

Recycled maps were a little odd at first, specially after DAO's maps. However, in a theater you can often see the same set pieces used over and over again... because the set doesn't really matter. It's the story that is told.

I loved how the game and the story fit together. It was perfect. The boring camp click fest is gone at long last, the boring dialogue click fest is gone at long last. A voiced protagonist is now a must in RPGs and the convo wheel can stay too.

Companions were great, though will say I could have used 2-3 more exchanges before or during the romances. Still, I got plenty of interaction with them through the travel banter, the cut scene dialogue, and their personal cut scenes.

Action was actiony. :-) I play on casual and flat out loved smashing the crap through every thing came at my team. It ruled. It was very much battle-story-battle-story and I loved that. The waves... I'm not such a fan of waves of monsters. They totally have their place.. but wave after wave of the random attack groups were amazingly dull during the night sections when I was trying to get to quest/story objectives. Waves have their place... Not all over the place. :-)

The cinematics were great and I loved how they blended into the action. They should all work that way. I want all of them to be 2-3 times longer than they were. :-D

[Solid N7]

8, dragon age II is a good game but I think origins is better

[Omiii]

+ The new combat system.  It doesn't get as boring as DA:O could get in the long run.
+ My character having a real voice.
+ The graphics are better, but there are some places Bioware has been VERY lazy.
+ I like the day/night difference.
+ No more random encounters on the road, unless they have a real purpose.
+ Much faster loading times.
+ I love the new qunari, they're awesome.


-  The story was weak. Had no real clear goal.
-  Act 1 was a pain.
-  Why did you have to kill off ALL my healers?
-  Not able to speak with companions on the run.
-  The new looks of the elves, they look like aliens. I'd never play one again if I was able to.
-  The new looks of the darkspawn.
-  The recycled caves and hideouts.
- Waves of useless trash enemies that you nearly one shot. Pointless.


Sound: 7/10
Graphics: 7/10
Story: 7/10
Gameplay: 7/10
Replay value: 3/10

Overall: 6,2/10

Modifié par Omiii, 15 mars 2011 - 05:53 .

[Ignoble Fat Man]

I downloaded the High Res pack so:

Graphics: 8.5/10
Story: 7.5/10
Voice Acting: 7/10
Game Play: 9/10
Replay Ability: 7/10
Sound: 8/10

Probably give the game an 8/10 over all which isn't bad.  I'd give Origins slightly higher marks though.  The story was done in an interesting way but my actions didn't seem to have to much effect in this story arc though I am guessing they will have some impacts in DA3.  I personally didn't want to meet my warden...I'd love to have played as my Warden but meeting him as a cameo would just have made me angry.

Good game but not best nor as good as it could have been.  They recycled to many maps and they needed to allow me to have more business interests that would build my characters influence in the city.  I mean I was part owner of a mine but really never saw much profit in it or immersion from it.  Unlike the hate squad I liked a lot of the changes and didn't mind not having control of my companions armor though I would rather have been able to. 

[PSRdirector]

Give it a 7.5/10 so far, maybe an 8, Mass effect 2 is a 5/10 so is jade empire, mass effect 8.5/10 Origins 9/10

[srieser]

8.5/10 - PC.

The Good:
Excellent Story
Fast brutal combat
Excellent Characters
streamlined skills


Not so good:
Exploration/area variety
Interface too small on 1080p + resolution

My only real complaint is that Kirkwall isn't big enough to support a 40 hour game. Qunari should have had their own map, not one part of the docks. Perhaps some Noble estates outside the city would have helped as well.

[Raint]

8.6 / 10 people are just overreacting!

[blueruin]

BiowarEA wrote...

blueruin wrote...

BiowarEA wrote...

Graphics -- 5.5/10
Gameplay -- 4.0/10
Sound -- 6.0/10
Story -- 2.0/10
Replay Value -- 4.5/10
--------------------
Total Score -- 9.8/10

Haha... how does this make any sense?

Makes exactly as much sense as the professional critic reviews did. 

Zing.

[Aprudena Gist]

 4.5/10 really subar in tems of the whole role playing. No matter what choices you make the end is always the same a really ****ty game.