554 réponses à ce sujet

[sphinxess]

8

[DSGrant]

7


Personally, I think the survey conducted in the General Discussion forum gets some better details around the overall rating you are attempting to track in this thread.

You can take the survey here:  www.kwiksurveys.com/online-survey.php

The results are here:  www.kwiksurveys.com/results-overview.php

Modifié par DSGrant, 09 avril 2011 - 03:32 .

[erynnar]

lazysuperstar wrote...

Dan UK wrote...

OP up to date as of now. Getting on for 300 votes, keep it up. If youve not voted yet get your number on the charts

It is interesting that its often thrown about that 'everyone knows this was a let down' and other similar comments, when so far it would paint the picture that actualy the majority are pleased.

Allthough one thing to bear in mind this is only the views of us folk who post on these forums, and this specific subforum, so is NOT an overall picture, just a picture of this perticular community.

I would also think that generaly folk who bother to post on here are in some way fans on the seriesor developer. Casual gamers (rightly or wrongly) I wouldnt expect to spend as much time here as alot of us do, so the lower votes do still speak volumes, despite their apparent minority.

One thing we can safely say is - it is not a 4 or 5 out of 10 game.

No, all you can say is that the enjoyment levels are higher. On say
metacritic people docked it for bugs, story, replayability. This is an
emotions poll. 

Me well...since they touted it as the sequel and
to ask me to not compare it to DAO is disingenious.

DAO 10/10 for
enjoyment and may playthroughs(on hubby's stolen account before I got my
own with the Deluxe package. I think he bought it for me so he could have his back.[smilie]../../../images/forum/emoticons/lol.png[/smilie]).

DA2 gets docked on my enjoy o' meter for the let down of crappy reused dungeons, becoming a button masher with hack and slash,
with most of it's RPG and the elements that made DAO so fun stripped like Salome's dance of the seven veils.

It gets
docked for boss fights with too much HP and the feeling when fighting
them is tedious (if it weren't for me running in circles to the Benny Hill theme song, which makes it go up a half a point) and doing mindless side quests thus becoming a game of doing chores. It gets docked for a disjointed story line and for making Act 2 feel like it should have been Act 3!  However, on that note, Act 2 was very fun indeed (save the stupid repitition of places) so it went up in points. Overall, this is only replayable once, if that for me.

Oh and it gets docked for being a shoddy, side story,  rushed DLC feel to it.  From any other company this would be a 6.  From a company like BioWare...that made my enjoyment go down faster than Isabela's thong.

DA2...4.5

Modifié par erynnar, 09 avril 2011 - 04:01 .

[Begarian]

After two complete play throughs as a Diplomatic nice guy Apostate Mage (who helped mages), and a Sarcastic, aggressive female Warrior (who sided with the Templars), I'll give the game a solid 6.5. Some pros are: cool battle mechanics (cross class combos are awesome), great ability trees, and the female/male Hawke persona is pretty cool. Some cons would be: lazy and rushed level design, Bioware still hasn't found the sweet spot for earning currency and loot, ANOTHER WAVE! combat.

[neppakyo]

erynnar wrote...

DA2 gets docked on my enjoy o' meter for the let down of crappy reused dungeons, becoming a button masher with hack and slash,
with most of it's RPG and the elements that made DAO so fun stripped like Salome's dance of the seven veils.

It gets
docked for boss fights with too much HP and the feeling when fighting
them is tedious (if it weren't for me running in circles to the Benny Hill theme song, which makes it go up a half a point) and doing mindless side quests thus becoming a game of doing chores. It gets docked for a disjointed story line and for making Act 2 feel like it should have been Act 3!  However, on that note, Act 2 was very fun indeed (save the stupid repitition of places) so it went up in points. Overall, this is only replayable once, if that for me.

DA2...4.5

Dragon Age: Hawke does Stuff..

Fedex rates it as 10 /10 "I really enjoyed this game, it was so much like work!" - Driver.

UPS rates it as 8/10 "It was a really good delivery system, but I feel it catered too much to the FedEx crowd" - Shift Supervisor.

[erynnar]

neppakyo wrote...

erynnar wrote...

DA2 gets docked on my enjoy o' meter for the let down of crappy reused dungeons, becoming a button masher with hack and slash,
with most of it's RPG and the elements that made DAO so fun stripped like Salome's dance of the seven veils.

It gets
docked for boss fights with too much HP and the feeling when fighting
them is tedious (if it weren't for me running in circles to the Benny Hill theme song, which makes it go up a half a point) and doing mindless side quests thus becoming a game of doing chores. It gets docked for a disjointed story line and for making Act 2 feel like it should have been Act 3!  However, on that note, Act 2 was very fun indeed (save the stupid repitition of places) so it went up in points. Overall, this is only replayable once, if that for me.

DA2...4.5

Dragon Age: Hawke does Stuff..

Fedex rates it as 10 /10 "I really enjoyed this game, it was so much like work!" - Driver.

UPS rates it as 8/10 "It was a really good delivery system, but I feel it catered too much to the FedEx crowd" - Shift Supervisor.

*giggle/snort*

[Rockpopple]

erynnar wrote...

lazysuperstar wrote...

Dan UK wrote...

OP up to date as of now. Getting on for 300 votes, keep it up. If youve not voted yet get your number on the charts

It is interesting that its often thrown about that 'everyone knows this was a let down' and other similar comments, when so far it would paint the picture that actualy the majority are pleased.

Allthough one thing to bear in mind this is only the views of us folk who post on these forums, and this specific subforum, so is NOT an overall picture, just a picture of this perticular community.

I would also think that generaly folk who bother to post on here are in some way fans on the seriesor developer. Casual gamers (rightly or wrongly) I wouldnt expect to spend as much time here as alot of us do, so the lower votes do still speak volumes, despite their apparent minority.

One thing we can safely say is - it is not a 4 or 5 out of 10 game.

No, all you can say is that the enjoyment levels are higher. On say
metacritic people docked it for bugs, story, replayability. This is an
emotions poll. 

Me well...since they touted it as the sequel and
to ask me to not compare it to DAO is disingenious.

DAO 10/10 for
enjoyment and may playthroughs(on hubby's stolen account before I got my
own with the Deluxe package. I think he bought it for me so he could have his back.[smilie]../../../images/forum/emoticons/lol.png[/smilie]).

DA2 gets docked on my enjoy o' meter for the let down of crappy reused dungeons, becoming a button masher with hack and slash,
with most of it's RPG and the elements that made DAO so fun stripped like Salome's dance of the seven veils.

It gets
docked for boss fights with too much HP and the feeling when fighting
them is tedious (if it weren't for me running in circles to the Benny Hill theme song, which makes it go up a half a point) and doing mindless side quests thus becoming a game of doing chores. It gets docked for a disjointed story line and for making Act 2 feel like it should have been Act 3!  However, on that note, Act 2 was very fun indeed (save the stupid repitition of places) so it went up in points. Overall, this is only replayable once, if that for me.

Oh and it gets docked for being a shoddy, side story,  rushed DLC feel to it.  From any other company this would be a 6.  From a company like BioWare...that made my enjoyment go down faster than Isabela's thong.

DA2...4.5

No offense... but if you reach any further you're liable to pull something major. At least do some stretches first. =P

[erynnar]

Rockpopple wrote...

erynnar wrote...

lazysuperstar wrote...

Dan UK wrote...

OP up to date as of now. Getting on for 300 votes, keep it up. If youve not voted yet get your number on the charts

It is interesting that its often thrown about that 'everyone knows this was a let down' and other similar comments, when so far it would paint the picture that actualy the majority are pleased.

Allthough one thing to bear in mind this is only the views of us folk who post on these forums, and this specific subforum, so is NOT an overall picture, just a picture of this perticular community.

I would also think that generaly folk who bother to post on here are in some way fans on the seriesor developer. Casual gamers (rightly or wrongly) I wouldnt expect to spend as much time here as alot of us do, so the lower votes do still speak volumes, despite their apparent minority.

One thing we can safely say is - it is not a 4 or 5 out of 10 game.

No, all you can say is that the enjoyment levels are higher. On say
metacritic people docked it for bugs, story, replayability. This is an
emotions poll. 

Me well...since they touted it as the sequel and
to ask me to not compare it to DAO is disingenious.

DAO 10/10 for
enjoyment and may playthroughs(on hubby's stolen account before I got my
own with the Deluxe package. I think he bought it for me so he could have his back.[smilie]../../../images/forum/emoticons/lol.png[/smilie]).

DA2 gets docked on my enjoy o' meter for the let down of crappy reused dungeons, becoming a button masher with hack and slash,
with most of it's RPG and the elements that made DAO so fun stripped like Salome's dance of the seven veils.

It gets
docked for boss fights with too much HP and the feeling when fighting
them is tedious (if it weren't for me running in circles to the Benny Hill theme song, which makes it go up a half a point) and doing mindless side quests thus becoming a game of doing chores. It gets docked for a disjointed story line and for making Act 2 feel like it should have been Act 3!  However, on that note, Act 2 was very fun indeed (save the stupid repitition of places) so it went up in points. Overall, this is only replayable once, if that for me.

Oh and it gets docked for being a shoddy, side story,  rushed DLC feel to it.  From any other company this would be a 6.  From a company like BioWare...that made my enjoyment go down faster than Isabela's thong.

DA2...4.5

No offense... but if you reach any further you're liable to pull something major. At least do some stretches first. =P

ROFL!!! *stretches then pummels Rockpopple with a huge hug* Ahhhh much better!

[MEBengal2008]

3

[PanosSmirnakos]

5.

This is my "enjoy-O-meter" though and not my overall rating of the game.

Minus points for :
- Recycled to death areas.
- Waves "TM" battles.
- Average story.
- Copy & paste to everything.
- Bugs.

[silver-crescent]

So out of the 443 people who voted so far (the thread was updated 3 days ago mind), 86% gave a positive rating, 74% gave an 7 or more rating, 60% gave an 8 or more rating.

[Luridel]

10.

[Luca Grease]

6

[zackiz]

3

[Zhijn]

Ah gues ill jump the number wagon.

4.

ps @DSGrant
Thouse survey results require sign up?.  oO

pps OP- you outta change your topic title to attract both sides of the fence, or this poll is going to become very one-sided (alrdy is).

Modifié par Zhijn, 09 avril 2011 - 01:50 .

[Lintanis]

10    

[Persephone]

Have I posted here already? If so, sorry.

9/10 for me.

DAO gets a 7/10 for me these days.

[Gravias]

I'm gonna be fair and open-minded on this one so I give it a solid 7.

[Midz]

9/10
..each time played the settings as many said stayed the same ( but had 1 new cave this time not seen before )..but the interactions changed .
Just finished again and for first time saw Zevran join my side in the final battle with Meredith ..

Its all opinions I enjoyed it more than DAO is all can say that others should feel same or not cannot say each has there own view.

[Krilral]

8

[TJSolo]

Persephone wrote...

Have I posted here already? If so, sorry.

9/10 for me.

DAO gets a 7/10 for me these days.

Yep this is your 2nd time posting scores in there and 1232465461321st time bringing DAO up along with DA2 to show your brand of DAO "appreciation"(it was a 7-8 now it is a hard 7).

Modifié par TJSolo, 09 avril 2011 - 03:55 .

[neppakyo]

Sweet, I'll repost mine as well. I gave it a generous 7 if I recall earlier, now its a solid 5.5.

[Persephone]

TJSolo wrote...

Persephone wrote...

Have I posted here already? If so, sorry.

9/10 for me.

DAO gets a 7/10 for me these days.

Yep this is your 2nd time posting scores in there and 1232465461321st time bringing DAO up along with DA2 to show your brand of DAO "appreciation"(it was a 7-8 now it is a hard 7).

OMG the audacity!!! It jumps between 7-8/10 for Origins.

Not a bad rating. Must it be a 9 or 10/10 to be "appreciation"? <_<

[Foed15]

5

[TJSolo]

Whatevs, you can act as outraged as you want but I was just pointing out how common it is for you in any conversation being critical of DA2 that you also do a good dredging of DAO just to make it clear you think DAO is the lesser game now. All that is of course framed with your liking or loving both games nearly equally.