313 réponses à ce sujet

[Glorfindel709]

No. Not at all.

DA:O
KotOR
Morrowind
Oblivion
Baldurs Gate 2

[Brightassin]

Morrowind
Oblivion
DA:O
DA II
Gothic IV. (blasphemy?! x'D)

I hope this list will change fast with the coming of Skyrim and DA III.

[Luzeka]

No!!

1) Guild wars series
2) Fallout new vegas
3) Elder Scrolls series
4) DA:O
5) Mass Effect 2

[Bostur]

The games that felt most memorable when I played them:

Ultima V
Wastelands
Some of the SSI AD&D games (Champions of Krynn, Pool of radiance)
BG 1&2
Planescape: Torment
Fallout 1&2
DA:O

Games like System Shock 2 and ME1&2 mostly for story qualities and not so much for RPG qualities.

Playing DA:O made me realize I might have missed a decade of good RPGs so I'm playing Fallout 3 now and enjoying it tremendously :-)

[hawat333]

I always improvise these lists, but it's something like this
I can only make a list depending on the joy they gave me, so there will be some 'shared' places.

Dragon Age: Origins / Knights of the Old Republic
Planescape: Torment / Fallout 2
Mass Effect
Fallout 1 / Jade Empire
NWN2 / KotOR2 (with the restoration mod applied, it was a pain to play the unfinished game where the point of it all was missing.)

And then comes ME2, DA2 and Alpha Protocol (the latter because of the nasty consequence and the developed approval system)

[CRISIS1717]

Nope

If this game is in your top 5 rpgs you've probably only played 5 rpgs anyway.

[Super ._. Shepard]

1. DA:O
2. ME2
3.ME1
4.KOTOR
5.JADE EMPIRE

[Rawgrim]

Ultima 7
Betrayal at Krondor
Might and Magic 6
Baldur`s Gate
Drakensang


Yeah, I know. Pretty old-school.

[moilami]

1. WoW.
2. CoD.
3. NHL11
4. ???
5. DA2.

[FellowerOfOdin]

Mass Effect 2
Geneforge Series
Baldur's Gate 1 + 2
Neverwinter Nights 2
The Witcher

...so....no.

moilami wrote...

1. WoW.
2. CoD.
3. NHL11
4. ???
5. DA2.

I never knew NHL or CoD were RPGs.

Modifié par FellowerOfOdin, 18 mars 2011 - 11:55 .

[Eiia]

Well, DA2 goes on the 'barely worth finishing' list..

My favorite rpg list:
Arcanum
Planescape:Torment
Neverwinter Nights 2: Mask of the Betrayer
Fallout 1-2
Gothic 2: Night of the Raven
honorable mentions: BG2, KotoR 1-2, The Witcher, Vampire tmB, New Vegas.

Modifié par Eiia, 18 mars 2011 - 12:05 .

[Galad22]

Not even near.

Planescape:Torment
Deus Ex
Vampire the Masquarade Bloodlines
Baldur's Gate 2
Witcher

DA2 is one of the most disappointing rpgs I have played along with FF13.

[shyzny]

why are so many people including ME 2? This isn't top 5 gears of war clones lol

[darklordpocky-san]

Shin Megami Tensei Persona 4

Final Fantasy V and IX

Dragon Quest IV and IX

Dark Cloud 2

Demon's Souls

these are just five I like, in no real order. . . DA2 is way too unpolished to make this list, at all.

[AmyBA]

Its very close, high up there, but not quite. Neither DA game has made the cut for my top 5 yet.

In no particular order:

1. Jade Empire
2. Mass Effect 1
3. Mass Effect 2
4. Septerra Core (I am not sure anyone else remembers this game or even liked it, but I can't help but have too many fond memories of it.)
5. Fallout 1


I would say DA:O and DA2 fall into my top 10-15 though.

Eiia wrote...
Arcanum

Arcanum was fun game. I still have my disks for that. XD

Modifié par AmyBA, 18 mars 2011 - 01:32 .

[Imryll]

Zepplin_Rules wrote...

Funny how little you see Ultima, Might and Magic, Dark Sun, Betrayal At Krondor or pretty much any older rpg in these lists...

Well, for me BaK was the first so it's really in its own category. My husband and I played MM7 when we were first married so it's really "out of time" as well. I also have a hard time separating my enjoyment of BaK from the pleasure I took in Feist's novels.

I imagine that many are too young to have played those games, or if they have see them as cultural artifacts rather than as something they encountered when it was new.

So, since those early titles are "incomparable" my personal list is:

Morrowind
Oblivion
...

I loved the BGs, KotOR (except for the mini games), and the NWN expansions and enjoyed DA:O, too, so I owe Bioware gratitude for many hours of enjoyment.

I hope my list will look a little different this time next year.  ;-)

[Stormstrider32]

Baldur's gate 2
Baldur's gate
DA:O
FF VII
Planescape: Torment


DA:2 is a good game but it just doesn't have the quality.  I hate exploring the same places again and again each act.  Not to mention cookie-cutter dungeons. I really hated going to character's homes separately too.

Modifié par Stormstrider32, 18 mars 2011 - 12:46 .

[Magi_the_Solona]

  I do not suppose i can not count to 5.  But,there is something i know well  is that my list will begin with Witcher 2.
Second might be DA 2. 

[WasGTIguy]

Oblivion
Diablo 2 LOD
Fallout 3-NV
Mass Effect series
DA:O
Two Worlds 2
DA:2

No real order

Modifié par WasGTIguy, 18 mars 2011 - 12:53 .

[bill4747bill]

My Top five is tough

Vampire Bloodlines and Dragon Age Origins tied for first place
Planescape Torment
Baldur's Gate 2
Neverwinter Nights 2



Very difficult to decide though. There were some oldie but goodies too.
 Hard for me to rate Pool of Radiance....it is so old and so long ago

[bill4747bill]

Imryll wrote...

Zepplin_Rules wrote...

Funny how little you see Ultima, Might and Magic, Dark Sun, Betrayal At Krondor or pretty much any older rpg in these lists...

Well, for me BaK was the first so it's really in its own category. My husband and I played MM7 when we were first married so it's really "out of time" as well. I also have a hard time separating my enjoyment of BaK from the pleasure I took in Feist's novels.

I imagine that many are too young to have played those games, or if they have see them as cultural artifacts rather than as something they encountered when it was new.

So, since those early titles are "incomparable" my personal list is:

Morrowind
Oblivion
...

I loved the BGs, KotOR (except for the mini games), and the NWN expansions and enjoyed DA:O, too, so I owe Bioware gratitude for many hours of enjoyment.

I hope my list will look a little different this time next year.  ;-)

The old games like Ultima/Mightmagic/wizardry/Dark Sun/krondor/bardstale and all the ones I am overlooking I remember fondly, but have not played them in so many years I had to choose more recent games.

[Annarl]

No, its not in the top five. It's not in the top 10
1 Baldur's Gate
2 KOTOR
3 Mass Effect
4 DA:O
5 The Witcher
6 Morrowind
7 Oblivion
8 Mass Effect 2
9 FF 7 (and I love FF 8 I'll put them together)
10 Fallout New Vegas
11 Fallout 3
and then the NWN series.  So its far down my list of best.  And I enjoyed the game.  I just didn't love it.

Edit: I forgot the The Witcher:D

Modifié par omearaee, 18 mars 2011 - 01:31 .

[AmyBA]

Zepplin_Rules wrote...

Funny how little you see Ultima, Might and Magic, Dark Sun, Betrayal At Krondor or pretty much any older rpg in these lists...

I remember most of those games fondly, minus Dark Sun which I actually have never played.

I think my main reason for not adding any of them in my top 5 is because I usually also consider games I've played and replayed many times over and have yet to tire of.

Most of the Ultima games I played no more than once or twice, same with Might and Magic, though I still enjoyed them. But I also havent revisted them in a very long time. Betrayal at Krondor is a game I replayed more then twice to be sure, but again, its been awhile since my last go at, was probably around 1998 when the not as good sequel, Return to Krondor came out.

[Shazzie]

I don't really list my faves in order, but, no. It's definitely not in my 'The Best RPGs' category, nor is it in the 'Damn Good RPGs' category. It might find itself in 'Pretty Good'.

I could go into far too much detail as to why, but DA2 is proving to be a game somewhere between 'love to hate' and 'hate to love', with a lot of 'terrible disappointment and aggravation' thrown in. There's so many parts I think are fantastic, and parts I feel are improvements, and yet there are so very very many parts that are seriously terrible to me.

[Shazzie]

I don't really list my faves in order, but, no. It's definitely not in my 'The Best RPGs' category, nor is it in the 'Damn Good RPGs' category. It might find itself in 'Pretty Good'.

I could go into far too much detail as to why, but DA2 is proving to be a game somewhere between 'love to hate' and 'hate to love', with a lot of 'terrible disappointment and aggravation' thrown in. There's so many parts I think are fantastic, and parts I feel are improvements, and yet there are so very very many parts that are seriously terrible to me.