Sharn01 wrote...
elimccl wrote...
Sharn01 wrote...
Your basing this theory on what though, the sexual habits of people in the modern day United States? For all we know bisexuality may be a frequent occurence in Thedas, the average person, human, already has lots of other things to hate on, elves, mages, qunari, non andrastians, maybe bisexuality and even homosexuality just ducked under the hate radar with the citizenry having so many other things to hate.
Part of telling a story is understanding the perspectives of your audience. If you make things too alien, you achieve disconnect. There's a careful balance between introducing fantastic elements and outright denying conventional logic. I'm not saying they can't all be bisexual in their world, or even ours. Yet, if you do that, you're obviously going to have confused players, or players who simply can't take it seriously because, yes, that's how it works in reality. Generally, the more alien you make characters to real people, the greater the empathetic distance there is. Again, there are obviously bisexuals in reality, but they aren't exactly flying out of the woodwork. It seems obvious to me that it was a design decision, not a writing decision. That's the main problem.
So your unhappy that they didnt make Fenris and Merrill completely gay and add two more companions or more that where straight LI? In seriousness I do understand where you are coming from, but its a really small cast, your choices would be no choice if they cut anyone. I havent even had a game where Isabella for example hasnt left the party permanently yet, and I wouldnt romance her even if she did return. I dont see any character defining qualities that show that Merrill or Fenris couldnt be gay or bi, and most of the argueing isnt about that they can be gay or bi, its seems a lot of people dont want to be exposed to it at all.
Be careful about lumping everyone that voices a complaint or concern about it as simply being homophobic.
Yes, having an option for everyone would not have been feasible given the small cast. Again, you don't need an option for everyone. If the characters you create are all hetereo, this is fine. If one is gay, and the rest are hetero, fine. If all are gay, you're getting into "wait, what?" territory, but so long as it fits within their characterization, it's fine.
Mentioning how you see nothing in their character defining their sexuality is also an important point. Their sexuality doesn't matter within the context of the story. The only reason it exists is because of the seemingly forced romance options. It feels very stapled on, rather than a natural progression of events. Again, it feels designed, not a result of the storytelling. Design should reinforce those elements, not necessitate them.
Also, I'm aware they "switch sexual preferences" rather than actually being bisexual. Although, that's not a distinction I take seriously. Sexuality isn't a switch you can flip on or off and have it not affect your entire character. It only serves to prove my point that the romance option and the characters' sexuality is completely artificial.
I'm not even mentioning this because I was disappointed with it. I didn't care about the romance subplot in DA2, at all. It felt very mechanical and hollow to me. The numerous bugs didn't help. I only mention this because the issue is raised, and many people seem to be having trouble articulating the response they felt while playing the game.