83 réponses à ce sujet

[Johnsen1972]

For me it looks like:

DAO: 9/10
DA Awakening: 7/10
DA2: 5/10
ME1: 8/10
ME2: 9/10
BG1: 8/10
BG2: 9/10
KOTOR: 9/10
NWN: 8/10
Jade Empire: Not played
MDK2: 7/10
Sonic Cronicles: not played
Shattered Steel: not played

[MrDizazta]

Jade Empire: 8/10
Mass Effect: 9/10
Mass Effect 2: 10/10
Dragon Age Origins: 8.5/10 (played on the 360; wished play it on PC)
Dragon Age Origins: Awakening: 7/10
Dragon Age 2: 6/10 (enjoyable, but some sh!t doesn't set well with me)

[Dominus]

DAO: 8/10 - I played the console version, so...
DA Awakening: Not played
DA2: 8/10 - I played the PC version, so...(kidding)
ME1: 9.3/10 - Where it all started.
ME2: 9.5/10 - Improve what already rocked.
BG1: Not played
BG2: Not played
KOTOR: Never finished
NWN: 8/10 - I remember summoning a badger in that game once... so +8 points.
Jade Empire: 8/10 - Ambitious.
MDK2: 7/10 - Downright silly The ship sounds an awful like elcors...
Sonic Cronicles: not played
Shattered Steel: not played, but do have the demo, will eventually give it a go.

Modifié par DominusVita, 25 mars 2011 - 03:33 .

[Johnsen1972]

Metacritics of Bioware games

Mass Effect 2 (2010) - 96
Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn (2000) - 95
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic (2003 )- 93
Baldur's Gate (1998) - 91
Neverwinter Nights (2002) - 91
Mass Effect (2007) - 91
Dragon Age: Origins (2009) - 91
Jade Empire (2005) - 89
MDK2 (2000) - 83
Dragon Age II (2011) - 82
Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood (2008) - 74
Shattered Steel: NA

www.metacritics.com

Modifié par Johnsen1972, 25 mars 2011 - 03:47 .

[MaaZeus]

My rating from 1-10 where 5 is average.

Mass Effect - 8
Mass Effect 2 - 9
Dragon Age Origins - 9
Dragon Age II - 7
Baldurs Gate II + Tob - 10
KOTOR - 8

Modifié par MaaZeus, 25 mars 2011 - 05:21 .

[TheMufflon]

Score out of 10, in chronological order:

Baldur's Gate: 7
Tales of the Sword Coast: 5
Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn: 10
Throne of Bhaal: 8
Neverwinter Nights: 5
The Aurora Toolset: 10
Shadows of Undertide: 5
Hordes of the Underdark: 6
Knights of the Old Republic: 6
Jade Empire: 5
Mass Effect: 7
Mass Effect 2: 8
Dragon Age: Origins: 9
Dragon Age: Awakening: 6
Dragon Age 2: 9

[RainyDayLover]

KotOR - 9.8/10
Mass Effect - 9.6/10
Mass Effect 2 - 9.9/10
Dragon Age: Origins - 9.5/10
Dragon Age 2 - 8/10

[Akulakhan]

BG 8/10
BG2 9/10
Jade Empire 5.5/10
KotOR 7/10
Mass Effect 7.5/10
Mass Effect 2 7/10
DAO 8/10
DA2 3/10

[Herr Sovereign]

KotOR - 9.7
Mass Effect - 9.7
Dragon Age: Origins - 9.0
Mass Effect 2 - 9.8
Dragon Age 2 - 8.7

Modifié par Herr Sovereign, 25 mars 2011 - 05:28 .

[Nameless one7]

MDK2: Not Played
Shattered Steel: Not Played
Sonic Chronicles: 6/10
NWN Nights: 8/10
NWN Shadows of Undertide: Not Played
NWN Hordes of Underdark: 9/10
BG1: 8/10
BG2: 10/10
BG2 Throne of Bhaal: 9/10
Knights of the Old Republic: 10/10
Jade Empire: 9.5/10
Mass Effect: 9.5/10
Mass Effect 2: 9/10
Dragon Age Origins: 9.5/10
Dragon Age Awakening: 8.5/10
Dragon Age 2: 9/10

[Merci357]

Baldur's Gate 7/10
(Tales of the Sword Coast 4/10)
Baldur's Gate 2 10/10
(Throne of Baal 9/10)
Neverwinter Nights 5/10
(Shadows of Undrentide 6/10)
(Hordes of the Underdark 7/10)
Knights of the Old Republic 9/10
Jade Empire 5/10
Mass Effect 8/10
Dragon Age: Origins 9/10
(Awakening 7/10)
Mass Effect 2 9/10
Dragon Age 2 7/10

In short, some are amazing, some are decent. To be honest, the older games (everything before JE, I guess) get a huge bonus, if I had to play and rate them today, they'd all lose points.

Never played Shattered Steel, MDK 2 or Sonic Chronicles.

[ObserverStatus]

KotOR 98
Mass Effect 95
Dragon Age Origin 90
Mass Effect 2 88
Dragon Age 2 83

I like where this trend is going

[MJRick]

Knights of the Old Republic 10/10
Jade Empire 10/10
Mass Effect 8.5/10
Dragon Age: Origins 6.5/10
Mass Effect 2 10/10
Dragon Age 2 9.2/10

[Johnsen1972]

Merci357 wrote...

In short, some are amazing, some are decent. To be honest, the older games (everything before JE, I guess) get a huge bonus, if I had to play and rate them today, they'd all lose points.

Never played Shattered Steel, MDK 2 or Sonic Chronicles.

surely I wouldnt play MDK2 or BG again and enjoy it. But at the time when it was released it was an awesome game and thats what counts.

Modifié par Johnsen1972, 25 mars 2011 - 06:13 .

[caradoc2000]

Jade Empire: 9.5
DAO, DA2: 9.2
KotOR: 9.0
NWN: 8.5
Mass Effect: 8.3
Baldur's Gates: 8.0
Mass Effect 2: 5.0

[Drake Sigar]

Baldur’s Gate 2 – 9.5
Baldur’s Gate – 9
KotoR – 9
Mass Effect – 8
Dragon Age Origins – 8
Neverwinter Nights – 7
Jade Empire - 6

I won't bother rating the expansions.

[Kronner]

BG 7/10
BG2 8/10
Jade Empire 5/10
KotOR 7/10
Neverwinter Nights 6/10
Mass Effect 9/10
Mass Effect 2 9/10
Dragon Age: Origins 8/10
Dragon Age 2 7/10

[Ponce de Leon]

Based from 0-100 scores :

Baldur's Gate 1 - 84/100
MDK2 - 80/100
Baldur's Gate 2 - 94/100
Neverwinter Nights - 70/100
Knights of the Old Republic - 90/100
Mass Effect - 91/100
Dragon Age : Origins - 88/100
Mass Effect 2 - 93/100
Dragon Age 2 - 76/100

Edit : forgot KotOR... 

Modifié par dark-lauron, 25 mars 2011 - 06:57 .

[B3taMaxxx]

Mass Effect                 -9.75
Mass Effect 2              -8.75
Dragon Age: Origins    -8.5
Dragon Age 2              -9.0
KOTOR                        -8.75
Jade Empire                -8.0

Modifié par B3taMaxxx, 25 mars 2011 - 07:15 .

[Moondoggie]

DAO: 9/10
DA Awakening: 6/10
DA2: 7/10
ME1: 7/10
ME2: 8/10
BG1: 7/10
BG2: 9/10
KOTOR: 7/10
NWN: 5/10
Jade Empire: 3/10
MDK2: 5/10
Sonic Cronicles: 5/10
Shattered Steel: 6/10

[Druss99]

KOTOR: 9/10
DAO: 7/10
DA2: 8.5/10
ME: 9/10
ME2: 10/10
Jade Empire: 5/10
BG2: 9/10

[slimgrin]

ME1: 8.5/10
ME2: 8/10
DA: 7.5/10

In short: ME1 would recieve a 10 if it weren't due to inferior gameplay/controls, and would be my all around highest rated Bioware game.

ME2 would have gotten a 9 if it had a story on par with ME1, more abilities/inventory, and less linear level design.

DA:O would have gotten an 8.5 if it had less generic lore and fewer overlapping abilities.


I find it surprisingly hard to rate these games.

Modifié par slimgrin, 25 mars 2011 - 08:02 .

[Jonp382]

Baldur's Gate: Tales of the Swordcoast 9/10
Baldur's Gate 2: Shadow of Amn 8/10
Baldur's Gate 2: Throne of Bhaal 6/10
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 9/10
Jade Empire 7/10
Mass Effect 5/10
Dragon Age: Origins 9/10
Mass Effect 2 2/10
Dragon Age: Origins - Awakening 6/10
Dragon Age 2 4/10

I've got Neverwinter Nights and the expansions, but never really played them.